61 assisted living facilities in Shirley, NY have costs between $1,550 to $10,700, have input from 2,911 reviews, and 81% have photos. Seniors in assisted living would appreciate Shirley, New York for its combination of community resources and serene environment conducive to an active lifestyle. The city is home to the Suffolk County Senior Center, which offers a variety of programs and services tailored for older adults, including educational workshops, social activities, and fitness classes. Nearby, the Forge River is perfect for gentle walks or birdwatching, providing a peaceful backdrop for residents. Additionally, local parks like the William Floyd Estate allow seniors to enjoy nature while engaging in organized events that foster connection and engagement with their peers.
Brookhaven Town House For Adults in Brookhaven, NY offers comfortable assisted living with 24-hour supervision and a range of amenities but may lack personalized attention or flexibility in care for individual needs.
Beautiful Environment
The Chelsea at Brookhaven
4.3 from 55 reviews
#2 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$3,300 to $5,250 per month
The Chelsea at Brookhaven offers a clean, beautifully decorated environment with caring staff and engaging activities for residents, but it faces challenges with medication errors and high costs that potential families should consider.
South Bay Adult Home
5.0 from 2 reviews
#3 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$3,000 to $6,000 per month
South Bay Adult Home in Center Moriches, NY offers a variety of amenities and specialized care services, including diabetic support and medication management, but lacks extensive on-site spiritual activities and may limit residents' independence.
New Brookhaven Town House
1.0 from 1 review
#4 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$1,550 to $2,800 per month
The review highlights alarming neglect and isolation at a care facility, with staff exhibiting blatant disregard for residents' well-being, making it a cautionary tale for anyone considering such establishments.
Great Staff
Village Walk at Patchogue
4.4 from 124 reviews
#5 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$5,145 to $7,715 per month
Village Walk at Patchogue offers a friendly atmosphere with engaging activities and affordable options, but prospective residents should be aware of varying dining experiences, inconsistent cleanliness, and staffing challenges that could impact care quality.
Personalized Care
Village Walk
4.4 from 87 reviews
#6 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Village Walk at Patchogue is a well-reviewed senior living community praised for its cleanliness, personalized care, vibrant location with convenient amenities, and ample activities, though some critiques mention neighborhood safety and an institutional atmosphere.
Great Staff
The Bristal at Holtsville
4.6 from 124 reviews
#7 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$4,400 to $8,100 per month
The Bristal at Holtsville is highly regarded for its clean, welcoming environment; friendly staff; various engaging activities; and convenient amenities, making it a desirable choice for families seeking supportive assisted living options.
The Bristal At Holtsville
4.7 from 60 reviews
#8 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
The Bristal At Holtsville offers a range of assisted living options and amenities but might lack the personalized attention some residents may desire due to its focus on providing a variety of services and activities.
Great Food
McPeaks Assisted Living Nursing Home
4.3 from 18 reviews
#9 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
McPeak's Assisted Living offers a warm, home-like environment with personalized care, engaging activities, and responsive staff, making it an appealing choice for families seeking supportive housing for their loved ones.
Great Staff
Sunrise of Holbrook
4.4 from 84 reviews
#10 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$3,600 to $8,190 per month
Sunrise of Holbrook is praised for its welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and engaging activities, but potential residents should consider mixed reviews on dining variety and cleanliness, alongside concerns about staffing levels and management responsiveness.
McPeak's Adult Home
4.4 from 7 reviews
#11 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$2,500 to $3,750 per month
McPeak's Adult Home in Patchogue provides a warm environment with quality care, engaging activities, and convenient access to amenities, but residents may face limitations with off-site devotional services and reliance on nearby medical facilities.
Friendly Staff
All American Assisted Living at Coram
4.5 from 62 reviews
#12 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$3,950 to $7,920 per month
All American Assisted Living at Coram is praised for its warm atmosphere, compassionate staff, diverse activities that promote socialization and engagement, and well-maintained living spaces, making it a strong option for families seeking assisted living solutions.
