Otterbein New Albany

Save

  • Interior

    A beautifully arranged dining room with a long table set for a meal, showcasing modern design and an open kitchen layout.
  • Decor

    A cozy living room featuring a stone fireplace and stylish bookshelves.
  • Architecture

    A beautifully designed modern house featuring a mix of stone and siding, surrounded by greenery.
  • Bedroom

    A modern bedroom with an open layout connecting to a stylish bathroom.
  • Landscaping

    A charming suburban home with a well-maintained front yard and an American flag proudly displayed.
  • Kitchen

    A woman is cooking in a modern kitchen, showing her culinary skills.
  • Seating Area

    A serene outdoor patio setup featuring wooden furniture, an umbrella for shade, and lush greenery.
  • Outdoor

    A sunny patio area featuring a set of chairs and an umbrella, surrounded by greenery and flowers.
  • Natural Light

    A cozy bedroom featuring a single bed, light green walls, and natural lighting.
  • Cooking

    A chef and a staff member reviewing cooking notes in a modern kitchen.

Otterbein New Albany

6690 Liberation Way, New Albany, OH 43054

For more information about senior living options: (844) 490-3973

2.9 from 50 reviews
5 stars
19
4 stars
2
3 stars
7
2 stars
1
1 stars
21

Overall Review of Otterbein New Albany

Pros

  • pro The frontline aides and nurses are kind, compassionate, and doing their best under difficult staffing conditions.
  • pro The community model’s smaller housing units, shared meals, and common spaces create a setting that feels less institutional.
  • pro The staff are caring and dedicated, with several caregivers showing genuine compassion and dignity.
  • pro Otterbein’s concept is impressive, helping residents feel at home or like they have their own apartments.
  • pro The facility is noted for being cleaner and more home-like than many other rehab/nursing homes.
  • pro Home-cooked meals are provided for residents, reflecting a focus on nutrition and comfort.
  • pro Private rooms with private bathrooms and the cottage-style layout contribute to a comfortable living environment.
  • pro Staff across roles, including social workers, nurses, and therapists, are recognized for being helpful and attentive.

Cons

  • pro They describe Otterbein SeniorLife as a death trap and say it is not a genuine skilled nursing facility.
  • pro They claim their husband was not properly treated and died after about three weeks there, and they would never recommend the facility.
  • pro They say meals are not home-cooked and the nutrition quality is poor given the high cost.
  • pro They report cleanliness as inconsistent; rooms were not thoroughly cleaned between residents.
  • pro They state physical and occupational therapy lacked consistency and measurable progress, with dental care difficult to access.
  • pro They warn that medication management was minimal and reactive, with few in-person visits from the on-staff physician.
  • pro They note administration communication was poor; calls were often not returned and there was no outreach after the death.
  • pro They describe frontline staff as rude or inattentive, with aides slow to respond and often on their phones.
  • pro They accuse the facility of being severely understaffed, especially on weekends, leading to inadequate PT/OT and discharge planning.

Review

Otterbein New Albany is best suited for families seeking a home‑like, cottage‑style senior living option where private rooms and small-house living create a less institutional feel. This community appeals to residents who do not require constant, high‑intensity medical oversight but still need skilled rehab, daily assistance, and a social environment that mirrors family life. The layout, several small cottages, shared meals, and common spaces, can help a resident feel connected and less isolated during recovery or extended care. It works best when family members are willing to engage with the care team, monitor day‑to‑day operations, and advocate for consistent service. Those who prize a tranquil, residential ambiance may overlook some gaps in coverage, as the setting itself can soften the impact of uneven staffing and turnover. In short, this is a workable fit for a caregiver who values atmosphere and individual moments of compassionate care, while recognizing that reliability and medical rigor may fluctuate.

