Mary D Buck Memorial Apts in Whitesboro, NY

Pros

• Mary Buck Apartments are a wonderful place to live.
• The apartments are well maintained and comfortable.
• The security of residents is of the utmost priority.
• A family friend has lived there for years and absolutely loves it.
• Mary Buck Apartments come highly recommended to everyone.

Cons

• A resident’s mounted doorbell was stolen by a neighbor known to steal things.
• The building had security only on the ground floor, and the elevators were known to break down every other day.
• The snow-plowing company has not been paid for its services despite sending over 20 overdue invoices.
• Meetings to speak with management were scheduled, but no one showed up.
• The gentleman at 10 Clonton laughed in their face and said good luck with that.
• The resident has had only a handful of conversations with building management since May 2022.
• The office is frequently empty when help is needed; the blinds are closed all day and notices declare there won’t be any services.
• Every time the resident’s mother calls for information, nobody returns the call, and she remains homeless.
• HUD low-income apartments are described as mean, as though management thinks they own residents and will try to rip out their soul.

Review

Mary D Buck Memorial Apts in Whitesboro is best suited for financially constrained seniors who need affordable housing and can tolerate uneven on-site management. The complex attracts residents who expect a low-cost option and are willing to navigate potential maintenance gaps and inconsistent staff presence. For anyone who requires a consistently responsive management team, guaranteed maintenance turnaround, or robust security oversight, alternatives should be actively considered. The appeal lies in price and a sense of “home,” but that value hinges on acceptance of a management reality that is far from dependable.

On the positive side, several voices describe the apartments themselves as well maintained and reasonably comfortable when viewed in isolation. A portion of tenants emphasize that the living spaces feel orderly and that the security emphasis, at least in principle, is a priority. A notable sentiment from supporters is that the property could be a suitable home for those who need a budget-friendly option without extravagant amenities. These favorable notes suggest there is a foundation of livability that can work for residents who prioritize cost and basic comfort over concierge-level service.

Yet the most persistent and consequential themes are the management and maintenance gaps. Reports consistently flag limited access to the office and staff, with the building often appearing understaffed or unavailable when residents and vendors need assistance. Calls and visits go unanswered, and there is a pattern of empty offices and delayed responses that undermine trust and create a sense of abandonment for those reliant on timely information. Those dynamics translate into real-world frustrations, especially for households navigating healthcare needs, rent-sensitive budgeting, or urgent repairs.

Maintenance reliability compounds the problem: elevators are described as malfunctioning with alarming frequency, which complicates routines for mobility-impaired residents and family caregivers alike. Security concerns are not merely theoretical; one review cites a doorbell theft and limited security coverage to the ground floor, reinforcing a perception that safety and access control are not consistently enforceable. Combined with inconsistent communication and opaque processes for service requests, these issues can erode quality of life and escalate stress for both seniors and their families.

The overall equation favors caution for any prospective resident who values predictability. The affordability and the sense that a basic, livable apartment is available come with a heavy caveat: persistent management gaps and recurring maintenance failures can offset the financial appeal. For someone who can tolerate intermittent access to staff, understands the likelihood of delays, and does not require rapid elevator service or airtight security, the Mary D Buck Memorial Apts may still be a workable choice. However, for households seeking dependable on-site management, timely repairs, and proactive communication, alternatives that deliver consistent staff availability and clearer accountability are likely to be more prudent.

If this community is under consideration, a disciplined evaluation is essential. Prospective residents should insist on a transparent demonstration of management presence, regular office hours, predictable response times, and a clear escalation path for urgent issues. Request a documented history of maintenance repairs, elevator service logs, and recent security measures to verify what actually occurs over a representative period. Engage current tenants in candid conversations about how often problems are resolved and how well concerns are acknowledged. Finally, obtain written assurances in the lease about service expectations, vendor payment practices, and what remedies exist when promised issues remain unresolved. This due diligence helps ensure the choice aligns with both budget realities and the need for reliable day-to-day support.

Whitesboro, New York offers a convenient and vibrant community for seniors to consider for living. With several pharmacies located within close proximity, accessing medication and healthcare services is easily manageable. A variety of restaurants provide dining options for every taste, while hospitals and physicians offices are readily available for medical needs. For leisure activities, there are cafes for socializing and theaters for entertainment. Places of worship offer spiritual support as well. Overall, Whitesboro presents a well-rounded environment that caters to the various needs of seniors looking to settle in a welcoming neighborhood with access to essential amenities.

Pharmacies

• Langdon's Apothecary (0.1 miles)
• Rite Aid (0.1 miles)
• Kinney Drugs (0.4 miles)
• Medicine Shoppe (1.1 miles)
• Walgreens (1.8 miles)
• Rite Aid (1.8 miles)
• Hannaford Pharmacy (2.6 miles)

Restaurants

• Boulevard Diner (0.1 miles)
• Burger King (0.4 miles)
• McDonald's (1 miles)
• Taco Bell (1 miles)
• Holland Farms Bakery & Deli (1.2 miles)
• Symeon’s (1.4 miles)
• Chowder House (1.8 miles)

Hospitals

• Faxton-St Luke's Healthcare (0.3 miles)
• St Lukes-Memorial Hospital Center - Faxton-St Lukes Healthcare (1.9 miles)
• Faxton St Luke's Healthcare: St Luke's Campus (2 miles)
• Mohawk Valley Psychiatric Center (2.2 miles)
• Utica Psychiatric Center (2.3 miles)
• Faxton X-ray Department (2.8 miles)
• FAXTON-St LUKE'S HEALTHCARE - FAXTON CAMPUS (2.8 miles)

Physicians

• Adirondack Community Physicians: Whitesboro Medical Office (0.3 miles)
• Empire Orthopedic Laboratories (1.3 miles)
• Valley Dental (1.9 miles)
• Francis Eye and Laser Center (2 miles)
• Thomson Anne J Pa Slocumdickson Medical Group New Hartford (2.1 miles)
• Dayal D Raja MD (2.1 miles)
• Slocum-Dickson Medical Group (2.1 miles)

Cafes

• Panera Bread (1.9 miles)
• Raspberries Cafe (2 miles)
• Starbucks (2.1 miles)
• Bagel Grove (2.8 miles)
• Joseph Putrello Coffee Barista Bar (3.3 miles)
• Daylight Donuts (3.3 miles)

Theaters

• Marquee Cinemas - Orchard 14 (2.3 miles)

Places of Worship

• Our Lady Of Lourdes Ch (2.9 miles)