New Facility
Brightview Sayville
4.5 from 105 reviews
#13 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Brightview Sayville is a well-designed senior living community that offers comprehensive care, a supportive and attentive staff, modern amenities, inviting aesthetics, and high-quality dining options in a warm, community-oriented environment.
Cleanliness
Braemar Living at Medford
3.6 from 30 reviews
#14 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$4,100 to $4,700 per month
When choosing an assisted living facility, families should prioritize care options, cleanliness, staff responsiveness, financial considerations, and the overall community atmosphere to ensure their loved one's well-being and satisfaction.
Gables Home For Adults
4.6 from 72 reviews
#15 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Gables Home For Adults in Patchogue, NY offers a fully furnished assisted living community with amenities like 24-hour supervision and medication management, but may lack more specialized care services and diverse activities.
Friendly Staff
The Bristal At Sayville
4.8 from 86 reviews
#16 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$4,800 to $9,600 per month
The Bristal at Sayville offers a warm community atmosphere with engaged staff and positive social interactions, alongside a pleasing environment that supports residents? emotional well-being and safety.
Great Activities
The Villa At Westhampton
3.9 from 36 reviews
#17 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$4,100 to $8,100 per month
The Villa at Westhampton offers modern amenities, a welcoming atmosphere, and engaging activities for residents, although some reviewers have raised concerns about care quality in certain areas.
Friendly Staff
The Arbors at Bohemia
4.6 from 113 reviews
#18 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$3,700 to $6,800 per month
The Arbors at Bohemia is highly recommended for its friendly, attentive staff, clean environment, engaging daily activities, and overall warm atmosphere that ensures residents feel cared for and valued.
Brightview Port Jefferson
4.4 from 56 reviews
#19 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Brightview Port Jefferson in Port Jefferson Station, NY offers a range of assisted living services with amenities like furnished apartments and 24-hour supervision, but potential downsides include reliance on staff for daily activities and limited independence.
Friendly Staff
The Bristal At Lake Grove
4.5 from 111 reviews
#20 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$4,900 to $8,200 per month
The Bristal at Lake Grove offers a vibrant, engaging environment with compassionate staff, a beautiful facility, and a variety of activities that foster resident satisfaction and a strong sense of community.
Great Food
Atria South Setauket
4.3 from 109 reviews
#21 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$3,695 to $5,395 per month
Atria South Setauket is praised for its caring staff, affordable rates, good food, and engaging activities, but prospective residents should be aware of potential operational challenges and communication issues with management before making a decision.
Cleanliness
The Lake Shore Assisted Living Residence
4.2 from 78 reviews
#22 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$2,500 to $4,500 per month
Lake Shore Assisted Living Residence features attractive renovations and friendly staff but has notable concerns regarding food quality, safety protocols, and administrative responsiveness that potential residents should consider.
Community Environment
Amber Court of Smithtown
4.6 from 105 reviews
#23 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$4,600 to $6,600 per month
Amber Court of Smithtown is highly praised for its dedicated staff, clean and comfortable living conditions, diverse amenities, and engaging activities that foster a vibrant community atmosphere for residents.
Hidden Gem Home for Adults
4.0 from 8 reviews
#24 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$2,250 per month
Our assisted living community in Lake Ronkonkoma, NY, offers personalized care services, peaceful surroundings, and easy access to amenities but may lack extensive on-site spiritual activities.
Olsen Rest
5.0 from 7 reviews
#25 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Olsen Rest in Nesconset, NY offers a warm assisted living environment with comfortable accommodations and 24-hour supervision, but it may have limited options for solitary activities beyond the small library.
Great Dining
Jefferson's Ferry
4.4 from 11 reviews
#26 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$6,570 to $7,980 per month
Jefferson's Ferry offers a range of services and amenities in a welcoming atmosphere with attentive staff, but high costs and occasional facility maintenance issues may deter prospective residents seeking affordable assisted living options.