That reality means potential residents and their families should consider alternatives if continuous, predictable clinical oversight is nonnegotiable. Programs with proven, around‑the‑clock nursing adherence, rigorous medication management, and consistently prompt responses to calls may be a better match for those with complex medical needs, high risk of fall or infection, or dementia with challenging behaviors. Prospective residents who require highly coordinated multidisciplinary services, home health, dental, PT/OT with clear progress milestones, and steady in‑house physician access, could find Otterbein New Albany lacking in consistency. Families who cannot tolerate frequent staff turnover, uneven housekeeping, or periodic communication gaps should explicitly compare other nearby facilities where governance and workflow design prioritize steadier staffing and more proactive outreach.

The strongest positives hinge on human touch and a sense of “home.” Several frontline aides and nurses are repeatedly described as kind, patient, and genuinely caring, and there are meaningful examples of staff going the extra mile to honor residents’ dignity. The rehab component can be effective when therapists are available and integrated with care planning, and some reviewers note genuinely home‑cooked meals and a setting that feels more personable than a traditional institutional floor. These strengths matter, especially for residents who respond well to personal connection and a calmer living environment. Yet these advantages are frequently tempered by systemic gaps that undercut daily experience: inconsistent cleanliness, irregular access to grooming services, and meals that do not consistently meet expectations. When a resident’s day hinges on the reliability of a few beloved aides, the contrast between moments of excellence and periods of neglect becomes painfully apparent.

The most persisting concerns center on understaffing and communication failures that ripple through every facet of care. Families report long call‑bell response times, care delays, and shared staffing across cottages that dilute attention to individual residents. Medication management is repeatedly flagged as reactive rather than proactive, with delayed dosing and limited in‑person physician oversight cited as risks. Cleanliness and room turnover can fall short between resident changes, and multiple accounts describe disjointed coordination among therapists, nurses, and administration. When adverse events occur, falls, delays in pain control, missed treatments, or discharges arranged with insufficient preparation, the facility’s ability to recover quickly depends on administrative responsiveness, which some reviews indicate is uneven. These patterns, extrapolated across months and multiple families, overshadow the positives and illuminate why safety and consistency remain the central questions for most prospective residents.

For families navigating a decision, a disciplined due‑diligence plan is essential. Demand a transparent staffing snapshot: ratios by shift, turnover rates, and the availability of licensed nurses on evenings and weekends. Request a detailed rehab schedule with clearly defined goals, progress milestones, and a guaranteed minimum daily therapy window. Insist on a formal discharge planning process, with a specific, itemized medication list and a plan for continuity of care after return home. Tour rooms and common areas at different times to observe cleanliness, responsiveness, and resident engagement, and press for a tour of the pharmacy and dietary services to confirm consistency in medication handling and meal quality. Ask for a direct line of contact with the nurse manager or director of nursing, and test their responsiveness by leaving questions and noting the time to reply. Finally, compare menus, snack options, and protein sources to gauge whether meals meet basic nutritional expectations, especially for residents with chronic conditions.

Ultimately, Otterbein New Albany can deliver warmth, dignity, and meaningful rehab when staffing aligns and oversight is steady, but the reported variability in care quality makes risk management essential. For families who can be present, advocate actively, and require structured monitoring, paired with a willingness to switch plans if standards slip, this community can serve as a comfortable bridge between home and more intensive care. However, for those whose loved ones depend on consistently prompt medical attention, meticulous medication administration, and reliable, uninterrupted therapies, alternatives with stronger governance on weekends, tighter nurse coverage, and clearer accountability will likely yield greater peace of mind. In the end, the choice hinges on balancing the appeal of a homey, cottage vibe against the reality of staffing realities and the level of medical reliability that must accompany long‑term senior care.

Features

Housing

  • 50 resident community capacity 50 resident community capacity

Types of Care

  • Skilled Nursing Facility Skilled Nursing FacilitySkilled Nursing Facilities are crucial for seniors as they provide round-the-clock medical care, rehabilitation services, and assistance with daily activities. These facilities ensure that seniors receive the specialized care they need to maintain their health and well-being as they age.

