Rose Garden Complex

Pros

• The grounds are kept beautifully.
• Carolyn and Rob are considered the best management and maintenance team the reviewer has met.
• Newark Rose Garden Apartments offers subsidized housing for individuals 55 and older with quaint, income-restricted, smoke-free units.
• Newark Rose Garden Apartments is described as the best place to live, with well-maintained facilities, quick responses, and friendly management.
• The property is well kept and maintenance issues are addressed immediately.

Cons

• The site manager is abusive and hypocritical, and the maintenance man is described as her thug/boyfriend.
• The site manager allegedly issues unnecessary lease violations and fabricates violations to push tenants out, while talking behind people's backs.
• Living there is described as walking on eggshells; inspectors come when tenants aren't home, and pets may be locked in bedrooms without food or water.
• There are claims of theft and property damage, with vehicles broken into and thieves on-site.
• The reviewer urges others to find somewhere else to live.

Review

Newark Rose Garden Apartments is presented to prospective tenants as a warm, affordable option for adults 55 and older who are navigating restricted incomes. The community is described as subsidized housing with quaint, comfortable units that are smoke-free, making it seem like a tight-knit place where quieter living and financial practicality go hand in hand. The overall sentiment from several residents is that the community is designed to support older adults who want a dignified, low-stress place to call home, with an emphasis on affordability without sacrificing basic comforts.

From the vantage point of long-standing residents, the grounds and buildings at Newark Rose Garden Apartments are frequently praised for their beauty and care. One reviewer says, "The grounds are kept beautifully! Carolyn and Rob are truly the best Mgr./Maintenance I've ever met." This person emphasizes not only the attractive exterior but the performance of the management team who are seen as reliable and personable. The implication is that the upkeep extends beyond cosmetic care to the heart of tenant service, where a well-tended property reflects the attentiveness of those who run it.

Maintenance responsiveness is another recurring theme in the favorable comments. Several voices highlight how issues are handled promptly, often with a friendly, reassuring attitude from those in charge. One resident recalls, "Newark Rose Garden Apartments is the best place I have lived. It is well maintained at all times with quick responses and a smile from management." The same note of appreciation appears in another testimonial that mentions a willingness to welcome a return after moving out - "I have moved out for the third time and was reassured that the door will remain open for me to return, as I am a good tenant." Taken together, these remarks paint a picture of a place where management is seen as accessible, responsive, and genuinely invested in residents' comfort and continuity.

Another favorable anecdote focuses on the sense of trust and respect for privacy, underscoring that the community's upkeep goes hand in hand with careful boundaries. A resident writes, "This place is very well kept and maintenance issues are addressed immediately! No one ever goes into the apartments without the tenant there and they certainly would never harm a pet, if anything they would report animal abuse." In this account, the site manager and maintenance staff are described as "strictly friends, not that it's anyone's business," suggesting a casual, friendly atmosphere while maintaining professional boundaries. The reviewer also expresses disappointment with people who allege misconduct, lamenting that those who "do not follow the rules" might resort to posting false statements about others' character.

Yet, the communal narrative is not one-dimensional. A distinctly harsher voice enters the portrait in a separate, one-star review that claims a very different lived experience. This reviewer asserts that a tenant's safety and rights were compromised by allegations of harassment - "a tenant there is being harassed by the site manager (who is very abusive in her deeds, and also hypocritical) and her maintenance man (her thug/boyfriend)." The statement contends that the site manager issues unnecessary lease violations and fabricates violations to push tenants out, describing a climate where residents allegedly feel watched and controlled. According to this account, there is talk of invasive inspections conducted when tenants aren't home, and even accusations that a pet could be kept without food or water as a means of coercion. The language is blunt and charged, ending with a strong caution to prospective tenants: "Please do yourself a favor and find somewhere else to live. I beg you."

That same review escalates into even more confrontational claims, labeling the management team as "scumbags" and describing how vehicles were reportedly broken into repeatedly. The tone communicates a profound fear for safety and a sense of vulnerability among residents, suggesting a neighborhood dynamic where crime and intimidating practices have allegedly occurred. While these assertions are stark and troubling, they are presented as the experiences of a single resident, contrasted against the more favorable impressions offered by others.

