Carriage Works Apartments in York, PA

Pros

• The staff are helpful and friendly, and the environment is beautiful and clean.
• Eddie, the maintenance supervisor, is professional, friendly, and does thorough, high-quality work.
• A new manager is actively addressing issues and making noticeable improvements around the property.
• The apartments have nice floor plans, high ceilings, and many electrical outlets.
• The property offers a playground where children can play safely.
• Maintenance requests are handled promptly, and problems are addressed when raised.
• The overall upkeep and cleanliness of the property are praised by residents.

Cons

• The oven replacement took more than 20 days to obtain a new one.
• The apartment wasn't cleaned before move-in.
• Despite being advertised as a non-smoking building, residents continue to smoke and the smell seeps through walls, aggravating asthma.
• The walls are extremely thin, making it easy to hear neighbors above.
• The automatic doors do not always work.
• There is drug use in the stairwell and theft, with old management allegedly aware and not evicting the offenders.
• A resident yelled about killing people and setting the building on fire, and management and the police did nothing.
• Management changes frequently and complaints are not taken seriously.

Review

Carriage Works Apartments in York is best suited for budget-conscious adults who want a roomy, well-finished apartment and are willing to tolerate a less predictable management environment. The units stand out with attractive floor plans, high ceilings, plentiful electrical outlets, and a generally clean interior that can feel more homey than many cheaper rentals. When the on-site maintenance supervisor is active, repairs are handled with competence and attention to detail, and that practical reliability can turn a dated building into a comfortable living space. For families, the playground and the secure entry add welcome touches that make the setting feel livable rather than purely utilitarian.

Those who should consider alternatives are families or seniors who prioritize consistent, proactive management, rigorous enforcement of rules, and a consistently quiet, safe environment. If non-negotiables include zero tolerance for smoking inside, rapid response to complaints, fully functioning common areas, working surveillance and security, or a stable leadership team, other properties will likely deliver with fewer headaches. Likewise, anyone needing predictable, transparent billing and a straightforward path to resolving disputes will fare better elsewhere, given the mix of turnover and reported communication gaps here.

The strongest positives help offset the downsides when the management team is engaged. The building's interior presentation is appealing, with wide hallways and tasteful decoration, and the apartments themselves are clips above typical income-based offerings in terms of space and finish. Maintenance staff, especially the named supervisor Eddie, receive consistent praise for doing precise, quality work and for going the extra mile to help residents. The sense of a secure building, and the occasional improvement in grounds and common areas under a responsive manager, can make this a workable home for tenants who value self-sufficiency and occasional hands-on support.

Nevertheless, the downsides run deep enough to shape a candid decision. Chronic complaints about management turnover, slow or inconsistent follow-through on repairs, and a history of complaints about noise, drug activity in common areas, and even theft create real unease. Move-in cleanliness and initial readiness can be lacking, with reports of stale smells, cigarette smoke seeping through walls, and damaged or non-functional entry features. The infrastructure issues - thin walls, unreliable automatic doors, elevator wear, recurring drainage problems, and a gym that is often dirty or under-supervised - compound the risk of living in a building where problems are not always resolved promptly.

In weighing pros against cons, the property can still be a practical choice for residents who prize space, a quiet personal unit, and affordable rents while accepting a more fluid governance model. The key is to align expectations: determine how much value is placed on timely maintenance versus the potential for management changes; how much tolerance exists for shared-area nuisances like noise, lingering odors, or litter; and how critical security and strict rule enforcement are. Pros offset cons most cleanly for self-reliant tenants who can tolerate intermittent oversight and who are prepared to advocate for themselves, ideally with a clear plan for escalation if issues persist.

For decision-makers, the bottom line is clear: this community rewards residents who can tolerate a variable management experience and who do not require a pristine safety record or perfect control of the environment. If safety, consistency, and predictable service are non-negotiables, it is prudent to look elsewhere. If affordable rents, generous apartment layouts, and a capable maintenance touchstone - when available - are valued, Carriage Works can work, provided a careful pre-move-in inspection, a frank discussion with current residents, and a clear plan for ongoing follow-up are part of the approach.

Pharmacies

• CVS Pharmacy (0.5 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (1.4 miles)
• Target Pharmacy (1.5 miles)
• Brockie Healthcare (1.6 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (2.5 miles)
• Weis Markets Pharmacy (3.6 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (3.6 miles)

Physicians

• Yorktowne Family Medicine (0.6 miles)
• Family Medicine Assoc Of York (0.9 miles)
• MyEyeDr (1 miles)
• Brockie Internal Medicine (1.2 miles)
• York E.N.T Associates (1.3 miles)
• Wellspan Health (1.3 miles)
• MyEyeDr (1.4 miles)

Places of Worship

• Madison Av Church of the Brethren (0.7 miles)

Restaurants

• Hardee's (0.7 miles)
• Plaza Azteca Restaurantes Mexicanos (1.2 miles)
• McDonald's (1.3 miles)
• MOD Pizza (1.3 miles)
• Olive Garden (1.5 miles)
• Lyndon Diner (1.5 miles)
• Quaker Steak & Lube (1.6 miles)

Theaters

• West Manchester STM 13 (1.4 miles)
• Frank Theatres Queensgate Stadium 13 (3.5 miles)

Cafes

• Starbucks (1.6 miles)
• Colonial Coffee Shop (2 miles)
• Starbucks (2.7 miles)
• Dunkin' Dounuts (3.4 miles)
• Starbucks (3.6 miles)

Parks

• Reservoir Park (2 miles)
• Bob Hoffman Fields (2.5 miles)
• York County Rail Trail - Brillhart Station (2.8 miles)
• Cousler Park (3.2 miles)

Hospitals

• UPMC Memorial (2 miles)
• York Hospital - Imaging Department (2.1 miles)
• UPMC Memorial Hospital (2.3 miles)
• WellSpan Behavioral Health (2.5 miles)
• WellSpan Surgery & Rehabilitation Hospital (2.8 miles)
• Wellspan Gettysburg Hospital (3 miles)
• Wellspan Childbirth And Family Education Center (3.6 miles)