Amenities

  • Beauty salon Beauty salonBeauty salons are important for seniors because they provide a space for them to feel pampered, socialize, and maintain their personal grooming and hygiene. Regular visits to a beauty salon can help boost seniors' self-esteem and overall well-being.
  • Cable or satellite TV Cable or satellite TVCable or satellite TV is important for seniors because it provides entertainment, news, and companionship, helping to combat loneliness and boredom. It also offers a wide range of programming options tailored to different interests and preferences.
  • Dining room Dining roomDining rooms are important for seniors as they provide a space for socialization, connection, and nutritious meals. They offer opportunities for residents to bond over shared meals, foster a sense of community, and promote healthy eating habits. Dining rooms also ensure that seniors have access to well-balanced meals tailored to their dietary needs and preferences.
  • Fully furnished Fully furnishedFully furnished senior living communities are important for seniors because they provide convenience, comfort, and a hassle-free moving experience. Seniors can easily settle into their new living space without the stress of having to buy and move furniture. This allows them to focus on enjoying their new home and community.
  • Garden GardenGardens are important for seniors as they provide a peaceful and therapeutic environment for relaxation, physical activity, and socialization. Being in nature has been shown to reduce stress, improve mood, and promote overall well-being. Gardens also offer opportunities for seniors to engage in gardening activities, which can improve mobility, flexibility, and cognitive function. Additionally, gardens create a sense of community and connection with others who share a passion for plants and outdoor spaces.
  • Housekeeping services Housekeeping servicesHousekeeping services are important for seniors because they help maintain a clean and safe living environment, promote independence, and reduce the risk of accidents or illnesses. Additionally, having assistance with household chores can alleviate physical strain and allow seniors to focus on other aspects of their well-being.
  • Kitchenette KitchenetteKitchenettes are important for seniors living in senior living communities because they provide the convenience and independence of being able to prepare simple meals and snacks in the comfort of their own living space. This can help promote a sense of autonomy and well-being for seniors, allowing them to maintain some level of control over their dietary choices and daily routines.
  • Move-in coordination Move-in coordinationMove-in coordination is important for seniors because it helps ease the transition into their new living environment. It ensures that all logistics, such as packing, organizing movers, and setting up utilities are taken care of, allowing seniors to focus on settling in and adjusting to their new home. Having a smooth move-in process can alleviate stress and anxiety, making the transition smoother and more enjoyable for seniors.
  • Outdoor space Outdoor spaceOutdoor spaces are important for seniors as they provide opportunities for physical activity, social interaction, exposure to natural light and fresh air, and a sense of connection to nature. Having access to outdoor spaces can improve overall well-being and quality of life for older adults living in senior communities.
  • Restaurant-style dining Restaurant-style diningRestaurant-style dining is important for seniors because it allows them to enjoy delicious, nutritious meals in a social and upscale setting. This enhances their dining experience, promotes healthy eating habits, and fosters socialization with fellow residents, ultimately contributing to their overall well-being and quality of life.
  • Small library Small librarySmall libraries are important for seniors as they provide access to a variety of reading materials, including books, newspapers, and magazines. This can help stimulate their minds, keep them engaged, and provide a sense of community through book clubs and other social activities. Additionally, reading has been shown to improve cognitive function and overall mental well-being in older adults.
  • Telephone TelephoneTelephones are important for seniors as they provide a lifeline for communication with loved ones, emergency services, and healthcare providers. They offer a sense of security and independence, enabling seniors to stay connected and access assistance when needed.
  • Wi-Fi/high-speed internet available Wi-Fi/high-speed internet availableWi-Fi/high-speed internet is important for seniors to stay connected with loved ones, access online resources, and participate in virtual activities to combat feelings of loneliness and isolation. It also allows them to easily manage healthcare needs, access entertainment, and engage in lifelong learning opportunities.

