Atria South Setauket offers competitive pricing for its living accommodations compared to both Suffolk County and New York State averages. For a studio apartment, residents can expect to pay $3,695 per month, which is significantly lower than the county average of $5,129 and the state average of $4,532. Similarly, the 1-bedroom option at Atria is priced at $5,395, aligning closely with the Suffolk County rate of $5,646 while remaining more expensive than New York's average of $4,307. This positioning highlights Atria South Setauket as an attractive choice for those seeking quality senior living options without exceeding their budget.
Floor plans
Atria South Setauket
Suffolk County
New York
Studio
$3,695
$5,129
$4,532
1 Bedroom
$5,395
$5,646
$4,307
Overall Review of Atria South Setauket
common25 reviews mention this
Caring, responsive staff stand out
Residents and families frequently describe staff as attentive, kind, and responsive.
Across the reviews, families emphasize how staff members follow through when something is requested and keep residents’ needs in focus. Several people mention the nursing and wellness teams as welcoming and supportive, and a number of comments highlight smooth move-in help and ongoing communication with family. Even in reviews that mention other issues, residents still commonly get described as being treated with respect and cared for day to day.
common18 reviews mention this
Food gets frequent positive feedback
Dining is consistently described as good, fresh, and satisfying.
Many reviews praise the food and describe it as fresh, plentiful, and enjoyable, with some mentioning daily meal service and menu variety. A few residents specifically talk about liking dining arrangements and the dining room experience. There are also a small number of negative food notes, including complaints that quality declined or that certain meals were not good for the price.
caveat12 reviews mention this
Activities are a mixed picture
Activities can be engaging, but some residents and families report limits.
On the positive side, reviews commonly mention ongoing activities like bingo, music, movies, trips, and religious or devotional events, with some people saying their loved ones stay busy. At the same time, several reviewers report that schedules repeat too much, appeal is limited, or activities are canceled or constrained. A few comments also connect activity access to logistics such as sign-ups or crowd limits.
caveat2 reviews mention this
No memory care for dementia needs
The reviews indicate this community does not offer a memory care program.
Two different reviewers describe that their loved one needed memory care or more hands-on support for dementia, and that Atria South Setauket was not the right fit. One family said they had to move after a short stay because memory care wasn’t available. Another review similarly points out that the community lacked memory care for their situation.
differentiator6 reviews mention this
Pricing is often framed as better value
Many families choose this community for affordability versus similar options.
Several reviews highlight affordability compared with other communities they toured and describe getting a fair deal for the services included. Some families also mention promotional timing and the peace of mind that came from clearer expectations around pricing and fees. Still, other reviewers raise concerns about rent increases, additional charges for higher levels of care, or needing to read fine print before signing.
caveat8 reviews mention this
Older building layout has drawbacks
The older hotel-style building and layout are a recurring concern in some reviews.
A number of reviewers describe the property as an older facility, with comments about narrow hallways, limited natural light in some rooms, and an elevator that can feel tight. Dining location also comes up negatively in some tours and visits, including descriptions of the dining room being underground and feeling unpleasant. Other reviews still say the rooms are clean and updated, but the layout and building feel are not consistent across experiences.
How we summarize
Counts show how many written reviews mention each theme; a review can touch several themes, and only frequently mentioned themes become a section.
Features
Housing
200 resident community capacity
Studio apartments
Types of Care
Assisted Living
Independent Living
Skilled Nursing Facility
Pets
Cats allowed
Dogs allowed
Amenities
Activities off-site
Activities on-site
Air-conditioning
Beautician on-site
Beauty salon
Cable or satellite TV
Computer center
Devotional services off-site
Dining room
Fitness room
Full kitchen
Fully furnished
Gaming room
Garden
Guest parking
Housekeeping services
Indoor common areas
Kitchenette
Laundry
Move-in coordination
Outdoor common areas
Outdoor space
Pet friendly
Private bathrooms
Resident parking
Respite or short term stays offered
Restaurant-style dining
Small library
Spa
Swimming pool
Swimming pool / hot tub
Telephone
VA Benefits Consultation
Wellness center
Wi-Fi/high-speed internet available
Transportation
Long Island - MacArthur (8 miles away)
Community operated transportation
Transportation & parking
Transportation arrangement
Transportation arrangement (non-medical)
Care Services
12-16 hour nursing
24-hour call system
24-hour supervision
Activities of daily living assistance
Ambulatory care
Assistance with bathing
Assistance with dressing
Assistance with transfers
Diabetes diet
Hospice waiver
Incontinence care
Meal preparation and service
Medication management
Mental wellness program
Physical therapy
Special dietary restrictions
Transportation to doctors appointments
Dining
Diabetes diet
Meals provided
Professional chef
Special dietary restrictions
Activities
Activities off-site
Activities on-site
Community-sponsored activities
Concierge services
Devotional activities offsite
Fitness programs
Planned day trips
Religious services
Resident-run activities
Scheduled daily activities
Languages Spoken
English
Nearby Places of Interest
This part of South Setauket, New York, offers a convenient and well-equipped neighborhood for senior living. With multiple CVS Pharmacies nearby, accessing medication and healthcare supplies is easily manageable. The area also boasts a selection of reputable physicians and medical facilities such as All Island Behavioral Health and University Surgical Center for any healthcare needs. For leisure activities, there are several parks like Selden Dog Park and Heritage Park where seniors can enjoy outdoor recreation. Dining options range from fast food chains like McDonald's to sit-down restaurants like Chili's Grill & Bar. In terms of healthcare, facilities such as John T Mather Memorial Hospital and St Charles Hospital are within reach. Additionally, transportation options like Suffolk Transportation Coram and LIRR - Ronkonkoma Station provide easy access to other parts of Long Island for further exploration and convenience.
