Hartfel House in Menomonee Falls, WI

Information last verified:

N88 W17630 Christman Road, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051

For more information about senior living options: (844) 490-3973

4.5 from 110 reviews
5 stars
78
4 stars
17
3 stars
9
2 stars
2
1 stars
4

Seniors.FYI Elite Community Awards

Top 5% Senior Living Community in 2026

Add this award to your website

Overall Review of Hartfel House

Pros

  • pro They enjoyed the burgers, fries, and healthy hash, appreciating the healthier option.
  • pro The atmosphere is fun, especially during game nights.
  • pro The whitefish was delicious, the atmosphere upbeat, and Jenny delivered fantastic service.
  • pro The place is beautiful, the service is great, and the food is good.
  • pro The cauliflower tacos and healthy hash were amazing, and the overall service was excellent.
  • pro The staff are super friendly and attentive.
  • pro Cheese curds were really good, and the chicken had great flavor and a perfect crunch.
  • pro They love this place—inside or outside, the atmosphere is beautiful and the food is wonderful, with friendly staff.
  • pro Sean at Hot House made their day with incredible service and positive vibes.
  • pro They had a fantastic birthday visit; Sean was the absolute best and made the night special.
  • pro Zach H was stellar; he offered great recommendations and the service was top notch.
  • pro The venue blends cool atmosphere, amazing food, and top-tier service, making it a go-to spot.

Cons

  • pro The food quality is inconsistent, with some dishes great and others bland.
  • pro The restaurant can be very noisy inside, and parking is scarce.
  • pro Deep-fried offerings are consistently overcooked and dry.
  • pro The mussels appetizer was spoiled, turning to mush and smelling like tuna.
  • pro The hot chicken sandwich arrived cold, and the coleslaw portion was tiny.
  • pro The kitchen was very slow, with food taking nearly 45 minutes to arrive.
  • pro The salmon meal was raw on the inside and made the diner sick.
  • pro The burger tasted and looked like it had been frozen.

Review

Hartfel House is best suited for families and residents who prize a lively, restaurant-like social scene as a core part of daily life. This community excels when dining and social events are treated as centerpiece experiences: a bustling dining room, outdoor patio options, trivia nights, and a consistently active atmosphere that keeps residents engaged. It suits individuals who enjoy observing a vibrant crowd, relish strong hospitality, and don’t mind the occasional higher-energy moments that come with a busy venue. Those who want serene, quiet meals and a meticulously predictable routine should look elsewhere, as the energy level here can swing from buzzing to loud, and that ambiance will dominate meal times. For families weighing options, Hartfel House is a compelling match for those who want companionship, connection, and plenty of options for shared meals and social outings.

On the flip side, several residents and families should explicitly consider alternatives. Quiet-minded seniors who prefer a calm dining room, soft background chatter, and minimal distractions will likely find the experience here too bustling. Those who require highly consistent meal quality week after week, with every dish arriving reliably perfect, may encounter enough variance to justify shopping alternatives. Parking can be tight during peak hours, and the kitchen’s pace can spike to accommodate crowds, which occasionally translates into longer waits or uneven food quality. If a care-focused, medically oriented program with highly controlled meals and strict adherence to routines is the priority, a different community with built-in medical staffing and a steadier rhythm will better meet expectations.

The strongest pros at Hartfel House lie in service, atmosphere, and culinary variety, all of which can meaningfully offset the main drawbacks. Several servers and bartenders, names that repeat across reviews, are consistently praised for attentiveness, warmth, and the ability to read a table’s needs without hovering. This level of hospitality helps residents feel seen and valued, turning ordinary meals into social events. The architectural charm and the energy of the space, reminiscent of a historic firehouse with garage-style doors, create a backdrop that makes meals feel like occasions rather than routine chores. The menu regularly earns kudos for both indulgent favorites and healthier choices, with items like cauliflower tacos and a health-forward hash offering options that align with varied dietary preferences. For families and residents who want a dynamic place to gather, these strengths can transform dining from a necessity into a highlight of the day.

