19 independent living communities in Middle Island, NY

• Great Food

  Atria South Setauket

  4.3 from 109 reviews

  #1 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

  $3,695 to $5,395 per month

  Atria South Setauket is praised for its caring staff, affordability, and quality food, but potential residents should be aware of accessibility issues and the need for clear communication regarding costs and management responsiveness.

• Friendly Staff

  The Bristal At Lake Grove

  4.5 from 123 reviews

  #2 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

  $4,900 to $8,200 per month

  The Bristal at Lake Grove boasts a vibrant, engaging environment with attentive staff, excellent communication with families, and appealing amenities that create a warm and welcoming community for residents.

• Beautiful Environment

  The Chelsea at Brookhaven

  4.2 from 68 reviews

  #3 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

  $3,300 to $5,250 per month

  The Chelsea at Brookhaven is a well-maintained, visually appealing independent living community with dedicated staff and engaging activities, though it faces challenges like medication errors and high costs that may concern potential residents.

• Friendly Staff

  The Bristal At Sayville

  4.7 from 97 reviews

  #4 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

  $4,800 to $9,600 per month

  The Bristal at Sayville fosters a warm community atmosphere with compassionate staff and engaged residents, offering a bright and inviting environment where seniors can thrive socially and emotionally.

• 

  Brightview Port Jefferson

  4.5 from 68 reviews

  #5 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

   

  Brightview Port Jefferson offers a vibrant independent living community with fully furnished apartments and various amenities, but its focus on care services may suggest a higher level of assistance than some residents might prefer.

• Friendly Staff

  Atria Hertlin Place

  4.5 from 112 reviews

  #6 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

  $5,495 to $6,095 per month

  Atria Hertlin Place is a beautiful and well-maintained independent living community with engaging activities, friendly staff, and positive dining experiences that many families appreciate for their loved ones.

• Friendly Staff

  Atria East Northport

  4.4 from 87 reviews

  #7 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

  $5,695 to $6,895 per month

  Atria East Northport is praised for its caring and professional staff, welcoming atmosphere, and appealing accommodations with engaging amenities, making it a strong choice for families seeking an independent living community for seniors.

• New Facility

  Brightview Sayville

  4.4 from 116 reviews

  #8 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

   

  Brightview Sayville is a modern, welcoming independent living community that offers spacious, thoughtfully designed living spaces, exceptional staff support, customizable dining options, and inviting amenities?all within a peaceful environment that fosters social engagement.

• 

  Jefferson's Ferry Lifecare Retirement

  4.6 from 77 reviews

  #9 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

  $2,416 to $3,377 per month

  Jefferson's Ferry Lifecare Retirement in South Setauket, NY, offers a range of amenities and activities for seniors but might lack the vibrancy found in more independent living environments.

• Great Activities

  The Bristal At East Northport

  4.6 from 92 reviews

  #10 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

   

  The Bristal Assisted Living at East Northport, NY offers an upscale, hotel-like environment with elegant dining, engaging activities, exceptional staff support, and well-maintained amenities that create a vibrant and fulfilling living experience for residents.

• Friendly Staff

  Atria Huntington

  4.5 from 88 reviews

  #11 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

  $2,795 to $4,095 per month

  Atria Huntington is highly regarded for its warm, family-like atmosphere, attentive staff, delicious dining options, and a wide range of engaging activities that promote social interaction and enhance the quality of life for residents.

• Friendly Staff

  The Bristal at West Babylon

  4.6 from 75 reviews

  #12 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

  $4,500 to $8,200 per month

  The Bristal at West Babylon offers a beautiful, engaging environment with friendly staff and numerous activities, but potential residents should be cautious about staffing consistency and communication.

• Friendly Staff

  Atria Bay Shore

  4.5 from 98 reviews

  #13 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

  $4,995 to $8,295 per month

  Atria Bay Shore is a charming senior community set in a beautifully maintained mansion, known for its warm atmosphere, attentive staff who foster genuine relationships, and a robust calendar of engaging activities that promote social interaction and resident well-being.

• Friendly Staff

  Birchwood Suites

  4.1 from 120 reviews

  #14 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

  $3,500 to $4,000 per month

  Birchwood Suites offers a warm and caring environment with attentive staff, but potential residents should be aware of concerns regarding staffing levels, limited engagement activities, communication issues, and inconsistent food quality.

• 

  The Cornerstone at Hauppauge

  4.7 from 18 reviews

  #15 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

  $2,445 to $2,895 per month

  The Cornerstone at Hauppauge offers well-appointed apartments and a variety of indoor and outdoor amenities, but may lack sufficient recreational activities and opportunities for independence.

• Amazing Care

  Pearl Garden Manor

  3.5 from 10 reviews

  #16 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

  $1,600 to $3,200 per month

  Potential residents and families should weigh both positive and negative reviews of a facility, considering factors like management quality, cleanliness, and overall environment to ensure it meets health standards and provides a supportive atmosphere.

• 

  Bayview Home for Adults

  2.7 from 15 reviews

  #17 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

   

  Bayview Rest Home faces serious criticism for inadequate care, poor building maintenance, frequent plumbing issues, subpar food quality, insufficient staff training, and a lack of engaging activities.

• 

  Barnum House

  5.0 from 3 reviews

  #18 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

   

  Barnum House in Bridgeport, CT, while conveniently located near amenities like cafes, parks, pharmacies, physicians, restaurants, transportation services, and hospitals, may lack the quiet and tranquility some seniors seek given its bustling neighborhood.

• 

  Woodbridge of Hampton Bays

  3.7 from 3 reviews

  #19 Best reviewed of independent living in Middle Island

   

  Woodbridge of Hampton Bays is an independent living community offering spacious apartments and a vibrant lifestyle, but it may not have the extensive medical support that some seniors require.

Cost of independent living in Middle Island, NY