Mary Scott Nursing Ctr Inc

Pros

• Mary Scott Nursing Center is a superb spot with agreeable staff.
• The facility has a warm, family-like atmosphere where staff feel like family.
• The activity department is uplifting and creative.
• The clinical staff are exceptional, well-trained, and dedicated.
• Taylor is considered one of the best nurses.
• The grounds are kept nice and the nursing staff are very helpful.
• The place is full of love and laughs, with a strong sense of community.

Cons

• The facility is described as overpriced for a rundown building with a mouse problem.
• Some staff are criticized for rude or unhelpful attitudes, including being told to "get them yourself" for diapers.
• The food is deemed substandard, with meals and coffee served cold.
• A resident encountered a mouse in their room, indicating cleanliness issues.
• There are serious safety concerns, such as a patient waiting 15 hours in pain before care, and a trach suctioning delay leading to deterioration.
• The facility is described as understaffed, with long delays in responding to call lights.
• There are allegations that cigarettes were sold on the premises, which is inappropriate for a care facility.
• The nursing home reportedly had multiple health department citations in the past.

Review

Mary Scott Nursing Center comes across in these accounts as a place that can feel like a chosen family to some residents and their families, even as it struggles with serious system and upkeep problems for others. Across the spectrum of impressions, the common thread is a facility with real heart and genuine warmth on one hand, and persistent, sometimes alarming shortcomings on the other. Several reviewers describe a family-like culture where staff care deeply about residents, while others warn of unsafe conditions, outdated equipment, and a feeling that care quality can swing wildly from shift to shift. It's a facility that has clearly undergone changes, with some people noting dramatic improvements and others still haunted by painful past experiences.

First impressions and living conditions show a stark split. A few reviewers emphasize cleanliness and a bright, comfortable environment, with comments like the place looking better in the afternoon or being a pleasant, family-like setting. Yet other voices paint a very different initial picture: a resident's room described as looking like a "dirty motel" upon arrival, plus a mouse in the room that had to be reported by the resident. Some accounts describe the interior as rundown and overpriced for what's offered, highlighting a gap between what visitors hope and what they actually encounter in the rooms and common areas. The contrast between frayed, outdated spaces and moments of renewed care or renovation is a recurring tension in these narratives.

Caregivers and staff emerge in two very distinct lights. On the positive side, reviewers repeatedly praise certain nurses and aides for their kindness, empathy, and dedication. Names like Taylor, described as "the best nurse ever," and Linda Keller, singled out as one of the best nurses, stand out as symbols of the kind of personal connection that residents and families value. The clinical team is also praised for training and professionalism by some families, with comments about dedicated nurses and STNAs who care deeply and contribute to a sense of family and safety. The activity department is lauded as uplifting and creative, and several residents insist that the staff feel like an extended family, doing their best to make residents feel at home and well cared for.

But the flip side is hard to ignore for prospective and current residents. Across many reviews, there are persistent notes of understaffing, long wait times, and uneven attention to residents' needs. Some accounts describe call lights going unanswered for hours, with one reviewer stating they were lucky to get any response after hours or days of silence. There are specific complaints about disrespectful or rushed interactions, with at least one account suggesting a staff member professionally dismissive about basic needs such as diapers. A small but striking portion of reviews raises concerns about safety and quality of medical care, including reports of a patient deteriorating due to delayed or missed medical interventions, and even allegations that staff would not suction a tracheostomy promptly in a critical moment. These serious items contrast sharply with the more loving, personal care praised by others and underscore why families must weigh both warmth and risk when considering care here.

Food, environment, and daily operations also reveal a divided experience. Some reviews say meals are nutritious and well supplied, with the facility cited for good overall service quality and a generally positive daily rhythm. Others describe the food as subpar or the dining experience as rushed or inadequate, with a recurring jab at the taste and variety. Simple daily comforts - like coffee - also become flashpoints: one resident was told to wait until dinner for a cup of black coffee, even at breakfast, which reflects broader concerns about attention to basic resident needs and the responsiveness of staff. Complaints about the overall atmosphere touch on both decor and maintenance; some find the environment pleasant and well-kept, while others describe it as cramped, outdated, or in need of more consistent upkeep and modernization.

