The Manors at The Colony Preserve in Shirley, NY

Information last verified:

333 William Floyd Parkway, Shirley, NY 11967

For more information about senior living options: (844) 490-3973

4.1 from 24 reviews
5 stars
16
4 stars
2
3 stars
2
2 stars
0
1 stars
4

Overall Review of The Manors at The Colony Preserve

Pros

  • pro The location is nice with lots of new developments underway.
  • pro It offers a private location with gated access.
  • pro There is a huge clubhouse with ample equipment to use.
  • pro The staff are friendly and the amenities are good.
  • pro The community is nice for retirement, with great amenities and friendly residents.
  • pro It is beautiful and quiet, offering peace with minimal noise.
  • pro The gated community is beautiful with nicely maintained lawns.
  • pro The condos are very nice in a gated community, and the residents are friendly.

Cons

  • pro The staff have been deceitful and evasive about the completion date.
  • pro A unit purchased almost two years ago has not yet been delivered.
  • pro Deceitful practices are alleged to be their business model.
  • pro Completion dates were repeatedly pushed out by a couple of months, now at 23 months and counting.
  • pro They are incurring substantial storage and rent costs due to the delays.
  • pro The entrance is terribly bumpy.

Review

The Manors at The Colony Preserve is best suited for active adults 55 and older who prize a gated, private setting with a strong sense of community, abundant amenities, and a quiet, resort-like atmosphere. It targets buyers who want a contemporary, amenity-rich condo lifestyle and are comfortable with a developing project that is still bringing in phases and infrastructure. For families seeking an immediate move-in, or buyers who cannot tolerate an extended timeline, this is not the stand-alone solution to pick right away.

Those considering alternatives should note a few red flags that matter in decision-making. Prospective buyers who need to close quickly or move in within months will likely face frustration, as delivery timelines have stretched well beyond initial promises. The sales experience has included warnings about evasive updates and shifting completion dates, which can translate into storage costs, rent, and the psychological strain of uncertainty. If curb appeal and a finished product now are nonnegotiable, this community warrants caution. Additionally, a sense of ongoing construction risk, especially in Phase 2, means road quality and daily access can be imperfect during the interim.

On the upside, the core advantages are compelling and durable. The location is clearly advantageous: a private, gated enclave with a generous clubhouse and substantial recreation options that can sustain an active social life and varied leisure activities. Residents consistently describe the neighborhood as beautiful, quiet, and well-suited to those who value peaceful surroundings and a friendly, neighborly vibe. The scale of amenities and the perceived security of a gated setting can offset the need for frequent trips off-site, making it attractive to residents who want convenience and a built-in social structure.

The most serious drawbacks center on timing and reliability. The most frequently cited pain point is a prolonged delivery and completion window for units, with some buyers experiencing nearly two years of waiting and ongoing uncertainty about when homes will be finished. Reports of deceitful or evasive communication about milestones amplify the risk, and not all buyers can absorb the costs associated with extended temporary housing, storage, or rent while waiting for possession. In addition, entrance quality and road conditions have been noted as areas needing attention, hinting at ongoing maintenance costs and minor daily irritants that accompany a still-maturing, developing project.

When weighing pros against cons, the positives tend to bolster a reasonable case for patience and long-term value, but only if solid protections and a clear, written path to completion are in place. If the contract includes firm, enforceable milestones, escrow or holdbacks that reflect realistic delivery dates, and a plan for interim living arrangements, the favorable social environment, security, and facilities can justify the wait. Prospective buyers should insist on speaking to current residents, verify the status of Phase 2 and road improvements, and demand transparent timelines from the sales team. A prudent approach also includes budgeting for storage, interim housing, and potential escalations, recognizing these costs are the flip side of the delayed move-in.

In the end, this community is a strong match for buyers who want a beautiful, quiet, gated setting with substantial amenities and a welcoming resident culture, and who can tolerate a prolonged path to full occupancy. If immediate occupancy, predictable maintenance, and guaranteed completion dates are non-negotiable, alternatives in the area should be pursued. For the right buyer, the wait can be worthwhile: the social capital, the clubhouse energy, and the overall quality of living can exceed the initial upheaval of a delayed delivery, provided there is due diligence, clear contracts, and a proactive plan to manage the timeline.

Features

Housing

  • 6 resident community capacity 6 resident community capacity

Types of Care

  • Active Adult Communities (55+) Active Adult Communities (55+)Active Adult Communities provide seniors with opportunities for socialization, activities, and wellness programs tailored to their needs. These communities offer a sense of belonging and security while promoting an active and independent lifestyle for those aged 55 and older.