Taken together, the collection of comments about Newark Rose Garden Apartments reveals a complex, two-sided picture. On the positive side, the community is portrayed as a well-kept, affordable option for 55-plus residents, with grounds that are cared for, units that are promptly repaired, and management teams that are approachable and supportive. Residents feel valued, with assurances that they can return after moving out and a general sense that their needs are understood and met. The smoke-free, income-conscious setting is repeatedly framed as a meaningful fit for older adults seeking stability and comfort.

On the negative side, there are serious allegations about harassment, privacy violations, and safety concerns that some residents feel are not being adequately addressed. The one-star account depicts a workplace or housing dynamic where personal entanglements, false lease violations, and intimidation are alleged to be part of daily life. These claims emphasize a very different lived reality - one where fear, distrust, and real safety worries color everyday experiences in the same community.

For anyone considering Newark Rose Garden Apartments, these perspectives suggest a place with strong, appealing attributes for older, budget-conscious renters who value prompt maintenance and a friendly management team. At the same time, they warn that, as with any community, experiences can diverge dramatically from person to person. Prospective tenants would do well to visit, talk to current residents, and observe how management handles routine issues and conflicts alike, recognizing that the community's overall reputation rests on a mix of reliable upkeep and, in some cases, contested interpersonal dynamics.

Hospitals

• Newark Medical Center (0.7 miles)
• Lipson Cancer Institute (5.5 miles)
• Clifton Springs Cardio Rehab (5.5 miles)
• Pal-Mac Medical Center (9.9 miles)
• Geneva General Hospital (12.3 miles)
• Finger Lakes Health Foundation (12.3 miles)
• Canandaigua VA Medical Center (12.7 miles)

Physicians

• Finger Lakes Otolaryngology (0.7 miles)
• Westfall Cardiology (1.7 miles)
• Reed Eye Associates (1.7 miles)
• Rochester Cardiopulmonary Group PC (1.7 miles)
• Rochester General Health System (1.8 miles)
• Newark-Wayne Community Hospital - Orthopaedic Care (1.8 miles)
• WorkReady - Newark-Wayne Community Hospital (1.8 miles)

Pharmacies

• Newark Village Pharmacy (0.8 miles)
• Wayne Ltc Pharmacy (0.8 miles)
• Rite Aid (0.8 miles)
• Wegmans (1.1 miles)
• Walmart Pharmacy (2.3 miles)
• Kinney Drugs (5.4 miles)
• Wayne-Clifton Pharmacy (5.5 miles)

Restaurants

• McDonald's (1 miles)
• Tom Wahl's (1.1 miles)
• Subway (5.5 miles)
• McDonald's (5.5 miles)
• Old Mill Hot Dog Stand (5.6 miles)
• Great Wall Chinese Restaurant (5.8 miles)
• McDonald's (7.8 miles)

Places of Worship

• New Hope Bible Church (4 miles)
• First Baptist Church (5.3 miles)
• Zion Episcopal Church (7.1 miles)
• The Sacred Grove (7.3 miles)
• United Methodist Church of Clyde (12 miles)

Parks

• Historic Erie Canal Lock E-56 (4.2 miles)
• Pal-Mac Aqueduct County Park (7.7 miles)
• Gravino Park : (10.1 miles)
• Bullis Park (11.5 miles)
• Ginegaw Park (11.8 miles)
• Sonnenberg Gardens & Mansion State Historic Park (13 miles)
• Farmbrook Park (13.2 miles)

Transportation

• East Palmyra Rail Crossing (4.7 miles)
• U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer (8.3 miles)

Cafes

• Water St Cafe (12.9 miles)
• Monaco's Coffee (13.1 miles)
• Tim Hortons (13.2 miles)
• Tim Hortons (13.3 miles)

Theaters

• Canandaigua Theatres (13.2 miles)