Safety, compliance, and regulatory concerns appear in the most serious notes. A few reviews recount chilling experiences - one recounts a parent enduring extended pain or neglect before a rapid response or emergency intervention finally occurred, and another references a health department citation history that includes multiple issues tied to patient safety and equipment. Stories about older, outdated equipment, and a perception that governance or oversight on certain units could be lacking, contribute to a cautious view of the facility. A separate thread in the reviews mentions disruptive noise and behavior outside the facility at night, such as car stereos, which, while not directly linked to medical care, contribute to a sense of an unsettled, less controlled environment.

There is also a sense of transformation across some reviews. Several commenters describe a turning point where the facility, previously perceived as less than ideal, genuinely improved - some speak of a shift from a "1 star to a 5 star" perception after renovations or staffing changes. They point to improvements in housekeeping, maintenance, and the way the staff make residents feel valued. For others, the praise is more about the people than the physical plant: the way residents are treated as family, the moments of care and kindness that occur despite systemic constraints, and the recognition that dedicated staff can elevate the experience even in imperfect surroundings. In short, the heart of Mary Scott Nursing Center for many is its people - their warmth, patience, and willingness to go the extra mile when times are tough.

Overall, the picture is deeply mixed. Mary Scott Nursing Center clearly hosts a community where strong, affectionate bonds can form between residents and caregivers, and where certain staff members are celebrated for their exceptional care. At the same time, reviewers raise legitimate concerns about cleanliness, safety, responsiveness, and the consistency of care across shifts and days. Prospective families should approach Mary Scott with a clear, measured plan: visit multiple times, meet with care coordinators across different shifts, inspect living quarters and common areas, ask direct questions about response times, safety protocols, and recent renovations, and talk openly about dietary needs and activities. This is a facility that can feel like home in some moments and a warning in others, depending on where one looks, who is on duty, and how the day unfolds.

This part of Dayton, Ohio, offers convenient access to essential services such as pharmacies and healthcare providers, with multiple options within a short distance. The presence of various restaurants and cafes provides opportunities for dining out or grabbing a quick bite to eat. Additionally, the proximity to hospitals and medical facilities ensures easy access to healthcare in case of emergencies or routine appointments. Parks and green spaces nearby offer opportunities for outdoor recreation and relaxation. Overall, this area combines convenience with amenities that cater to seniors looking for a comfortable and well-equipped neighborhood to call home.

Pharmacies

• Walgreens (0.7 miles)
• Khn Pharmacy (2 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (2.5 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (3.9 miles)
• Walgreens (4.2 miles)
• Rite Aid (4.4 miles)
• Meijer Pharmacy (5.9 miles)

Physicians

• Schear Family Practice Network (1.2 miles)
• Adam Jeffery S MD (2.4 miles)
• Southwest Ear and Throat Specialist (2.5 miles)
• Dayton Pain Center (2.9 miles)
• Good Samaritan Medical Imaging (3.2 miles)
• Dayton Heart Center (3.2 miles)
• Kimberly Bethel-Murray MD (3.2 miles)

Places of Worship

• Grace United Methodist (1.3 miles)
• Mount Carmel Missionary Baptist Church (3.9 miles)

Restaurants

• McDonald's (1.3 miles)
• McDonald's (1.6 miles)
• Bar Granada (2.6 miles)
• Table 33 (2.6 miles)
• McDonald's (2.7 miles)
• Uno Chicago Grill (2.7 miles)
• Grist (2.9 miles)

Hospitals

• Grandview Medical Center (2 miles)
• Miami Valley Hospital (2.1 miles)
• Va Medical Center (2.1 miles)
• Miami Valley Hospital (2.5 miles)
• Premier Health Partners (2.7 miles)
• Miami Valley Hospital Inpatient Rehab Unit (3.5 miles)
• Miami Valley Hospital Surgery Floor (3.6 miles)

Parks

• Deweese Park (2.3 miles)
• Kettering Field (2.5 miles)
• RiverScape MetroPark (2.8 miles)
• Hills & Dales MetroPark (5 miles)

Cafes

• Winans Chocolates + Co (2.9 miles)
• Press (3.3 miles)
• Starbucks (3.9 miles)
• Panera Bread (5.8 miles)
• Starbucks (5.9 miles)
• Starbucks (6 miles)

Transportation

• Dayton Yellow Cab (3.3 miles)
• U-Haul Moving & Storage (3.6 miles)