Atria South Setauket offers competitive pricing for its living accommodations compared to both Suffolk County and New York State averages. For a studio apartment, residents can expect to pay $3,695 per month, which is significantly lower than the county average of $5,129 and the state average of $4,532. Similarly, the 1-bedroom option at Atria is priced at $5,395, aligning closely with the Suffolk County rate of $5,646 while remaining more expensive than New York's average of $4,307. This positioning highlights Atria South Setauket as an attractive choice for those seeking quality senior living options without exceeding their budget.
Atria South Setauket on seniors.fyi includes 19 photos including images showing interior, floor plan, dining, decor, bedroom, chandelier, studio apartment, architecture, and more.
Nearby Communities
Jefferson's Ferry
Centereach, NY
Wide range of amenities and 24/7 care services
Jefferson's Ferry Lifecare Retirement
South Setauket, NY
4.6 from 77 reviews
$2,416 to $3,377 / month
Competitive pricing for the area with comprehensive amenities and pet-friendly policies.
Jefferson's Ferry
South Setauket, NY
4.4 from 11 reviews
$6,570 to $7,980 / month
Quality care with friendly staff, spacious modern apartments, and a wide range of amenities and activities.
The article compares assisted living and skilled nursing facilities, detailing their differing levels of assistance, medical support, cost structures, and day-to-day experiences. It emphasizes that assisted living is for those needing help with daily activities while maintaining independence, whereas skilled nursing facilities provide intensive medical care with 24-hour staff supervision.
The transition from assisted living to skilled nursing care is often prompted by complex medical needs that assisted living cannot meet, with key indicators including frequent health declines, increased falls, severe memory issues, and caregiver burnout. Families should recognize these signs early to discuss options with healthcare providers and prepare for the emotional and logistical aspects of moving to a facility that offers comprehensive medical support.
Vibrant Senior Living emphasizes active senior living communities that promote independence and engagement through diverse amenities and activities, fostering wellness and social interaction among older adults. These communities range from independent to assisted living, with a focus on personal growth, family involvement, financial planning, and leveraging technology to enhance residents' experiences.
Atria South Setauket photos
×
Interior
Decor
Living Room
Building
Architecture
Bedroom
Dining
Landscaping
Seating Area
Fireplace
Floor Plan
Outdoor
Lobby
Chandelier
Interior
Decor
Bedroom
Dining
Living Room and Fireplace
Landscaping and Flag
Floor Plan and Studio Apartment
Building
Architecture
Chandelier
Seating Area and Piano
Outdoor and Swimming Pool
Entrance
Lobby
Wall Art
Parking
Lounge
Kitchenette
Home Interior
Table Settings
Get PricingAsk A QuestionSchedule A TourContact Senior Advisor
By clicking submit, you agree to our Partner's Terms of Use. You
also consent to receive calls and texts, which may be autodialed, from our Partner. Your consent is not a condition to
using our Partner's service. Please visit our Partner's Privacy Policy for information about their privacy practices.
200 resident community capacity
Studio apartments
Assisted Living
Independent Living
Skilled Nursing Facility
Cats allowed
Dogs allowed
Activities off-site
Air-conditioning
Beautician on-site
Cable or satellite TV
Computer center
Devotional services off-site
Dining room
Fitness room
Full kitchen
Fully furnished
Gaming room
Garden
Guest parking
Housekeeping services
Indoor common areas
Laundry
Move-in coordination
Outdoor common areas
Pet friendly
Private bathrooms
Respite or short term stays offered
Restaurant-style dining
Small library
Spa
Swimming pool
Telephone
VA Benefits Consultation
Wi-Fi/high-speed internet available
Long Island - MacArthur (8 miles away)
Community operated transportation
12-16 hour nursing
24-hour call system
Ambulatory care
Assistance with bathing
Assistance with dressing
Assistance with transfers
Diabetes diet
Hospice waiver
Incontinence care
Medication management
Mental wellness program
Physical therapy
Special dietary restrictions
Concierge services
Planned day trips
English
Wide range of amenities and 24/7 care services
Exploring the Contrasts Between Assisted Living and Skilled Nursing
8 Key Indicators That Suggest It May Be Time to Transition from Assisted Living to Skilled Nursing Care
Vibrant Senior Living: A Comprehensive Guide for Active Older Adults
