Cabot Cove in Hilliard, OH

Information last verified:

5535 Cabot Cove Drive, Hilliard, OH 43026

For more information about senior living options: (844) 490-3973

4.2 from 111 reviews
5 stars
76
4 stars
13
3 stars
3
2 stars
1
1 stars
18

Cabot Cove Costs & Pricing

Cabot Cove stands out as an exceptionally affordable housing option compared to both Madison County and the broader Ohio region. For instance, a two-bedroom unit in Cabot Cove is priced at just $649 per month, a stark contrast to the $3,215 charged in Madison County and the $3,501 average across Ohio. Similarly, studio apartments in Cabot Cove are available for $684, significantly lower than the $3,738 typical in Madison County and closely aligned with the Ohio average of $3,727. These figures highlight not only the cost-effective living options within Cabot Cove but also suggest a unique opportunity for residents seeking quality accommodations without the hefty price tag prevalent in surrounding areas.

Floor plansCabot CoveMadison CountyOhio
2 Bedrooms$649$3,215$3,501
Studio$684$3,738$3,727

Overall Review of Cabot Cove

Pros

  • pro The maintenance technician was kind, efficient, and fixed the issue the same day.
  • pro The office staff are friendly and very helpful.
  • pro The location is nice and quiet, and the service is excellent.
  • pro Tammy went above and beyond assisting residents with their issues.
  • pro The apartments are beautiful, clean, and well maintained.
  • pro The move-in process is smooth thanks to professional leasing staff.
  • pro The maintenance team is responsive and fixes issues promptly.

Cons

  • pro The grounds are disgusting, with trash everywhere and dumpsters overflowing.
  • pro Maintenance is completely unreliable and issues go unfixed for months.
  • pro The management doesn’t enforce rules and is generally incompetent.
  • pro The complex is infested with roaches in a majority of buildings.
  • pro The area feels unsafe, with past violence and car break-ins.
  • pro Noise from neighbors is constant and unsolved by management.
  • pro Mold and water damage persist due to neglect.
  • pro The complex has declined significantly over time and is no longer nice.
  • pro Office communication is poor and follow-up is rare.

Review

Cabot Cove in Hilliard, Ohio is a community best suited for renters who prize curb appeal, a quiet residential feel, and responsive on-site management for day-to-day needs. When the sun is out, the grounds present a pleasant, walkable environment, with residents citing beauty, ample space, and a generally friendly office crew as major strengths. The property can feel calm and neighborly, and some tenants highlight easy moves in and strong maintenance responsiveness for straightforward issues. This is attractive for households that want an attractive campus vibe, where leasing staff can be helpful, and where pets are accommodated without friction. However, potential residents should come in with eyes wide open about inconsistencies in maintenance, safety, and pest control, because those gaps can quickly overwhelm the positives if left unaddressed.

Those considering alternatives should pay close attention to three red flags that recur in the reviews: persistent maintenance delays, and in some cases miscommunication; pest and moisture problems including humidity and mold; and security or nuisance concerns that weaken daily life. Several long-term residents describe mold and dampness in bathrooms and bedrooms, roaches in multiple buildings, and chronic maintenance misses that leave problems unresolved for weeks. Safety worries appear in multiple posts, unreliable lighting, rumors of theft or break-ins, and even discussions of non-resident activity near common areas. For families or seniors who cannot tolerate recurring pest control interruptions, inconsistently enforced lease provisions, or a pool and amenity space that feels intermittently accessible, Cabot Cove may not meet expectations.

The strongest positives, knowledgeable staff, visible maintenance effort when it does occur, and a generally clean, appealing setting, do have measurable upside. Several reviews praise specific team members who respond quickly, communicate clearly, and stay on problems until resolution, turning what could be a routine repair into a positive service experience. When the office is staffed by attentive individuals who understand the lease, move-in processes are smooth, and the surrounding community looks presentable, residents feel supported. For tenants who consider emotional comfort and a sense of stability as part of the value equation, those consistent, if not universal, staff-driven moments can offset some friction and create a satisfying living environment, at least in the short to mid term.

Yet those advantages must be weighed against a pattern of ongoing operational concerns. The most consequential issues revolve around reliability and safety: roach infestations, mold, and humidity that recur across units; maintenance technicians who appear to respond inconsistently or only after repeated prompts; and reports of ineffective or delayed repairs that lead to repeated visits and ongoing discomfort. Compounding these are safety and nuisance considerations, crime in the area, questions about security measures, noisy neighbors, and non-resident access to common amenities like the pool. The combination of pest pressure and inconsistent enforcement of quiet and safety policies creates a living environment where daily peace of mind is not guaranteed, even if the outward appearance remains polished.