Maple Rest
4.8 from 31 reviews
#27 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Maple Rest in West Sayville, NY provides a welcoming assisted living community with various amenities and 24-hour care services, but residents may have limited privacy due to the shared living arrangements and communal activities.
Friendly Staff
Olsen Rest Home
4.1 from 28 reviews
#28 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$3,000 per month
Olsen Rest Home offers a cozy, home-like atmosphere with friendly staff and enjoyable dining experiences, though it has been noted that activity options could be improved and medication management requires attention.
Caring Staff
Sunrise of East Setauket
4.3 from 67 reviews
#29 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$6,240 to $9,510 per month
Sunrise of East Setauket is praised for its intimate atmosphere, attentive and compassionate staff, and nutritious dining options, though some families noted concerns about communication and engagement activities.
Woodhaven Home For Adults
2.9 from 23 reviews
#30 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Woodhaven Home for Adults combines a warm, welcoming atmosphere with attentive care, active community engagement through gardening and activities, affordable Medicaid support, and a focus on cleanliness, making it an appealing choice for those seeking assisted living options.
Woodhaven Adult Home
2.5 from 17 reviews
#31 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$5,350 to $10,700 per month
Woodhaven Adult Home raises concerns about resident safety due to inadequate security measures and insufficient supervision, despite having friendly staff.
Friendly Staff
The Arbors at Islandia - East and West
4.2 from 103 reviews
#32 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$3,700 to $5,600 per month
The Arbors at Islandia is well-regarded for its friendly atmosphere, excellent communication, engaging daily activities, and high-quality meals, though some areas like meal service efficiency and specific health-related services could be improved.
Ridge Rest Home
1.0 from 1 review
#33 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Ridge Rest Home in Ridge, NY provides a vibrant assisted living community with numerous amenities and services for seniors, but may lack some privacy and personalized care aspects that some residents might seek.
Social Interaction
Sunrise of Smithtown
4.3 from 72 reviews
#34 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$6,870 to $9,390 per month
Sunrise of Smithtown is highly regarded for its compassionate staff, warm atmosphere, and community-focused activities, though some reviews note concerns about room conditions, pricing, and occasional understaffing.
Great Activities
The Arbors At Islandia West
4.0 from 84 reviews
#35 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
The Arbors at Islandia East offers spacious apartments, excellent and caring staff, and a variety of engaging activities in a clean and welcoming environment, though its busy location and limited outdoor spaces may be drawbacks.
Echo Arms Adult Home
3.3 from 12 reviews
#36 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Echo Arms Adult Home in Port Jefferson Station, NY, offers temporary respite care and a range of amenities, but potential residents should consider the limited recreational facilities and location-dependent access to healthcare services.
Great Staff
Whisper Woods of Smithtown
4.7 from 79 reviews
#37 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$4,550 to $6,650 per month
Whisper Woods of Smithtown is a highly regarded assisted living facility known for its attentive and dedicated staff, beautiful environment, engaging activities, and strong sense of community, making it a comforting choice for families seeking quality care for their loved ones.
The Arbors At Islandia East
3.9 from 40 reviews
#38 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
The Arbors At Islandia East in Islandia, NY is an assisted living community providing specialized memory care, respite care, and a range of amenities for residents including dining services, recreational activities, 24-hour support, and convenient access to nearby amenities.
Friendly Staff
The Arbors at Hauppauge
4.3 from 95 reviews
#39 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$3,600 to $5,600 per month
The Arbors at Hauppauge is praised for its nurturing staff, engaging social activities, inclusive atmosphere, and strong resident relationships, making it an excellent choice for assisted living.
Wittridge Home For Adults
4.0 from 8 reviews
#40 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Wittridge Home For Adults in Ronkonkoma, NY, offers a cozy assisted living environment with personalized care and activities but may have limitations regarding the variety of services and potential space constraints.
Friendly Staff
Atria Bay Shore
4.5 from 94 reviews
#41 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$4,995 to $8,295 per month
Atria Bay Shore is praised for its warm, homelike atmosphere, attentive staff who foster meaningful relationships with residents, and a diverse array of engaging activities that promote social interaction and overall well-being.
