Abbey Senior Apartments in Indianapolis, IN

Pros

• Debbie calls him to discuss the situation.
• Debbie tells him that he and his service dog can move in.
• The exchange shows a willingness to consider service animal accommodation.

Cons

• The reviewer felt the service dog was discriminated against due to its size and weight.
• They faced weeks of paperwork and two months of waiting with shifting qualifications.
• They were asked to pay a deposit for the service dog, which they believed should be exempt.
• Maintenance is lax and the manager is not personable or helpful in solving problems.
• They decided not to live there because they could not trust the landlord and would not feel comfortable.

Review

Abbey Senior Apartments in Indianapolis is best suited for seniors who can navigate a property environment with limited responsiveness from management and who do not rely on service animals to live independently. The critical policy shaping who should consider this community is a 25-pound weight limit on service animals, a restriction that excludes many people who rely on larger service dogs. For someone planning to bring a service animal that exceeds that size, this community becomes a poor fit. The move-in process can feel opaque and adversarial rather than collaborative, with negotiations that stretch for weeks and leave the impression that policy enforcement takes precedence over resident well-being. In short, the setting serves a niche where a service animal is not central to daily living, and even then with caveats.

Those who may want to consider alternatives are seniors who require clear, fair service-animal accommodation, reliable on-site maintenance, and a manager who communicates promptly and amicably. The situation described suggests inconsistent handling of legitimate service-animal needs, including allegations of discrimination based on the animal’s size and a process that can drag on for months. Potential tenants who value consistent deposit guidelines, especially around service animals, should look elsewhere. Residents who expect proactive problem-solving from management will likely be disappointed, as the manager is portrayed as not personable and not focused on resolving everyday issues. For anyone seeking predictable rules and responsive staff, exploring other options is prudent.

On balance, whatever positive attributes exist do not offset the core downsides. The central concern remains the inconsistent service-animal policy and the sense that legality seems to drive decisions rather than resident comfort. The initial friction over a 25-pound limit leads to extended delays, with hints of legal overtones and confusion about deposits for service animals versus pets. Maintenance issues are described as lax, compounding daily-life challenges, and the manager’s disposition is cited as unhelpful for solving problems. Any minor advantage, such as potential alignment on deposits or a final move-in agreement, fails to counter the strain of repeated disputes and the impression that issues will persist. The living environment thus feels unsettled rather than supportive.

Practical due diligence should center on obtaining everything in writing before committing. Prospective tenants should request a formal service-animal policy, including whether any weight thresholds apply, what documentation is required, and how disputes are resolved. Verify deposit requirements for pets and whether service animals receive exemptions, with a clear statement on who bears costs. Ask for maintenance-response timelines and speak with several current residents about day-to-day reliability. Inquire about noise expectations, especially given concerns that a larger service animal could bark in a new environment. Finally, insist on a trial period or a detailed move-in plan that aligns expectations with the realities described by residents.

For those evaluating options in Indianapolis, this community should be compared against others with transparent service-animal policies and consistently dependable management. Seek out communities that publish written policies on service animals, have clearer deposit practices, and demonstrate proactive maintenance and grievance handling. Speak with current residents across multiple units to gauge whether the positive experiences are real or anecdotal. Consider whether any amenities or services compensate for management gaps, or if the trade-off is not worth the risk. If dependence on service-animal accommodation is non-negotiable, the search should lean toward properties known for respectful treatment of service animals and strong on-site leadership.

Bottom line: Abbey Senior Apartments is not recommended for households that rely on a service animal or that demand consistent, compassionate management. It may still fit independent seniors who do not require service-animal support and who can absorb maintenance lapses, but any expectation of reliable problem-solving or fair, transparent policies should be tempered. For families weighing options, this community should rank behind places with clear service-animal guidelines, prompt maintenance, and staff who treat residents with respect and empathy. When reliability, clarity, and daily living ease matter most, pursuing alternatives that deliver on those essentials is the prudent choice.

This part of Indianapolis, Indiana offers a convenient and diverse array of amenities for senior living. With multiple pharmacies within close proximity, accessing medication and healthcare supplies is easily manageable. There are also various dining options ranging from fast food to sit-down restaurants, catering to different culinary preferences. Additionally, there are several reputable physician offices nearby for medical care needs. The area provides easy access to transportation services, including the airport, making travel convenient. Parks and places of worship offer opportunities for outdoor recreation and spiritual fulfillment. Various hospitals are available within a short distance for healthcare emergencies. Lastly, cafes and theaters provide entertainment and socializing opportunities for seniors looking to stay engaged in the community.

Pharmacies

• CVS Pharmacy (0.4 miles)
• Sunnylife Pharma (4 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (4.3 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (5 miles)
• Walgreens (5 miles)
• Walgreens (5.6 miles)
• Dista Products Company (5.8 miles)

Restaurants

• Jimmy John's (1.7 miles)
• McDonald's (3 miles)
• McDonald's (3.2 miles)
• McDonald's (5 miles)
• Mug'n Bun Drive In (5.1 miles)
• Big Woods Speedway (5.1 miles)
• The Crane Bay (5.3 miles)

Physicians

• US HealthWorks Occupation Health Center (2.2 miles)
• Dr Thomas (3.4 miles)
• Oak Street Health (4.7 miles)
• Indiana Kidney Specialists (5 miles)
• Windrose Health Network (5 miles)
• Riley Pediatric Neurology - IU Health Simon Cancer Center (5.8 miles)
• IU Health Meridian South Surgery Center - Methodist Medical Plaza South (6.4 miles)

Places of Worship

• Valley Mills Christian (2.7 miles)
• St Ann Catholic Church (2.9 miles)
• Speedway Christian Church (5.5 miles)
• New Hope Church (6.4 miles)
• Suburban Baptist Church (7.1 miles)

Transportation

• Concourse A (3 miles)
• Delta Sky Club (3 miles)
• TSA Screening (3.1 miles)
• Delta Air Lines Ticket Counter (3.1 miles)
• Indianapolis International Airport (IND) (3.1 miles)
• Concourse B (3.1 miles)

Parks

• Meridian Woods Park & Neighborhood (4.6 miles)
• White River State Park (5.5 miles)
• Military Park (5.9 miles)
• Meadowood Park (6.9 miles)

Hospitals

• Assurance Of Indianapolis (5.2 miles)
• Richard L. Roudebush Va Medical Center (5.7 miles)
• Sidney & Lois Eskenazi Hospital (5.8 miles)
• Newborn Follow-Up Program, Riley Hospital for Children at IU Health (5.9 miles)
• Simon Family Tower (5.9 miles)
• Indiana University Hospital (5.9 miles)
• Eskenazi Hospital (6.3 miles)

Cafes

• Starbucks (6.1 miles)
• Panera Bread (6.2 miles)
• Starbucks (6.4 miles)
• Starbucks (6.6 miles)
• Starbucks (6.7 miles)
• Starbucks (7.1 miles)

Theaters

• AMC Perry Crossing 18 (6.4 miles)
• Regal Shiloh Crossing (6.7 miles)