Transportation

  • John Glenn Columbus International Airport (7 miles away) John Glenn Columbus International Airport (7 miles away)

Care Services

  • 24-hour call system 24-hour call system24-hour call systems are important for seniors because they provide peace of mind and immediate assistance in case of emergencies. This technology ensures that help is always available, promoting safety and security for elderly individuals living alone or in assisted living facilities.
  • 24-hour supervision 24-hour supervision24-hour supervision is important for seniors to ensure their safety, well-being, and access to immediate assistance in case of emergencies or health issues. This constant support provides peace of mind for both seniors and their loved ones, allowing them to age in place with dignity and security.
  • Activities of daily living assistance Activities of daily living assistanceActivities of daily living assistance are important for seniors because they provide essential support with tasks such as eating, bathing, dressing, and mobility. This assistance helps seniors maintain their independence, dignity, and overall quality of life as they age.
  • Assistance with bathing Assistance with bathingAssistance with bathing is crucial for seniors as it helps maintain personal hygiene, prevents infections, and ensures their overall well-being and comfort. It also provides a sense of dignity and independence for seniors who may struggle with this task on their own.
  • Assistance with dressing Assistance with dressingAssistance with dressing is important for seniors because it helps maintain their independence, promotes personal hygiene, prevents accidents and injuries, and improves overall quality of life. This service ensures that seniors can continue to dress comfortably and confidently, despite any physical limitations they may have.
  • Assistance with transfers Assistance with transfersAssistance with transfers is crucial for seniors as it helps prevent falls and injuries, maintains their independence, and ensures they can safely navigate their living environment. It also provides peace of mind for both seniors and their loved ones.
  • Diabetes diet Diabetes dietA diabetes diet is crucial for seniors as it helps manage blood sugar levels, reduce risks of complications, and improve overall health and well-being. By following a balanced and nutritious diet tailored to their specific needs, seniors can better control their diabetes and enhance their quality of life.
  • High acuity care High acuity careHigh acuity care is important for seniors because it provides specialized medical attention and support for individuals with complex medical needs. This level of care ensures that seniors receive the appropriate treatment and assistance to maintain their health and quality of life as they age.
  • Meal preparation and service Meal preparation and serviceMeal preparation and service are crucial for seniors as they may have limited mobility or energy to cook nutritious meals. Having access to healthy and convenient food options can ensure they are getting the proper nutrition needed to maintain their overall health and well-being.
  • Medication management Medication managementMedication management is crucial for seniors to ensure they are taking the right medications at the correct dosages and times. This helps prevent adverse drug interactions, reduces the risk of medication errors, and promotes overall health and well-being. Proactive management also allows for adjustments as needed based on changing health conditions or new prescriptions.
  • Mental wellness program Mental wellness programMental wellness programs are essential for seniors as they promote cognitive stimulation, emotional support, and social engagement. These programs help prevent isolation, depression, and cognitive decline, ultimately enhancing the overall quality of life for older adults.
  • Special dietary restrictions Special dietary restrictionsSpecial dietary restrictions are important for seniors because age-related changes in metabolism and health conditions can make it difficult for their bodies to process certain foods. By following a diet tailored to their specific needs, seniors can maintain their overall health and well-being, manage chronic conditions, and reduce the risk of complications such as malnutrition or food interactions with medications.

Dining

  • Diabetes diet Diabetes dietA diabetes diet is crucial for seniors as it helps manage blood sugar levels, reduce risks of complications, and improve overall health and well-being. By following a balanced and nutritious diet tailored to their specific needs, seniors can better control their diabetes and enhance their quality of life.
  • Special dietary restrictions Special dietary restrictionsSpecial dietary restrictions are important for seniors because age-related changes in metabolism and health conditions can make it difficult for their bodies to process certain foods. By following a diet tailored to their specific needs, seniors can maintain their overall health and well-being, manage chronic conditions, and reduce the risk of complications such as malnutrition or food interactions with medications.

Activities

  • Community-sponsored activities Community-sponsored activitiesCommunity-sponsored activities are important for seniors as they provide opportunities for social interaction, mental stimulation, and physical activity. These activities can help improve overall well-being, combat loneliness and isolation, and promote a sense of belonging and purpose among older adults.
  • Resident-run activities Resident-run activitiesResident-run activities are important for seniors as they encourage social interaction, creativity, and a sense of autonomy. These activities empower seniors to stay engaged and active in their community while fostering meaningful connections with their peers.
  • Scheduled daily activities Scheduled daily activitiesScheduled daily activities are important for seniors because they provide structure, socialization, mental stimulation, and physical activity. Engaging in regular activities can improve overall well-being and quality of life for seniors living in a community setting.