Nevertheless, the common downsides are real and deserve planning. Food quality can be inconsistent, with some dishes clearly excellent and others disappointingly bland or overcooked, especially with fried items when the kitchen is pressed to speed up service. Service can wobble during busy periods, leading to longer than expected waits, misordered entrees, or intermittent lapses in table maintenance. Noise levels sometimes spike, complicating conversations and making evenings less comfortable for those who are easily overwhelmed by sound. Parking remains a practical friction point at peak times, and takeout experiences have varied, with a few patrons reporting disorganization or subpar presentation. For decision-making families, these patterns matter because they affect day-to-day satisfaction and the perceived value of the living environment.

In practical terms, Hartfel House delivers a compelling value for households prioritizing social engagement and gastronomic variety, while there are clear scenarios where alternatives may be preferable. For families planning regular large gatherings or celebrating special occasions, the venue-like ambiance and capacity to accommodate sizable groups stand out as major advantages. The grid of strong servers, often singled out by name, means that in the right moment, a resident can enjoy high-caliber service that elevates the dining experience beyond mere sustenance. The breadth of the menu, including healthful options and crowd-pleasing staples, gives caregivers a workable framework to tailor meals around dietary needs without sacrificing variety. In short, the pros often compensate for the cons when the goal is to create social, memorable dining moments in a lively setting.

The bottom-line verdict is pragmatic and decisive. Hartfel House will likely be the better fit for families seeking an active, hospitality-forward living experience with built-in opportunities for socialization, events, and expansive dining options. It rewards those who value a vibrant atmosphere and are willing to contend with occasional noise, busy rooms, and the occasional service hiccup in exchange for excellent moments of service and standout meals. For households where quiet evenings, ultra-predictable meal quality, or medical-focused daily routines are nonnegotiables, alternatives should be actively considered. The recommended approach is to visit during a non-peak window to gauge how the space feels when it’s calmer, request seating with a known high-performing server, and discuss dietary specifics in depth with the kitchen team. If a resident thrives on energy, connection, and the occasional culinary surprise, Hartfel House stands out as a thoughtful, capable choice worth embracing.

Features

Housing

  • 8 resident community capacity 8 resident community capacity

Types of Care

  • Assisted Living Assisted LivingAssisted living facilities provide crucial support and care for seniors who may need help with daily tasks such as medication management, bathing, and meal preparation. These communities offer a safe and comfortable environment where seniors can maintain their independence while receiving the assistance they need to thrive in their golden years.

Amenities

  • Cable or satellite TV Cable or satellite TVCable or satellite TV is important for seniors because it provides entertainment, news, and companionship, helping to combat loneliness and boredom. It also offers a wide range of programming options tailored to different interests and preferences.
  • Dining room Dining roomDining rooms are important for seniors as they provide a space for socialization, connection, and nutritious meals. They offer opportunities for residents to bond over shared meals, foster a sense of community, and promote healthy eating habits. Dining rooms also ensure that seniors have access to well-balanced meals tailored to their dietary needs and preferences.
  • Fully furnished Fully furnishedFully furnished senior living communities are important for seniors because they provide convenience, comfort, and a hassle-free moving experience. Seniors can easily settle into their new living space without the stress of having to buy and move furniture. This allows them to focus on enjoying their new home and community.
  • Garden GardenGardens are important for seniors as they provide a peaceful and therapeutic environment for relaxation, physical activity, and socialization. Being in nature has been shown to reduce stress, improve mood, and promote overall well-being. Gardens also offer opportunities for seniors to engage in gardening activities, which can improve mobility, flexibility, and cognitive function. Additionally, gardens create a sense of community and connection with others who share a passion for plants and outdoor spaces.
  • Housekeeping services Housekeeping servicesHousekeeping services are important for seniors because they help maintain a clean and safe living environment, promote independence, and reduce the risk of accidents or illnesses. Additionally, having assistance with household chores can alleviate physical strain and allow seniors to focus on other aspects of their well-being.
  • Move-in coordination Move-in coordinationMove-in coordination is important for seniors because it helps ease the transition into their new living environment. It ensures that all logistics, such as packing, organizing movers, and setting up utilities are taken care of, allowing seniors to focus on settling in and adjusting to their new home. Having a smooth move-in process can alleviate stress and anxiety, making the transition smoother and more enjoyable for seniors.
  • Outdoor space Outdoor spaceOutdoor spaces are important for seniors as they provide opportunities for physical activity, social interaction, exposure to natural light and fresh air, and a sense of connection to nature. Having access to outdoor spaces can improve overall well-being and quality of life for older adults living in senior communities.
  • Telephone TelephoneTelephones are important for seniors as they provide a lifeline for communication with loved ones, emergency services, and healthcare providers. They offer a sense of security and independence, enabling seniors to stay connected and access assistance when needed.
  • Wi-Fi/high-speed internet available Wi-Fi/high-speed internet availableWi-Fi/high-speed internet is important for seniors to stay connected with loved ones, access online resources, and participate in virtual activities to combat feelings of loneliness and isolation. It also allows them to easily manage healthcare needs, access entertainment, and engage in lifelong learning opportunities.

