Collingwood Green

Pros

• These homes are energy-efficient.
• The office lady, who was there from the very beginning but unfortunately no longer is, was incredibly kind and always stood up for everyone.
• Trees can add value to your home, help cool your home and neighborhood, break the cold winds to lower your heating costs, and provide food for wildlife.
• This place served as a stepping stone to prepare for future positive experiences.
• WONDERFUL PLACE TO LIVE ?? Affordable downtown living. Love the private security and maintenance crew. Management is very professional and reliable to work with.
• Beautiful.
• Very helpful.

Cons

• Management was frequently changed, causing inconsistency and unresponsiveness.
• Maintenance requests were often ignored for years.
• There were repeated thefts and break-ins by non-residents, including stolen packages and car vandalism.
• The property appeared poorly maintained, with trash, broken glass, and damaged trees.
• Units had poor climate control, with bedrooms hot in summer and much hotter in winter.
• Deposits were mishandled and not refunded after move-out.

Review

This community started out with a clear sense of promise. The three-bedroom townhomes first opened in 2020, and many residents felt they were stepping into energy-efficient spaces that could be a fresh start. For a time, the excitement was fueled by a steady office presence - the office "lady" who had been there from the beginning and who notably stood up for residents. She did her best to help through the churn of management changes, which seemed to come every couple of months, a rhythm that made it hard to feel truly settled. Early on, there was recognition that these homes could be a solid foundation: a new place to grow, with decent design and a chance to build a sense of community.

Yet as the years wore on, a consistent pattern of problems emerged that overshadowed the initial optimism. A recurring theme was the disruption caused by children and teens in and around the property. Several reviewers described kids running through spaces, kicking doors, and leaving dents, with some even claiming that children from across the way would wander over from a neighboring complex to disturb others' belongings. The safety and security concerns extended to valuables, with multiple accounts of packages being stolen and intruders being identified as local children or teens. This led some residents to abandon outside decorating for fear of theft, and it clearly affected the overall sense of safety in the area. In addition to personal property, there were reports of cars being rummaged through or broken into, and trash and broken glass sometimes left behind, painting a picture of a neighborhood where supervision and respect for property were hard to maintain.

The landscape itself - trees and green space - became a point of pride for some residents, even as others saw damage done by misbehavior. Several people emphasized how trees add value to a home, help cool the environment, reduce heating costs, and provide food for wildlife. The contrast was stark: those who cared about the greenery felt the space could be healthier and more sustainable for everyone, while others described a battle with kids who didn't treat the grounds with care, tearing up newly planted saplings and disrupting the surrounding flora. It underscored a broader sentiment that the property's outdoor environment deserved real attention, not just for aesthetics but for long-term value and community well-being.

On the other hand, there were tangible concerns about the building's construction quality and climate control. Some residents felt the homes were poorly made: summer heat could be oppressive in their bedrooms even when the rest of the house was comfortable, and winter could turn a room into a furnace - symptoms some attributed to the layout, such as a bedroom positioned over a neighboring unit. A separate thread in the feedback pointed to confusion and inconsistency in the address system, with the same house numbers appearing on nearby blocks and the lack of clear signage - no stop signs on a major thoroughfare, Bresnahan and Rogan Way to Belmont - creating practical headaches for deliveries and daily navigation. The implication was that these logistical gaps fed daily annoyances and added to residents' stress.

The experience with maintenance and management was a recurring source of frustration, especially for those who stayed long enough to compare early promises with later reality. Several reviewers described frequent management turnover - sometimes as often as every year or two - and difficulties getting timely responses to maintenance requests. Emergencies sometimes did not seem urgent to the management, while routine fixes could stretch into weeks or months. There was a sense that once problems were finally addressed, the process could still feel disorganized, and in some cases residents found themselves having to take matters into their own hands or coordinate repairs themselves. An unnerving thread ran through several accounts: important inspections that did not result in lasting fixes, and persistent issues that resurfaced after partial resolutions. Compounding the frustration, residents recounted problems with handling personal documents and payments - signing the same documents repeatedly, mismanagement of money orders, and even delays or failures in returning security deposits after moving out, despite repeated calls.

Another layer to the story is the mixed experience with the application process and public accessibility. One family described a concerning interaction around applying, noting that the office was closed to the public and applications had to be submitted through a rent drop box, with subsequent inconsistencies about whether the application had actually been received. In one instance, a resident who moved forward with an application in 2021 faced a jarring claim years later that the application had never been turned in, raising concerns about data handling and privacy. These anecdotes underscored a deeper sense that the administrative side of the community could feel opaque and unreliable at times, leaving hopeful renters unsure about whether they would be treated fairly or given timely information.