From a decision-making standpoint, the prudent path is a disciplined due-diligence approach: schedule a thorough on-site visit with a detailed, floor-by-floor inspection of habitability, pest history, and moisture controls; request a recent maintenance response log and visitation schedule; and insist on tangible assurances about ongoing security, lighting, and enforcement of noise ordinances. Probe the current pest management plan, ask for a transparent history of any mold remediation, and verify the frequency and method of preventive spraying. Confirm what the pool rules look like in practice, who enforces them, and whether non-residents tend to access the amenity. Finally, seek out a candid dialogue about rent increases relative to service quality, and whether the management team has clear plans or recent evidence of improvement in the most problematic areas.

In the end, Cabot Cove can still be a good home for households that value aesthetic appeal, amicable staff interactions, and a generally quiet setting, and who are willing to tolerate, or actively monitor, maintenance and safety quirks. The verdict hinges on weighting the visible strengths of management responsiveness and pleasant surroundings against the systemic issues of pests, mold, and uneven maintenance performance. For families or seniors whose non-negotiables include consistently clean pest control, predictable repairs, and solid security, alternatives with proven track records in those domains deserve serious consideration. If choosing Cabot Cove, approach with a rigorous checklist, insist on real-time problem-solving commitments, and maintain a backup plan should the frequency or severity of the cons intensify.

Features

Types of Care

  • Active Adult Communities (55+) Active Adult Communities (55+)Active Adult Communities provide seniors with opportunities for socialization, activities, and wellness programs tailored to their needs. These communities offer a sense of belonging and security while promoting an active and independent lifestyle for those aged 55 and older.

Pets

  • Cats allowed Cats allowed"Pet friendly" senior living communities are important for seniors because pets provide companionship, reduce feelings of loneliness and depression, promote physical activity and mental stimulation, and offer a sense of purpose and responsibility. Pets can improve overall well-being and quality of life for seniors in many ways.
  • Dogs allowed Dogs allowed"Pet friendly" senior living communities are important for seniors because pets provide companionship, reduce feelings of loneliness and depression, promote physical activity and mental stimulation, and offer a sense of purpose and responsibility. Pets can improve overall well-being and quality of life for seniors in many ways.

Amenities

  • Activities off-site Activities off-siteEngaging in off-site activities is crucial for seniors to maintain social connections, stay active, and stimulate their minds. It promotes overall well-being and helps combat feelings of isolation and loneliness.
  • Activities on-site Activities on-siteActivities on-site are important for seniors because they provide opportunities for socialization, mental stimulation, physical activity, and overall well-being. Engaging in activities can help seniors stay active, maintain their independence, and improve their quality of life.
  • Indoor common areas Indoor common areasIndoor common areas are crucial for seniors as they provide a space for socialization, recreation, and community engagement, promoting overall well-being and reducing feelings of isolation and loneliness.
  • Outdoor common areas Outdoor common areasOutdoor common areas are important for seniors as they provide a space for socialization, physical activity, and relaxation. Being outside in nature can improve mood and overall well-being, while also encouraging movement and engagement with others. These spaces can help combat feelings of isolation and promote a sense of community among residents.
  • Swimming pool / hot tub Swimming pool / hot tubSwimming pools and hot tubs are important for seniors as they provide a safe and enjoyable way to stay active, improve mobility, reduce joint pain, and promote relaxation. Regular use of these amenities can contribute to overall well-being and quality of life for older adults living in senior communities.

Transportation

  • John Glenn Columbus International Airport (14 miles away) John Glenn Columbus International Airport (14 miles away)

Activities

  • Activities off-site Activities off-siteEngaging in off-site activities is crucial for seniors to maintain social connections, stay active, and stimulate their minds. It promotes overall well-being and helps combat feelings of isolation and loneliness.
  • Activities on-site Activities on-siteActivities on-site are important for seniors because they provide opportunities for socialization, mental stimulation, physical activity, and overall well-being. Engaging in activities can help seniors stay active, maintain their independence, and improve their quality of life.

Description

Cabot Cove in Hilliard, OH is a vibrant assisted living community that offers a range of amenities and activities to enhance the lives of its residents. The community boasts well-maintained indoor and outdoor common areas where residents can engage in various social interactions and recreational activities.

For those who enjoy staying active and engaged, Cabot Cove offers on-site activities that cater to different interests and hobbies. From fitness classes to arts and crafts sessions, there is always something enjoyable happening within the community.

In addition to the on-site amenities, Cabot Cove also features a refreshing swimming pool and hot tub. Residents can take a dip in the pool or relax in the soothing hot tub, providing them with both physical and mental relaxation.

Location-wise, Cabot Cove is perfectly situated near various essential services. There are several cafes nearby for residents to grab a quick bite or enjoy a leisurely cup of coffee. Nature enthusiasts will be pleased to find four parks in close proximity where they can take leisurely walks or enjoy outdoor picnics.

Accessing healthcare is convenient as well, with five pharmacies and eleven physicians located nearby. This ensures that residents have easy access to their medications and medical appointments whenever needed.