Transportation

  • General Mitchell International (20 miles away) General Mitchell International (20 miles away)

Care Services

  • 24-hour supervision 24-hour supervision24-hour supervision is important for seniors to ensure their safety, well-being, and access to immediate assistance in case of emergencies or health issues. This constant support provides peace of mind for both seniors and their loved ones, allowing them to age in place with dignity and security.
  • Activities of daily living assistance Activities of daily living assistanceActivities of daily living assistance are important for seniors because they provide essential support with tasks such as eating, bathing, dressing, and mobility. This assistance helps seniors maintain their independence, dignity, and overall quality of life as they age.
  • Assistance with bathing Assistance with bathingAssistance with bathing is crucial for seniors as it helps maintain personal hygiene, prevents infections, and ensures their overall well-being and comfort. It also provides a sense of dignity and independence for seniors who may struggle with this task on their own.
  • Assistance with dressing Assistance with dressingAssistance with dressing is important for seniors because it helps maintain their independence, promotes personal hygiene, prevents accidents and injuries, and improves overall quality of life. This service ensures that seniors can continue to dress comfortably and confidently, despite any physical limitations they may have.
  • Assistance with transfers Assistance with transfersAssistance with transfers is crucial for seniors as it helps prevent falls and injuries, maintains their independence, and ensures they can safely navigate their living environment. It also provides peace of mind for both seniors and their loved ones.
  • Coordination with health care providers Coordination with health care providersCoordination with health care providers is crucial for seniors to ensure proper medical care, medication management, and overall well-being. This collaboration helps prevent overlapping treatments, track progress more effectively, and provide comprehensive support tailored to individual needs.
  • Diabetes diet Diabetes dietA diabetes diet is crucial for seniors as it helps manage blood sugar levels, reduce risks of complications, and improve overall health and well-being. By following a balanced and nutritious diet tailored to their specific needs, seniors can better control their diabetes and enhance their quality of life.
  • Meal preparation and service Meal preparation and serviceMeal preparation and service are crucial for seniors as they may have limited mobility or energy to cook nutritious meals. Having access to healthy and convenient food options can ensure they are getting the proper nutrition needed to maintain their overall health and well-being.
  • Medication management Medication managementMedication management is crucial for seniors to ensure they are taking the right medications at the correct dosages and times. This helps prevent adverse drug interactions, reduces the risk of medication errors, and promotes overall health and well-being. Proactive management also allows for adjustments as needed based on changing health conditions or new prescriptions.
  • Special dietary restrictions Special dietary restrictionsSpecial dietary restrictions are important for seniors because age-related changes in metabolism and health conditions can make it difficult for their bodies to process certain foods. By following a diet tailored to their specific needs, seniors can maintain their overall health and well-being, manage chronic conditions, and reduce the risk of complications such as malnutrition or food interactions with medications.
  • Transportation arrangement (medical) Transportation arrangement (medical)Transportation arrangements for medical purposes are essential for seniors as they may have difficulty driving themselves to appointments or accessing public transportation. Having reliable and safe transportation options ensures that seniors can receive timely medical care and maintain their health and well-being.
  • Transportation to doctors appointments Transportation to doctors appointmentsTransportation to doctors' appointments is crucial for seniors as it ensures they have access to necessary medical care and support for their health needs. Without reliable transportation, seniors may struggle to attend important appointments, leading to potential delays in treatment and health complications. Providing transportation services helps seniors maintain their overall well-being and quality of life.