Amenities

  • Housekeeping services Housekeeping servicesHousekeeping services are important for seniors because they help maintain a clean and safe living environment, promote independence, and reduce the risk of accidents or illnesses. Additionally, having assistance with household chores can alleviate physical strain and allow seniors to focus on other aspects of their well-being.
  • Telephone TelephoneTelephones are important for seniors as they provide a lifeline for communication with loved ones, emergency services, and healthcare providers. They offer a sense of security and independence, enabling seniors to stay connected and access assistance when needed.
  • Wi-Fi/high-speed internet available Wi-Fi/high-speed internet availableWi-Fi/high-speed internet is important for seniors to stay connected with loved ones, access online resources, and participate in virtual activities to combat feelings of loneliness and isolation. It also allows them to easily manage healthcare needs, access entertainment, and engage in lifelong learning opportunities.

Transportation

  • Long Island - MacArthur (12 miles away) Long Island - MacArthur (12 miles away)

Care Services

  • Assistance with dressing Assistance with dressingAssistance with dressing is important for seniors because it helps maintain their independence, promotes personal hygiene, prevents accidents and injuries, and improves overall quality of life. This service ensures that seniors can continue to dress comfortably and confidently, despite any physical limitations they may have.
  • Meal preparation and service Meal preparation and serviceMeal preparation and service are crucial for seniors as they may have limited mobility or energy to cook nutritious meals. Having access to healthy and convenient food options can ensure they are getting the proper nutrition needed to maintain their overall health and well-being.
  • Medication management Medication managementMedication management is crucial for seniors to ensure they are taking the right medications at the correct dosages and times. This helps prevent adverse drug interactions, reduces the risk of medication errors, and promotes overall health and well-being. Proactive management also allows for adjustments as needed based on changing health conditions or new prescriptions.

Dining

  • Diabetes diet Diabetes dietA diabetes diet is crucial for seniors as it helps manage blood sugar levels, reduce risks of complications, and improve overall health and well-being. By following a balanced and nutritious diet tailored to their specific needs, seniors can better control their diabetes and enhance their quality of life.
  • Special dietary restrictions Special dietary restrictionsSpecial dietary restrictions are important for seniors because age-related changes in metabolism and health conditions can make it difficult for their bodies to process certain foods. By following a diet tailored to their specific needs, seniors can maintain their overall health and well-being, manage chronic conditions, and reduce the risk of complications such as malnutrition or food interactions with medications.

Description

The Manors at The Colony Preserve in Shirley, NY is an assisted living community designed to provide comfort and support for seniors. With a range of amenities and care services, residents can enjoy a worry-free lifestyle.

For those who like to stay connected, the community offers telephone and Wi-Fi/high-speed internet access, allowing residents to keep in touch with loved ones and engage in online activities.

Meal preparation and service are included as part of the care services provided at The Manors. Experienced staff members ensure that residents receive well-balanced and nutritious meals catered to their dietary needs. Special dietary restrictions are also taken into consideration, ensuring that every resident's needs are met.

Residents at The Manors can rest easy knowing that medication management is available to them. Trained staff members assist with medication reminders and administration, promoting safety and wellness among residents.

In terms of convenience, there are several nearby amenities that make life easier for residents. With 1 cafe nearby, residents can enjoy a relaxing cup of coffee or socialize with friends without having to travel far. Additionally, there are 8 pharmacies nearby, ensuring easy access to medications and healthcare supplies. For medical needs, there are 3 physicians located conveniently close by.

When it comes to dining options, The Manors has you covered with 5 restaurants nearby. Residents have the opportunity to explore different cuisines and enjoy meals outside of the community if desired.

Transportation is made simple with 2 transportation options located nearby. Whether residents need assistance getting around town or arranging trips for appointments or social outings, they can rely on these convenient transportation services.

Overall, The Manors at The Colony Preserve in Shirley, NY provides a comfortable and supportive environment for seniors where they can enjoy a range of amenities and care services while being conveniently located near various amenities in the surrounding area.