Description

Otterbein New Albany in New Albany, OH is a premier assisted living community that offers a wide range of amenities and care services to ensure the comfort and well-being of its residents.

The community boasts cable or satellite TV, fully furnished accommodations, and Wi-Fi/high-speed internet access for residents to stay connected and entertained. Each resident can enjoy delicious meals in a spacious dining room or opt for restaurant-style dining. Additionally, there is a small library where residents can relax and immerse themselves in their favorite books.

For care services, Otterbein New Albany provides 24-hour supervision by trained staff who are always available to assist with daily living activities such as bathing, dressing, and transfers. The community also offers assistance with medication management and meal preparation according to special dietary restrictions, including diabetes diets.

Residents at Otterbein New Albany can engage in various activities throughout the day, both resident-run and scheduled daily activities organized by the community. This ensures that there is always something for everyone to enjoy and remain socially active.

Conveniently located nearby are two cafes, parks, pharmacies, physicians' offices, restaurants, places of worship, theaters, and hospitals. This allows residents easy access to necessary services and enriches their overall quality of life.

With its exceptional amenities and comprehensive care services, Otterbein New Albany in New Albany, OH is an outstanding choice for individuals seeking an assisted living community that prioritizes their comfort, health, and happiness.

Videos

Nearby Places of Interest

This part of New Albany, Ohio offers a variety of amenities and services that may be appealing for senior living. The area is home to a diverse range of restaurants, cafes, pharmacies, physicians, hospitals, parks, places of worship, and even a nearby airport for convenient travel options. Residents can enjoy dining options such as Roosters and The Goat New Albany, as well as healthcare facilities like Market District Pharmacy and Central Ohio Surgical Institute. For recreation and relaxation, parks like Thompson Park and Sharon Woods Metro Park offer green spaces for outdoor activities. Additionally, easy access to major transportation hubs like John Glenn Columbus International Airport provides opportunities for exploring other destinations. Overall, this neighborhood provides a well-rounded environment with essential conveniences for seniors looking to settle in a vibrant community.

Restaurants

  • Roosters (0.7 miles)
  • McDonald's (0.8 miles)
  • The Goat New Albany (0.8 miles)
  • Rusty Bucket Corner Tavern (1.4 miles)
  • Bibibop Asian Grill (2.6 miles)
  • The Barn at Rocky Fork Creek (2.7 miles)
  • First Watch (2.9 miles)

Pharmacies

  • Market District Pharmacy (0.7 miles)
  • Walgreens (1.1 miles)
  • CVS Pharmacy (1.6 miles)
  • Walgreens (2.5 miles)
  • CVS Pharmacy (3.6 miles)
  • CVS Pharmacy (3.7 miles)
  • CVS Pharmacy (3.9 miles)

Hospitals

  • Central Ohio Surgical Institute (1.2 miles)
  • Mount Carmel St Ann's OBGYN Clinic (6 miles)

Cafes

  • Fox in the Snow Cafe (1.6 miles)
  • Panera Bread (4.9 miles)
  • Northstar Cafe (5 miles)
  • Panera Bread (5.8 miles)
  • Starbucks (6.8 miles)
  • Starbucks (6.9 miles)
  • Starbucks (7.5 miles)

Physicians

  • New Albany Family Health (1.6 miles)
  • Mount Carmel Medical Group New Albany (1.6 miles)
  • B. Well Clinic Integrative Medicine (2.4 miles)
  • Advanced Dermatology & Skin Surgery Center (2.5 miles)
  • PrimeMD - Westerville Primary Care Walk-ins (5.6 miles)
  • Maureen Ann Stark (5.6 miles)
  • Stickel, Brian C DDS (5.7 miles)

