Extendicare at Menomonee Falls

Skilled Nursing Facilities with a similar price nearby

• from -$250 / mo

  Lakewood Transitional Assisted Living and Memory Care

  4.8 from 61 reviews

  $6,500 to $7,600 / month

  5.4 miles away
• from -$452 / mo

  Newcastle Place, a CCRC

  4.6 from 177 reviews

  $6,298 to $8,724 / month

  11.4 miles away
• from -$1285 / mo

  Lutheran Home Adult Day Services

  3.5 from 48 reviews

  $5,465 to $6,315 / month

  9.5 miles away
• from -$958 / mo

  Dycora Transitional Health - Glendale

  3.6 from 55 reviews

  $5,792 / month

  10.4 miles away
• from -$600 / mo

  Maple Ridge

  3.5 from 41 reviews

  $6,150 / month

  18.2 miles away

Pros

• Bev was amazing and consistently willing to assist residents and their families.
• The staff were attentive to residents' needs and therapy was excellent.
• The new administration has made great changes, with newly remodeled rooms and a friendly, caring staff, plus a therapy dog on site.
• The staff were friendly, interactive, and knowledgeable, and residents were kept clean, well-dressed, and engaged in activities.
• The facility is in a safe area with ample parking and offers good, varied food.
• The activity department is great, and the staff are good people.
• In-person visitation has started, improving family connections with the facility.
• The therapy dog on staff is a great addition to the building and well loved by residents.

Cons

• The facility has very poor management and disrespectful managers.
• The aides are disrespectful, and there are too many bad apples among the staff.
• Some staff members walk by without speaking and do not engage with residents.
• Call lights go unanswered for long periods due to staffing shortages.
• The environment can be noisy, making sleep difficult for residents.
• The building is old and in need of updates; the overall condition is austere.
• The meals are misrepresented as gourmet, with portions that feel insufficient for adults.
• Wrong medications have been given to patients, and vital-sign equipment is unreliable or uncalibrated.
• Linens are not changed for seven days, and restrooms lack locks.

Review

Extendicare at Menomonee Falls is best suited for seniors who need skilled nursing and rehabilitation in a straightforward, value-focused setting. It works for families navigating Medicaid and seeking reliable daily care without a luxury price tag. The care quality is steady, with attentive aides, capable nurses, and therapists who help residents regain strength. The new administration has updated rooms, added a therapy dog, and expanded activity options. The building is older but well kept, and the location offers easy parking and safe access for visits. For families prioritizing practical care, predictable routines, and hands-on staff support over boutique amenities, this community stands up well.

Those who should consider alternatives are families who demand a pristine, modern environment or flawless staffing 24/7. Reviews describe an older building with wear, and on some days short-staffed teams leading to slow response to call bells. There are troubling accounts of management gaps and disrespectful behavior by some aides, plus reliance on temporary agency staff with uneven training. If a perfectly calm atmosphere, consistent leadership, and single-room privacy are non-negotiables, it may be wise to look at other options with stronger oversight and newer facilities.

Yet the positives carry real weight. The strongest pro line is staff responsiveness and care: a social worker who helps with Medicaid transitions, an administrator who addresses concerns, and consistently attentive therapy teams. Rehab and activities keep residents engaged, and the presence of a therapy dog adds identifiable warmth. Some rooms have been remodeled, and cleanliness remains a common theme in visits. The combination of capable care and a structured program creates meaningful recovery outcomes and social engagement that can offset the buildingā€™s age.

Nevertheless, recurring concerns warrant serious consideration. Staffing gaps on certain shifts translate into delayed help and unsettled call-bell times. Some residents report unfriendly behavior or dismissive attitudes from a few staff members. There are alarming anecdotes about shared bathrooms without locks and inconsistencies in medication administration. The buildingā€™s age shows in spaces that could be quieter or better temperature-controlled. Taken together, these problems can erode trust if not actively managed, especially for residents with dementia or limited mobility who rely on prompt, respectful assistance.

To decide, request a detailed, shift-by-shift tour and speak with frontline staff about typical response times. Ask how agency staff are integrated, what changes have been made to improve call-light responsiveness, and how concerns are tracked and corrected. Inspect room options, verify climate controls, and sample the dining experience. Confirm Medicaid navigation support and request references from families with similar care needs. A thorough evaluation should also review rehab space, therapy throughput, and the schedule of supervised activities to ensure alignment with the residentā€™s goals.

Overall, Extendicare at Menomonee Falls offers solid, practical care in an accessible, lower-frills setting. It can be a strong fit for families seeking dependable rehabilitation, consistent daily care, and active engagement at a reasonable cost. It is less suitable for those who require a high-end environment, perfectly consistent staffing, and consistently flawless execution. For families weighing options, this community deserves serious consideration, provided due diligence is completed, expectations are aligned with reality, and a plan is in place to monitor care quality over time.