Dining

  • Diabetes diet Diabetes dietA diabetes diet is crucial for seniors as it helps manage blood sugar levels, reduce risks of complications, and improve overall health and well-being. By following a balanced and nutritious diet tailored to their specific needs, seniors can better control their diabetes and enhance their quality of life.
  • Special dietary restrictions Special dietary restrictionsSpecial dietary restrictions are important for seniors because age-related changes in metabolism and health conditions can make it difficult for their bodies to process certain foods. By following a diet tailored to their specific needs, seniors can maintain their overall health and well-being, manage chronic conditions, and reduce the risk of complications such as malnutrition or food interactions with medications.

Activities

  • Community-sponsored activities Community-sponsored activitiesCommunity-sponsored activities are important for seniors as they provide opportunities for social interaction, mental stimulation, and physical activity. These activities can help improve overall well-being, combat loneliness and isolation, and promote a sense of belonging and purpose among older adults.
  • Scheduled daily activities Scheduled daily activitiesScheduled daily activities are important for seniors because they provide structure, socialization, mental stimulation, and physical activity. Engaging in regular activities can improve overall well-being and quality of life for seniors living in a community setting.

Description

Hartfel House in Menomonee Falls, WI is an assisted living community that offers a range of amenities and care services to provide a comfortable and supportive environment for its residents. The community features a spacious dining room where residents can enjoy delicious meals prepared by the staff. Each living space is fully furnished with all the necessary items to ensure convenience and comfort.

Hartfel House also boasts a beautiful garden and outdoor space where residents can relax, socialize, or engage in various activities. The community provides housekeeping services to ensure that the living spaces are always clean and well-maintained.

Residents at Hartfel House receive assistance with their daily activities such as bathing, dressing, and transfers. The dedicated staff coordinates with health care providers to ensure that residents receive the necessary medical attention and support. For individuals with diabetes or special dietary restrictions, the community offers specialized meal preparation and service.

Transportation arrangements are available for medical appointments, ensuring that residents can easily access healthcare facilities when needed. In addition to this, there are several nearby amenities including cafes, parks, pharmacies, restaurants, theaters, and hospitals. Residents can explore these establishments or take part in scheduled daily activities organized by Hartfel House.

Overall, Hartfel House in Menomonee Falls provides a nurturing environment where seniors can receive personalized care while enjoying a range of amenities and nearby conveniences.

Nearby Places of Interest

Theaters

  • Menomonee Falls Cinema Menomonee Falls, Wi (0.6 miles)

Restaurants

  • Qdoba Mexican Eats (0.9 miles)
  • Hot House Tavern (0.9 miles)
  • Culver's (1 miles)
  • Arby's (1.1 miles)
  • McDonald's (1.2 miles)
  • Su Casa Grande (1.5 miles)
  • Robert's Frozen Custard (3.3 miles)

Physicians

  • Town Hall Health Center (0.9 miles)
  • Froedtert Orthopaedic, Sports and Spine Center (1.6 miles)
  • Advanced Health Care (3 miles)
  • Froedtert Germantown Health Center (3.2 miles)
  • Shaibal Mazumdar MD (4.9 miles)
  • Aurora Advanced Healthcare (4.9 miles)
  • Froedtert Sussex Health Center (6.1 miles)

Cafes

  • Starbucks (1.5 miles)
  • Starbucks (6.1 miles)
  • Starbucks (7 miles)

Pharmacies

  • Walgreens (1.6 miles)
  • CVS Pharmacy (1.7 miles)
  • Walgreens (3.5 miles)
  • Walgreens (4.3 miles)
  • Aurora Pharmacy (4.9 miles)
  • Walgreens (5.9 miles)
  • Pick 'n Save Pharmacy (6 miles)

