At St John's Herr Estate, the monthly rental costs for various room types present a competitive alternative when compared to the broader market rates in Lancaster County and Pennsylvania. For instance, a one-bedroom unit is available at $1,189, significantly lower than the county's average of $4,379 and the state's average of $4,006. Similarly, two-bedroom options are priced at $1,455 - again well below Lancaster County's average of $5,040 and Pennsylvania's average of $4,242. However, the studio apartment stands out with a rate of $5,170, which surpasses both county and state averages ($4,419 and $3,737 respectively). Overall, St John's Herr Estate offers appealing pricing for one- and two-bedroom options while presenting higher studio costs that merit consideration for specific needs or preferences.
Floor plans
St John's Herr Estate
Lancaster County
Pennsylvania
1 Bedroom
$1,189
$4,379
$4,006
2 Bedrooms
$1,455
$5,040
$4,242
Studio
$5,170
$4,419
$3,737
Overall Review of St John's Herr Estate
differentiator2 reviews mention this
Faith support is built in
Residents point to a strong Lutheran and chaplain presence alongside daily life.
Several residents describe a faith-focused atmosphere, including mention of a Lutheran chapel and a caring chaplain. That aligns with the way the community offers devotional services both on-site and off-site.
differentiator8 reviews mention this
Care spans multiple support levels
Families like the comfort that support levels are available as needs change.
Residents and families often focus on knowing they can stay and receive care if their situation changes. Reviews mention caring nursing staff and receiving great care, and one resident also calls out that all levels of care are available. The community also lists support services such as medication management and diabetic, incontinence, and high acuity care.
common8 reviews mention this
Activities keep residents engaged
Residents describe an activity-heavy lifestyle with options beyond daily routine.
Reviews repeatedly mention a busy activity calendar and plenty of things to do. Several residents specifically describe participating in group activities, including joining a bowling team, while others note good activities availability when they want them. That matches the communityâs posted schedule of on-site and off-site activities, plus classes and outings.
common10 reviews mention this
Friendly staff and clean spaces
People consistently mention kind, helpful staff in a facility they describe as clean.
Across multiple reviews, residents describe the staff as friendly, caring, and attentive. Several also highlight cleanliness, including sparkly or neat rooms and a well-kept facility. One resident experience does raise concerns about a specific dayshift nurse and a personal care manager, but the overall feedback about staff helpfulness remains positive.
caveat7 reviews mention this
Food quality is a mixed point
Dining gets both praise and complaints, with some residents saying the meals are basic.
Some residents describe the food as delicious and say they enjoy the meals available to the community. Others describe the food more negatively, including comments that it can feel basic and that residents donât get enough choice. The community does provide meals, and some reviews also mention a lovely dining room and outdoor courtyard as part of the dining experience.
caveat2 reviews mention this
Cost shows up as a tradeoff
Value is mentioned, but at least one family chose a different option for cost.
One review calls out the community as a great value, while another family chose a different place because it was a lower cost. That lines up with the pricing comparisons showing this communityâs rates below both the county and state benchmarks across unit types.
How we summarize
Counts show how many written reviews mention each theme; a review can touch several themes, and only frequently mentioned themes are displayed.
Features
Types of Care
Assisted Living
Independent Living
Pets
Cats allowed
Dogs allowed
Amenities
Activities off-site
Activities on-site
Air-conditioning
Beautician on-site
Devotional services off-site
Devotional services on-site
Full kitchen
Ground floor units
Handicap accessible
Indoor common areas
Kitchenette
Outdoor common areas
Respite or short term stays offered
Wheelchair accessible showers
Wi-Fi/high-speed internet available
Transportation
Harrisburg International (18 miles away)
Care Services
Ambulatory care
Diabetic care
High acuity care
Incontinence care
Medication management
Dining
Meals provided
Activities
Art classes
Cooking classes
Day trips and outings
Devotional activities offsite
Devotional activities on-site
Educational speakers / life long learning
Happy hour
Live dance or theater performances
Live musical performances
Stretching classes
Tai Chi
Nearby Places of Interest
Located in Columbia, Pennsylvania, this area offers a variety of amenities and services that cater to the needs of seniors. With multiple physicians' offices nearby such as Columbia Regional Health Center and Mountville Family Practice, residents have convenient access to healthcare services. There are also several cafes like Coffee and Cream for socializing over a cup of coffee, as well as restaurants including Columbia Family Restaurant for dining out with friends or family. For outdoor recreation, there are parks like Murray Ridge Park and Wood's Edge Park within a short drive. Additionally, pharmacies like CVS Pharmacy provide easy access to medications and healthcare supplies. Nearby hospitals such as Physicians Surgery Center and Lancaster Rehabilitation Hospital offer peace of mind knowing that medical care is easily accessible if needed. Lastly, places of worship such as Sacred Heart Church are available for spiritual nourishment and community involvement. Overall, this part of Columbia provides a welcoming and convenient environment for seniors looking to settle down in a peaceful and supportive community.