Amidst the challenges, there were still voices that spoke to the place's positive potential and even moments of satisfaction. A few residents highlighted quiet moments, well-maintained interiors, and strong personal impressions of certain staff members who remained helpful and professional. A notable contrast arose in a later review that praised the community for its "private security and maintenance crew," and described management as professional and reliable to work with. There were also explicit expressions of satisfaction from people who had moved in and found the community appealing, especially those attracted to the look and upkeep of the property or drawn to its more affordable downtown setting. One person, Brandi Hamilton, even expressed enthusiasm about moving in, while another review described the community as a wonderful place to live with the sense that security and maintenance were being prioritized.

Looking at the overall arc, this complex embodies a tension between potential and persistently challenging realities. It is a place that could offer energy-efficient homes, a strategic urban setting, and a solid foundation for a family or individual starting anew. Yet that potential has repeatedly collided with management instability, inconsistent maintenance, and safety concerns tied to a young, disruptive population and inadequate security and oversight. The result is a landscape of mixed experiences: some residents found quiet, well-kept spaces and competent staff, while others endured repeated delays, miscommunications, and a range of safety and property issues that sometimes forced them to question whether the community could ever truly meet their needs. For anyone considering moving here, the takeaway is clear: ask detailed questions about management stability, maintenance responsiveness, security measures, and deposit practices, and be prepared to navigate both the strengths and the long-standing, multi-faceted challenges that define this community.

This part of Toledo, Ohio offers a variety of amenities that may be of interest to seniors looking for a comfortable and convenient place to live. There are several restaurants within close proximity, offering a range of dining options to enjoy. In terms of healthcare, there are multiple physicians and hospitals nearby, providing easy access to medical services. Additionally, there are several parks in the area for leisurely walks and outdoor activities. For those who enjoy coffee and socializing, there are cafes within a short distance. Overall, this neighborhood provides a mix of conveniences and opportunities for recreation that may appeal to seniors looking for a vibrant community to call home.

Restaurants

• Tin Can Bar (0.6 miles)
• Ye Olde Cock N Bull (0.6 miles)
• Spaghetti Warehouse (0.6 miles)
• Chevy's Place (0.6 miles)
• Packo's at the Park (0.7 miles)
• Ye Olde Durty Bird (0.7 miles)
• Maumee Bay Brew Pub (0.8 miles)

Physicians

• Mercy Family Physicians-Mercy Campus (0.7 miles)
• Mercy Health - Franklin Avenue Pediatrics (1.1 miles)
• Mercy Diabetes Education (1.5 miles)
• Toledo Cardiology Consultants (1.5 miles)
• Mercy Family Care Navarre Park: Linares Claudio E MD (2.3 miles)
• St Charles Mercy Hospital (2.3 miles)
• Nephrology Consultants of NW Ohio (2.9 miles)

Parks

• Harold Boeschenstein Park (0.9 miles)
• Middlegrounds Metropark (0.9 miles)
• Promenade Park (1 miles)
• Navarre Park (2.4 miles)
• Walbridge Park (2.8 miles)
• Oak Shade Hall & Picnic Grove (4.7 miles)

Cafes

• Grindhrs (0.9 miles)
• Tim Hortons (3.5 miles)
• BREW coffee bar (3.6 miles)
• SIP Coffee (4 miles)
• Starbucks (4.2 miles)

Hospitals

• St Jude Children's Hospital (0.9 miles)
• Toledo Hospital Labor & Delivery (2.7 miles)
• Toledo Hospital 7th Floor SICU (2.8 miles)
• ProMedica Toledo Hospital (2.8 miles)
• Toledo Hospital Er (2.9 miles)
• Toledo Hospital Breast Care (2.9 miles)
• Mh St Charles Op Pharm (3.6 miles)

Transportation

• Martin Luther King, Jr Plaza (0.9 miles)

Places of Worship

• Immaculate Conception Catholic Church (1 miles)
• Corpus Christi University Parish (3.2 miles)

Pharmacies

• Health Mart Pharmacy (1.3 miles)
• Rite Aid (1.5 miles)
• Walgreens (2.1 miles)
• Rite Aid (2.9 miles)
• Rite Aid (2.9 miles)
• Rite Aid (3.1 miles)
• ProMedica Pharmacy Counter - Central Ave (3.4 miles)