Parks

  • Menomonee Park (2.7 miles)
  • Kinderberg Park (3 miles)
  • Imperial Estate Park (5.3 miles)
  • Richfield Nature Park (7.3 miles)
  • Fox Brook Park (7.4 miles)
  • A C Hanson Park (7.4 miles)
  • Lake Park Park (7.5 miles)

Hospitals

  • Ambulatory EEG Recordings (4.8 miles)
  • Rogers Memorial Hospital (8.4 miles)

Places of Worship

  • Northwest Baptist Church (7.8 miles)
  • Redemption Lutheran Church (8 miles)

Transportation

  • U-Haul Moving & Storage (7.9 miles)

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Hartfel House?

Nearby Communities

  • Messner Manor

    Messner Manor

    Menomonee Falls, WI

    2 from 3 reviews
     

    pro Peaceful, convenient location with nearby parks, dining, healthcare, and entertainment.

  • Vista Pointe

    Vista Pointe

    Menomonee Falls, WI

    4.2 from 31 reviews
    $4,500 to $5,000 / month

    pro Attentive staff, good dining, and a clean, engaging environment.

  • Vista Pointe II

    Vista Pointe II

    Menomonee Falls, WI

    4.3 from 14 reviews
     

    pro Specialized memory care with 24/7 supervision and cognitive programming.

  • Menomonee Place

    Menomonee Place

    Menomonee Falls, WI

    4.3 from 40 reviews
    $1,763 to $3,617 / month

    pro Safe, clean environment with friendly staff and ample on-site amenities.

  • Menomonee Falls Health Services

    Menomonee Falls Health Services

    Menomonee Falls, WI

    3.5 from 32 reviews
     

    pro Private furnished apartments with private baths, restaurant-style dining, 24/7 supervision, and robust activities and transportation services.

  • Extendicare at Menomonee Falls

    Extendicare at Menomonee Falls

    Menomonee Falls, WI

    3.3 from 12 reviews
    $6,750 to $9,450 / month

    pro Caring staff with engaging activities and notable improvements under new administration.

  • Riverview Village Senior Living

    Riverview Village Senior Living

    Menomonee Falls, WI

    3.6 from 111 reviews
    $4,430 / month

    pro Warm, welcoming atmosphere with caring staff, good dining, and engaging activities.

  • The Arboretum

    The Arboretum

    Menomonee Falls, WI

    3.9 from 114 reviews
    $1,300 to $2,000 / month

    pro Friendly, caring staff and a strong sense of community with engaging activities.

  • Grace Commons

    Grace Commons

    Menomonee Falls, WI

    4.5 from 49 reviews
     

    pro Beautiful, modern facility with restaurant-style dining and attentive staff.

Related Resources

  • assisted living costUnderstanding the True Cost of Assisted Living in 2025: A Comprehensive Guide

    Assisted living in 2025 offers a crucial balance of independence and support for seniors, with costs varying from $2,500 to over $7,000 per month based on factors such as location and care level. Understanding pricing complexities, including regional differences and potential hidden fees, is essential for families to plan financially while ensuring quality care for their loved ones.

  • does medicaid pay for assisted livingUnderstanding Medicaid Coverage for Assisted Living: A Comprehensive Guide

    The guide outlines the complexities of Medicaid coverage for assisted living, highlighting significant state-to-state variations, limited coverage often restricted to personal care services, and the existence of specialized waivers for certain needs like memory care. It advises families to consult local Medicaid offices for options while emphasizing the importance of understanding state-specific regulations and facility policies.

  • does medicaid pay for assisted livingHow and When Medicaid May Cover Assisted Living Costs

    Medicaid coverage for assisted living varies by state and is primarily available to low-income individuals, with eligibility dependent on strict income and asset limits. Some states offer HCBS waivers for specific services in assisted living, but families must generally cover room and board costs, and should verify facility acceptance of Medicaid while considering potential waiting lists.