When it comes to dining out or trying new cuisines, Cabot Cove's location provides an array of options with fourteen restaurants situated close by. From casual eateries to fine dining establishments, residents can explore different culinary delights as per their preferences.

For individuals seeking spiritual fulfillment, there are three places of worship located nearby where residents can attend religious services and connect with their faith community.

Lastly, for those who appreciate cultural experiences such as live performances, there is one theater nearby where residents can enjoy plays, musicals, and other forms of entertainment.

Overall, Cabot Cove in Hilliard, OH offers not only comfortable assisted living accommodations but also a vibrant community atmosphere enriched with various amenities and convenient access to essential services within its surroundings.

Nearby Places of Interest

Restaurants

  • Roosters (0.3 miles)
  • Chick-Fil-A (0.5 miles)
  • Culver's (1.2 miles)
  • Nasty's Sports Bar & Grill (1.6 miles)
  • McDonald's (2 miles)
  • Wendy's (2.3 miles)
  • Taco Bell (2.4 miles)

Pharmacies

  • CVS Pharmacy (0.9 miles)
  • Walmart Pharmacy (1.2 miles)
  • Walgreens (2.2 miles)
  • CVS Pharmacy (3.1 miles)
  • CVS Pharmacy (3.5 miles)
  • Walgreens (5.2 miles)
  • Walgreens (5.2 miles)

Cafes

  • Panera Bread (1.1 miles)
  • Starbucks (5.6 miles)
  • Starbucks (5.9 miles)
  • Starbucks (6.9 miles)

Theaters

  • AMC Starplex Columbus 10 (1.1 miles)

Physicians

  • Mount Carmel Medical Group (1.9 miles)
  • Hilliard Family Medicine (2.6 miles)
  • OhioHealth Laboratory Services - Hilliard Health Center (2.8 miles)
  • Northwest Family Physicians (2.9 miles)
  • Internal Medicine Pediatrics Hilliard (3.1 miles)
  • Arlington-Mill Run Internal Medicine (3.1 miles)
  • Central Ohio Cardiovascular (3.2 miles)

Parks

  • Hilliard Municipal Park (2.2 miles)
  • Quarry Trails Metro Park (2.7 miles)
  • Homestead Park (4 miles)
  • Freedom Park (4.8 miles)
  • Thompson Park (5.4 miles)
  • Prairie Oaks Metro Park (5.8 miles)
  • Carriage Place Park (5.9 miles)

Places of Worship

  • Scioto Ridge United Methodist Church (4.3 miles)
  • Saint Brendan Catholic Church (4.6 miles)
  • Grace Evangelical Church (4.8 miles)
  • St Andrew Church (5.4 miles)
  • St Simon & Jude Church (5.6 miles)
  • St Christopher Church (5.9 miles)

Transportation

  • The Ohio State University Airport at Don Scott Field (OSU) (6.7 miles)

Hospitals

  • Ohio Health (7.1 miles)
  • OSU Harding Hospital (7.1 miles)

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to live at Cabot Cove in Hilliard, OH?
Where is Cabot Cove?
Does Cabot Cove allow residents to have pets?

Nearby Communities

  • Carriage Court Senior Living

    Carriage Court Senior Living

    Hilliard, OH

    4.4 from 96 reviews
     

    pro Clean, well-maintained facility with attentive staff and engaging activities.

  • Carriage Court - Hilliard

    Carriage Court - Hilliard

    Hilliard, OH

    4.4 from 127 reviews
    $2,848 to $5,063 / month

    pro Friendly, attentive staff in a well-maintained, inviting setting with good dining and activities.

  • The Ashford at Sturbridge

    The Ashford at Sturbridge

    Hilliard, OH

    4.2 from 83 reviews
    $3,545 to $4,280 / month

    pro Friendly staff and clean, well-maintained surroundings with engaging activities.

  • The Laurels Of Hilliard

    The Laurels Of Hilliard

    Hilliard, OH

    3.2 from 16 reviews
     

    pro Comprehensive amenities and 24/7 care, including transport, dining, wellness, and activities.

  • Wellington Village

    Wellington Village

    Hilliard, OH

    4.1 from 96 reviews
    $951 to $1,141 / month

    pro Spacious, clean apartments with friendly staff and an active community.

  • Mill Run Rehabilitation Center

    Mill Run Rehabilitation Center

    Hilliard, OH

    3.6 from 126 reviews
     

    pro Home-like atmosphere with caring staff and engaging activities.

  • Harmony Trace

    Harmony Trace

    Hilliard, OH

    4.5 from 20 reviews
    $4,900 to $5,200 / month

    pro Excellent tour experience with friendly, personalized care.

  • Hilliard Assisted Living & Memory Care

    Hilliard Assisted Living & Memory Care

    Hilliard, OH

    4.2 from 49 reviews
    $3,650 to $5,665 / month

    pro Friendly, caring staff with engaging activities and good dining.

Related Resources