Keystone Manor in Sayre, PA

Pros

• The reviewer regards the place as okay.

Cons

• The place is a hell hole now.
• They don’t clean the handrails on any floor.
• They won’t wait for residents to answer their own doors.
• They let people move items that shouldn’t be left unsupervised.
• There is a lot of theft.
• They can no longer hang things in the hall because they will be taken.
• Residents can no longer control the heat in their own apartments.
• They knock and then just let themselves in.
• The head of maintenance yelled at residents to move.
• Residents are berated for requesting replacements for their stoves.
• Residents are charged for everything.
• This place has gone way downhill.

Review

Keystone Manor in Sayre, PA appears best suited for seniors who want apartment-style living with a degree of independence and a contained budget, but who can tolerate inconsistent service and limited oversight. It is not a setting for those needing regular, hands-on assistance or a highly supervised daily routine. For residents who value access to a basic bus route and the conveniences of a small-town location, the property may feel convenient on collateral terms, yet the day-to-day experience is likely to be uneven and unsettling rather than reassuring.

Families evaluating this community should consider alternatives if cleanliness, safety, and staff reliability are non-negotiable. Multiple red flags emerge in the reviews: routine neglect of essential cleaning tasks (such as handrails on multiple floors), intrusive staff behavior at the door, and a troubling pattern of unsupervised or poorly supervised resident movement. The perception of theft and the implication that belongings may not be secure further undercuts the sense of a safe, respectful home. If a resident depends on consistent housekeeping, predictable safety, and staff who treat residents with courtesy, Keystone Manor is a risky bet.

The few listed positives, availability of bus transportation and the possibility of basic, independent living within a managed building, do not come close to offsetting the core drawbacks. When cleanliness is irregular, security feels fragile, and everyday interactions with staff can be hostile or coercive, independent living is tempered by anxiety about what will be missed or mishandled next. The core appeal of an affordable, low-cost option is undermined by reports of rising charges for routine services and the shrinking scope of what is included, transforming what should feel like a straightforward lease into a moving target of hidden costs and policy shifts.

A recurring theme across the commentary is decline: phrases like “gone way downhill” and “hell hole” signal a broader deterioration in maintenance culture, resident safety, and overall quality of life. When maintenance personnel confront residents or when doors are not respected as secure entry points, the risk calculus shifts markedly. The credibility of management is called into question by alleged loud, dismissive responses and the sense that basic expectations, like timely stove replacements or properly functioning heat controls, are variable rather than guaranteed. In short, the negative experiences are not isolated incidents; they reflect a pattern that many families would rightly weigh against any potential short-term savings.

For families seriously weighing Keystone Manor, practical due diligence matters most. Visiting at different times of day to assess cleanliness, responsiveness, and the demeanor of front-line staff is essential. Inquire about actual heat control mechanisms in individual apartments, confirm how door access and supervision are handled after hours, and probe the security framework to deter theft or unauthorized access. Request a transparent, written fee schedule that clearly delineates what is included and what triggers additional charges. Speak with current residents about maintenance responsiveness, safety, and the overall quality of life. And insist on reference checks with families who have recently navigated exits or transfers from the community to understand real-world dynamics beyond the marketing narrative.

Ultimately, Keystone Manor is not a fit for families prioritizing dependable care, consistent cleanliness, and a respectful, professional housing environment. It may hold appeal for those who can tolerate a lean, budget-conscious option and who value transport access, but the risks are substantial: ongoing cleanliness lapses, insecure environments, erratic and sometimes confrontational staff interactions, and a fee structure that can erode value over time. For most seniors and their families seeking stable, dignified, and predictable housing with adequate safety and service, alternative communities with stronger housekeeping, clearer policies, and a proven track record of respectful care are strongly advisable.

This part of Sayre, Pennsylvania, offers a wide range of amenities that cater to senior living needs. With multiple pharmacies in close proximity, accessing medication and healthcare services is convenient. There are also several reputable physicians' offices and a hospital within a short distance, ensuring quality medical care is easily accessible. In terms of dining options, there are various restaurants offering different cuisines to suit every preference. Places of worship are abundant in the area, providing spiritual fulfillment for residents. Additionally, transportation options such as car rentals and U-Haul services make it easy for seniors to travel when needed. The presence of parks nearby allows for outdoor recreational activities, while cafes offer a cozy setting for socializing with friends. Overall, this part of Sayre provides a well-rounded environment for seniors seeking a comfortable and convenient place to live.

Restaurants

• Sam's Bar & Grill (0.1 miles)
• McDonald's (0.2 miles)
• Original Italian Grille (0.4 miles)
• Becky's Diner (0.9 miles)
• Lehigh Tavern (1 miles)
• Coaches Pizza (1 miles)
• Soprano's Italian Market (1 miles)

Pharmacies

• CVS Pharmacy (0.2 miles)
• Waverly Pharmacy (0.7 miles)
• Waverly Pharmacy (0.9 miles)
• Twin Tier (1 miles)
• Clinic Pharmacy Guthrie (1 miles)
• Rite Aid (1 miles)
• Walmart Pharmacy (1.3 miles)

Physicians

• Guthrie Pediatric Center (0.2 miles)
• Guthrie Sayre (0.6 miles)
• Guthrie Robert Packer Hospital (0.6 miles)
• Dr Alley's Office (0.8 miles)
• Guthrie Otolaryngology - Sayre (1 miles)
• Guthrie Walk-In Care - Sayre (1 miles)
• Guthrie Wound Care & Hyperbaric Medicine (1 miles)

Transportation

• Williams Auto Rental (0.8 miles)
• Alamo (2.6 miles)
• U-Haul (10.6 miles)
• Dreck's Taxidermy (14.4 miles)
• U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer (14.4 miles)

Places of Worship

• Grace Episcopal Church (0.9 miles)
• First Presbyterian Church (1 miles)
• St James Parish (1.1 miles)
• Christian & Missionary Alliance Church (1.2 miles)
• Southern Baptist Convention (1.2 miles)
• Sayre Christian Church (1.2 miles)
• Kingdom Hall of Jehovah S Witnesses (1.6 miles)

Hospitals

• Guthrie Healthcare System (0.9 miles)
• Memorial Hospital (15.1 miles)
• Personal Care Home Of Memorial Hospital (15.1 miles)

Parks

• Round Top Recreation Area (2.9 miles)
• Miller's Pond Park & Playground (14.7 miles)
• Mt. Pisgah (15 miles)

Cafes

• Owego Soft Serve (6.2 miles)