Sachem Adult Home
1.8 from 5 reviews
#42 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Sachem Adult Home in Holbrook, NY offers a variety of amenities and care services for seniors, but potential residents should be aware of the need for ongoing supervision and assistance with daily living activities.
Rodden Home
3.7 from 3 reviews
#43 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Rodden Home in Ronkonkoma, NY, offers a fully furnished assisted living community with amenities like cable TV, restaurant-style dining, and 24-hour care but may lack privacy and independence for residents.
Great Activities
The Bristal At East Northport
4.6 from 88 reviews
#44 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
The Bristal Assisted Living in East Northport, NY, offers a luxurious environment with elegant dining, engaging activities, attentive staff, and beautifully maintained facilities that prioritize residents' happiness and well-being.
Amazing Care
Pearl Garden Manor
3.3 from 9 reviews
#45 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$1,600 to $3,200 per month
Families considering assisted living facilities should carefully weigh mixed reviews highlighting both positive experiences with care and management, as well as serious concerns regarding cleanliness, safety, and overall atmosphere.
Friendly Staff
Atria East Northport
4.5 from 85 reviews
#46 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$5,695 to $6,895 per month
Atria East Northport is highly regarded for its attentive and compassionate staff, comfortable accommodations, appealing amenities, and responsive communication with families, though some inconsistency in service quality and meal satisfaction has been noted.
Private Rooms
Gurwin Jewish Fay J. Lindner Residence
4.0 from 42 reviews
#47 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$5,100 to $7,175 per month
Gurwin Jewish - Fay J. Lindner Residences offers a mix of attentive care and personal connection for some residents, but concerns about cleanliness, institutional ambiance, restrictive pandemic policies, and food quality suggest potential drawbacks that families should consider.
Friendly Staff
Birchwood Suites
4.1 from 107 reviews
#48 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$3,500 to $4,000 per month
Birchwood Suites offers a warm and caring environment with attentive staff but faces significant concerns regarding staffing levels, communication, resident engagement activities, and food quality that prospective clients should consider.
Great Staff
Sunrise of Dix Hills
4.4 from 108 reviews
#49 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$2,580 to $6,000 per month
Sunrise of Dix Hills is highly regarded for its caring staff, strong community atmosphere, excellent communication with families, and a variety of engaging activities, although some concerns about food quality and staffing levels have been noted.
Excellent Care
Babylon Beach House
4.4 from 11 reviews
#50 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$2,400 to $7,082 per month
This newly renovated assisted living facility is praised for its warm atmosphere, attentive leadership from Scott and Alice, and genuine care for residents, though it faces challenges with staffing levels.
Missionary Sisters Of St. Benedict
5.0 from 4 reviews
#51 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
The Missionary Sisters Of St. Benedict in Huntington, NY offers a supportive assisted living environment with various amenities and 24/7 care services but may lack certain advanced healthcare facilities nearby.
Babylon Beach House Home For Adults
4.3 from 7 reviews
#52 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Babylon Beach House Home For Adults in Babylon, NY, offers assisted living with amenities like a beauty salon, fitness room, and organized activities, but may lack extensive medical support and specialized programs for residents with complex health needs.
Brentwood Adult Home
5.0 from 1 review
#53 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Brentwood Adult Home provides comfortable assisted living with 24-hour supervision, daily activities, customizable meal options, and convenient access to amenities and medical services, although its location may limit the variety of entertainment options on-site.
Lots Of Activities
Bayview Rest Home
3.3 from 18 reviews
#54 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$2,100 to $4,200 per month
Bayview Rest Home offers an affordable option with some enjoyable activities and a central location, but potential residents should be aware of ongoing issues with staff professionalism, cleanliness, food quality, plumbing problems, and privacy violations.
Bayview Home for Adults
2.7 from 15 reviews
#55 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Bayview Rest Home faces significant criticism for inadequate care, poor maintenance of facilities, plumbing issues, subpar food quality, and insufficiently trained staff, raising serious concerns about the safety and well-being of residents.