Parks

  • Thompson Park (1.8 miles)
  • Centergreen Park (4.9 miles)
  • Sharon Woods Metro Park (6.4 miles)
  • Metzger Park (7 miles)
  • McNamara Park (7.3 miles)

Places of Worship

  • Westerville Christian Church (4.6 miles)
  • Faith Ministries Church (7.1 miles)

Theaters

  • Dreamscape at AMC Easton Town Center (5 miles)

Transportation

  • Concourse C (6.9 miles)
  • Concourse B (6.9 miles)
  • TSA Security Checkpoint B (7 miles)
  • TSA Pre-Check B (7 miles)
  • CMH Passenger Drop-off / Pick-up (7 miles)
  • TSA Security Checkpoint A (7 miles)
  • John Glenn Columbus International Airport (CMH) (7.1 miles)

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Otterbein New Albany?
What photos are available for Otterbein New Albany in New Albany, Ohio?

Nearby Communities

  • Our Family Home at Harlem Rd

    Our Family Home at Harlem Rd

    New Albany, OH

    5 from 1 review
    $4,000 to $7,350 / month

    pro Compassionate, dedicated staff delivering high-acuity memory care with comprehensive on-site amenities.

  • Albany Commons

    Albany Commons

    Westerville, OH

    4.6 from 107 reviews
    $740 to $845 / month

    pro Affordable pricing with active on-site programs and convenient access to nearby amenities.

  • Albany Woods

    Albany Woods

    New Albany, OH

    4.4 from 109 reviews
    $660 to $919 / month

    pro Extensive on-site and off-site activities with indoor and outdoor spaces plus a pool.

  • Spectrum Home Services of Greater Columbus

    Spectrum Home Services of Greater Columbus

    New Albany, OH

     
     

    pro Close access to cafes, parks, pharmacies, physicians, and hospitals.

  • The Woods at Sugar Run

    The Woods at Sugar Run

    New Albany, OH

    4.8 from 4 reviews
     

    pro Small, intimate community with personalized care and meal/medication services.

  • Wesley Woods at New Albany

    Wesley Woods at New Albany

    New Albany, OH

    4.2 from 51 reviews
     

    pro Comprehensive memory care with 24/7 supervision and specialized programming.

  • The Laurels Of Gahanna

    The Laurels Of Gahanna

    Columbus, OH

    3.2 from 95 reviews
     

    pro Caring, responsive staff and spacious, comfortable rooms.

  • Inniswood Village

    Inniswood Village

    Westerville, OH

    4.6 from 72 reviews
    $2,670 to $4,610 / month

    pro Beautiful, well-maintained community with friendly, engaging staff.

  • Rittenhouse Village Gahanna

    Rittenhouse Village Gahanna

    Gahanna, OH

    4.3 from 171 reviews
    $2,360 to $3,275 / month

    pro Friendly staff and a warm, engaging, clean environment.

Related Resources

  • pneumonia in elderlyEssential Knowledge on Pneumonia in Older Adults

    Pneumonia significantly affects older adults due to weakened immune systems and atypical symptoms that complicate diagnosis, necessitating early detection and tailored treatment. Risk factors include chronic diseases and cognitive impairments, with preventive measures like vaccinations and healthy lifestyles being crucial for reducing risk.

  • palliative care at homeExploring Palliative Care in the Home: A Comprehensive Overview

    Palliative care enhances the quality of life for seriously ill patients by providing comprehensive support at home through a multidisciplinary team, addressing various needs and prioritizing comfort over curative treatments. While it offers personalized care and involves family in decision-making, challenges like caregiver stress and logistical issues persist, with growing demand prompting advancements in technology and healthcare policies to improve access.

  • palliative care at homeComprehensive Insights into Palliative Home Care: What It Is and What to Expect

    Palliative home care focuses on improving the quality of life for individuals with serious illnesses by providing comfort, symptom management, and emotional support in their own homes. This approach includes personalized care plans, regular assessments, and resources for family caregivers, all while prioritizing person-centered treatment that aligns with patients' goals.