Physicians
Columbia Regional Health Center at St Anne's Retirement Community (0.9 miles)
Mountville Family Practice (3.1 miles)
Susquehanna Family Medicine (3.3 miles)
Eden Park Pediatric Associates (4.7 miles)
Hearing & Ear Care Center (5.4 miles)
Orthopedic Associates of Lancaster, LTD. (5.7 miles)
Allergy And Asthma Center (6.3 miles)
Cafes
Coffee and Cream (1.3 miles)
Starbucks (8 miles)
Valentino's Cafe (8.5 miles)
Copper Cup Coffee (8.6 miles)
Panera Bread (8.8 miles)
Starbucks (9 miles)
Restaurants
Columbia Family Restaurant At Prospect (1.8 miles)
Trio Bar and Grill (3.1 miles)
Loxleyâs Restaurant (4.7 miles)
Sonic Drive-In (4.7 miles)
Twisted Bine Beer (4.8 miles)
McDonald's (4.9 miles)
Bube's Brewery (4.9 miles)
Parks
Murray Ridge Park (3.9 miles)
Wood's Edge Park (5.4 miles)
A Herr Park (5.9 miles)
Long's Park (8.2 miles)
Buchanan Park (8.6 miles)
Beau's Dream Dog Park at Buchanan Park (8.7 miles)
At St John's Herr Estate, the monthly rental costs for various room types present a competitive alternative when compared to the broader market rates in Lancaster County and Pennsylvania. For instance, a one-bedroom unit is available at $1,189, significantly lower than the county's average of $4,379 and the state's average of $4,006. Similarly, two-bedroom options are priced at $1,455 - again well below Lancaster County's average of $5,040 and Pennsylvania's average of $4,242. However, the studio apartment stands out with a rate of $5,170, which surpasses both county and state averages ($4,419 and $3,737 respectively). Overall, St John's Herr Estate offers appealing pricing for one- and two-bedroom options while presenting higher studio costs that merit consideration for specific needs or preferences.
St John's Herr Estate on seniors.fyi includes 7 photos including images showing landscaping, interior, bedroom, architecture, building, garden, exterior, kitchen, and more.
Nearby Communities
St John S Herr Estate
Columbia, PA
4.3 from 10 reviews
Strong sense of community with spacious, well-equipped apartments and dining credit plus engaging activities.
St Peter Apartments
Columbia, PA
3.3 from 6 reviews
Compassionate assisted living with diabetic care and offsite devotional activities.
Susquehanna Valley Nursing & Rehabilitation Center
Columbia, PA
4 from 29 reviews
Comprehensive amenities and 24/7 care.
Trinity House
Columbia, PA
4.1 from 18 reviews
Specialized diabetic care with on-site activities and indoor common areas
Cherry Street Guest Home
Columbia, PA
5 from 1 review
Homelike, fully furnished accommodations with restaurant-style dining.
St Annes Retirement Community
Columbia, PA
4.4 from 108 reviews
Brereton Manor
Washington Boro, PA
4.6 from 45 reviews
$3,720 / month
Friendly, attentive staff in a warm, home-like community with home-cooked meals.
Mennonite Home Care Campus
Lancaster, PA
4 from 37 reviews
Continuum of care (CCRC) with extensive on-site amenities.
Providence Place Senior Living
Lancaster, PA
4 from 39 reviews
Caring staff with excellent communication; great dining, comfortable rooms, and engaging activities.
Senior move management services assist older adults in the relocation process by providing emotional support and organizational help, addressing unique challenges like downsizing and moving from long-term homes. These specialists collaborate with real estate agents and manage logistics, making the transition smoother for seniors and their families.
The article examines senior housing options, detailing the distinctions between independent living and assisted living, along with the emerging "independent assisted living" model that blends both approaches. It highlights the importance of assessing individual needs, preferences, and financial factors in making informed decisions about suitable living arrangements for seniors.
The deductibility of assisted living expenses on taxes hinges on factors like the individual's medical condition and service nature, typically requiring the resident to be "chronically ill" per IRS definitions. Taxpayers may deduct eligible medical expenses related to personal care services but generally not rent unless primarily for medical care, and they should maintain thorough documentation to support claims while considering itemizing versus standard deductions.
Get PricingAsk A QuestionSchedule A TourContact Senior Advisor
By clicking submit, you agree to our Partner's Terms of Use. You
also consent to receive calls and texts, which may be autodialed, from our Partner. Your consent is not a condition to
using our Partner's service. Please visit our Partner's Privacy Policy for information about their privacy practices.