Fairlawn Adult Home
3.3 from 3 reviews
#56 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$2,250 per month
Fairlawn Adult Home offers dedicated staff who actively communicate and support residents, but concerns about overcrowded spaces and shared rooms may deter families seeking a more comfortable living environment.
Pleasant Gardens Home For Adults
#57 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Pleasant Gardens Home For Adults offers fully furnished rooms, 24-hour supervision, meal services accommodating dietary restrictions, and a variety of activities, but may lack extensive recreational facilities and private outdoor space.
Heartland on the Bay, Inc.
#58 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
$1,700 to $1,750 per month
Heartland on the Bay in Blue Point, NY offers a supportive assisted living environment with various amenities and convenient access to essential services for seniors, but it may lack extensive on-site recreational facilities and activities.
The Open Gate Association For The Aged
#59 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
The Open Gate Association For the Aged in Bay Shore, NY offers vibrant assisted living with fully furnished apartments, professional chef-prepared meals, 24-hour care services, and convenient access to nearby amenities.
Elmore Home For Adults
#60 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Elmore Home For Adults in Central Islip, NY offers a range of amenities and care services for seniors, but residents may have limited independence and face potential challenges adapting to communal living and sharing spaces.
Harvest Grove
#61 Best reviewed of assisted living in Shirley
Harvest Grove in Lake Grove, NY, while offering a vibrant community and extensive amenities, may lack on-site spiritual services and could be limited in outdoor recreational options for residents.
The Chelsea at Brookhaven offers a clean, beautifully decorated environment with caring staff and engaging activities for residents, but it faces challenges with medication errors and high costs that potential families should consider.
Dogs & Cats
Village Walk at Patchogue
4.4 from 124 reviews
$5,145 to $7,715 per month
Village Walk at Patchogue offers a friendly atmosphere with engaging activities and affordable options, but prospective residents should be aware of varying dining experiences, inconsistent cleanliness, and staffing challenges that could impact care quality.
Dogs & Cats
The Bristal at Holtsville
4.6 from 124 reviews
$4,400 to $8,100 per month
The Bristal at Holtsville is highly regarded for its clean, welcoming environment; friendly staff; various engaging activities; and convenient amenities, making it a desirable choice for families seeking supportive assisted living options.
Dogs & Cats
All American Assisted Living at Coram
4.5 from 62 reviews
$3,950 to $7,920 per month
All American Assisted Living at Coram is praised for its warm atmosphere, compassionate staff, diverse activities that promote socialization and engagement, and well-maintained living spaces, making it a strong option for families seeking assisted living solutions.
Dogs Allowed
Braemar Living at Medford
3.6 from 30 reviews
$4,100 to $4,700 per month
When choosing an assisted living facility, families should prioritize care options, cleanliness, staff responsiveness, financial considerations, and the overall community atmosphere to ensure their loved one's well-being and satisfaction.
Considerations for seniors living in Shirley, NY
Access to quality healthcare: Shirley has several medical facilities and clinics, including Brookhaven Memorial Hospital Medical Center, which offers top-notch medical care to seniors.
Affordable cost of living: The cost of living in Shirley is relatively lower compared to other parts of Long Island and New York City, which can be a significant benefit for seniors on a fixed income.
Proximity to beautiful beaches and parks: Shirley is located close to many beautiful beaches and parks like Fire Island National Seashore, Smith Point County Park, Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge that offer excellent recreational opportunities for seniors.
Wide range of senior-friendly activities: Shirley has many senior centers that offer various activities such as exercise classes, social events, arts and crafts workshops, etc., providing multiple opportunities for seniors to remain active.
Efficient public transportation system: Seniors residing in Shirley have access to efficient public transportation systems like the Suffolk County Transit buses and the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR), making it easy for them to travel around the city without any hassle.
Assisted Living
Memory Care
Skilled Nursing
Independent Living
All Filters