Nearby Places of Interest

Pharmacies

  • Walgreens (0.7 miles)
  • CVS Pharmacy (0.8 miles)
  • Walgreens (2.1 miles)
  • CVS Pharmacy (2.1 miles)
  • Stop & Shop Pharmacy (2.4 miles)
  • CVS Pharmacy (4 miles)
  • King Kullen (4 miles)

Restaurants

  • Moriches Bay Diner (3.5 miles)
  • Avino's Italian Table (3.9 miles)
  • Peter's on the Green (4.3 miles)
  • Bellport Country Club (4.4 miles)
  • Lucharitos Lucharitos (4.7 miles)
  • McDonald's (6.2 miles)
  • George's Luncheonette (6.8 miles)

Cafes

  • Bellport General (3.9 miles)
  • Starbucks (7.6 miles)
  • Starbucks (7.7 miles)
  • Starbucks (8.6 miles)

Physicians

  • Stony Brook Pediatric Specialty Services (3.9 miles)
  • Timothy D Groth, MDPC (4.9 miles)
  • Bab Radiology (4.9 miles)
  • Advanced Orthopedics (5.5 miles)
  • SightMD (5.7 miles)
  • Doctors Office (5.8 miles)
  • East Moriches Primary Care (5.8 miles)

Transportation

  • Bellport Railroad Station (4 miles)
  • LIRR - Yaphank Station (4.5 miles)
  • Patchogue Lirr Station (7.8 miles)
  • LIRR Speonk (9.2 miles)
  • Suffolk Transportation Coram (9.8 miles)
  • Sayville LIRR (11.7 miles)
  • LIRR - Westhampton Station (12 miles)

Parks

  • Camp Paquatuck (5.2 miles)
  • Shorefront Park (7.5 miles)
  • Sayville Park (11.4 miles)

Hospitals

  • Long Island Community Hospital (5.7 miles)

Places of Worship

  • Shrine of Our Lady of the Island (7.9 miles)

Theaters

  • Island 16 Cinema de Lux (10.4 miles)

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is The Manors at The Colony Preserve?

Nearby Communities

  • Personal-Touch Home Care Inc

    Personal-Touch Home Care Inc

    Shirley, NY

    3 from 2 reviews
     

    pro Pet-friendly with easy access to pharmacies, doctors, dining, and transportation.

  • The Waterways at Moriches

    The Waterways at Moriches

    Moriches, NY

    3.7 from 3 reviews
     

    pro Intimate, small community with personalized care, meals and medication management, plus connectivity (Wi-Fi and phone) and dietary accommodations.

  • South Bay Adult Home

    South Bay Adult Home

    Center Moriches, NY

    5 from 2 reviews
    $3,000 to $6,000 / month

    pro Affordable semi-private pricing with diabetic care and medication management.

  • Bellhaven Center For Rehab And Nursing Care

    Bellhaven Center For Rehab And Nursing Care

    Brookhaven, NY

    4.6 from 114 reviews
     

    pro Attentive staff and a well-equipped, activity-rich environment.

  • New Brookhaven Town House

    New Brookhaven Town House

    Brookhaven, NY

    1 from 1 review
    $1,550 to $2,800 / month

    pro Encourages family involvement and resident independence.

  • New Brookhaven Town House For Adults

    New Brookhaven Town House For Adults

    Brookhaven, NY

    4.7 from 100 reviews
     

    pro Comprehensive amenities and 24/7 care support.

  • The Chelsea at Brookhaven

    The Chelsea at Brookhaven

    Yaphank, NY

    4.2 from 58 reviews
    $3,300 to $5,250 / month

    pro Clean, well-maintained environment with caring staff and engaging activities.

  • Village Walk at Patchogue

    Village Walk at Patchogue

    Patchogue, NY

    4.4 from 125 reviews
    $5,145 to $7,715 / month

    pro Friendly, attentive staff; engaging activities; clean, welcoming environment; responsive management and relatively affordable options.

  • Braemar Living at Medford

    Braemar Living at Medford

    Medford, NY

    3.6 from 32 reviews
    $4,100 to $4,700 / month

    pro Clean, friendly staff and Medicaid acceptance.

Related Resources

  • what does the sandwich generation meanUnderstanding the Sandwich Generation: Stress and Responsibilities for Multigenerational Caregivers

    The Sandwich Generation comprises adults managing the dual responsibilities of caring for aging parents and raising children, leading to significant emotional, logistical, and financial challenges. This situation is exacerbated by longer life expectancies and cultural expectations, necessitating effective coping strategies and support resources to alleviate caregiver stress and burnout.

  • assistive devices for elderly8 Essential Assistive Devices for Older Adults

    The article highlights eight essential assistive devices that improve the independence and safety of older adults, addressing issues related to mobility, balance, vision, hearing, and dexterity. It emphasizes the importance of proper selection guided by healthcare professionals to enhance seniors' quality of life while allowing them to age in place.

  • how to pay for nursing homeNavigating the Financial Road to Nursing Home Care: In-Depth Guidance and Resources

    The article offers detailed guidance on the financial complexities of nursing home care, covering costs, payment methods, and alternative funding strategies while emphasizing the importance of proactive planning and legal considerations for individuals and families making care decisions.