Newark Manor Nursing Home in Newark, NY

Pros

• The staff provided so much love and care to residents at Newark Manor.
• The building administrator and Director of Nursing were readily accessible and helpful.
• The staff went over and beyond to comfort and support families during difficult times.
• Adam was friendly and helpful to visitors.
• The nursing home was extremely clean, and the staff were exceptional in caring for residents.
• Newark Manor is highly recommended for the care of loved ones.
• The staff treated residents with kindness and love.
• The social worker is friendly, and the nursing and therapy teams were excellent.

Cons

• A family member was placed in a room with an air mattress that didn't work, a recliner that didn't work, and a filthy bedside table.
• It took three attempts to get a bed and chair that worked.
• They left the next day due to the conditions.
• He had to ask for washcloths and other basic supplies.
• No one ensured he could safely leave the building, let alone to the car.
• The place was filthy.
• The reviewer wouldn't give them even one star.
• It was suggested that someone who complained was given a $50 gift certificate.

Review

Newark Manor Nursing Home is best suited for families seeking a small, hands-on care environment where caregivers form meaningful, ongoing relationships with residents and where leadership remains approachable. The community earns its strongest marks from stories of nurses, aides, and maintenance staff who demonstrate genuine affection and dedication, with administrators who actively pitch in when needed. This is a setting that tends to reward residents who thrive on personal contact, regular therapy sessions, and end-of-life support delivered with warmth. Cleanliness and a quiet atmosphere are repeatedly cited as hallmarks, and the atmosphere supports families who value continuity of care and the reassurance that the same team members are present day after day.

Those considering alternatives should note that Newark Manor may not be the best fit for every situation. Families that cannot tolerate even occasional lapses in basic upkeep or room readiness may wish to explore other options. Several reviews flag experiences where equipment or rooms were not ready for loved ones, and where seemingly simple tasks, getting a bed, a chair, a bedside table working, took multiple visits or weeks to resolve. Prospective residents who require a consistently flawless environment, exceptionally tight housekeeping standards, or a highly structured, predictable routine with minimal variability may prefer facilities with more centralized oversight and standardized processes. In short, this is a community that rewards relationship-based care, but it may test the patience of those who demand near-flawless day-to-day logistics.

The strongest pros center on personnel and culture. The care team’s compassion is repeatedly highlighted, with many residents and families expressing deep gratitude for the kindness shown by staff. The nursing and therapy teams are frequently praised for their attentiveness and skill, and the social worker is noted as particularly friendly, contributing to a sense of well-being and support for both residents and families. Administrative leadership is described as visible and responsive, with the ability to step in when needed. The environment earns commendations for cleanliness and quietness, which together create a tranquil backdrop for healing, rehabilitation, or steady nursing care. For families seeking a homey, people-first culture backed by capable clinical staff, Newark Manor delivers substantial value.

On the downside, one must reckon with the most troubling counter-narratives. A not-insignificant minority of reviews describe rooms or common areas that did not meet basic expectations for comfort and safety, including equipment that failed to function promptly and a perceived lack of timely maintenance. There are mentions of rooms with mismatched or broken furniture, delays in receiving essential supplies, and a sense that some staff responses were less than reassuring in critical moments. Billing and autonomy concerns also surface in some accounts, with a sense that financial arrangements or expectations around what is included in care could have been clarified earlier. While these reports are not the predominant chorus, they signal meaningful variability in experiences that cannot be dismissed.

Those challenges can be mitigated by leveraging Newark Manor’s evident strengths. The positive experiences underscore a core benefit: when the care team is engaged and accessible, families feel supported through difficult days and the resident’s needs are actively addressed. The commitment of a responsive administrator and the adept therapy team can offset days when housekeeping or equipment hiccups occur, particularly if families go in with structured questions and a clear plan of care. Prospective residents should insist on a thorough tour, ask to meet the DON, and request a detailed, written care plan that covers daily routines, expected maintenance response times, and how therapy and social-work services will be integrated into the resident’s schedule. Additionally, requesting a walk-through of the rooms and a time-bound maintenance checklist can reduce surprises after move-in.

In practical terms, Newark Manor is a compelling option for seniors who want compassionate, relationship-first care and who can tolerate the normal ebb and flow of a busy nursing home. It is especially suitable for families prioritizing personal connections, a quiet and clean environment, and a care team that frequently goes the extra mile in moments of need. Those whose decision hinges on ultra-consistent housekeeping, absolute immediacy in equipment fixes, or a barrier-free path to every administrative inquiry may want to broaden the search to facilities with more standardized operational protocols. For families aligned with Newark Manor’s core strength, profound staff warmth, accessible leadership, and a calm, home-like setting, the next step is a deliberate, questions-forward visit. Bring up service timelines, maintenance guarantees, and the exact scope of therapy coverage; verify what is included in monthly billing and how disputes are resolved. If alignment is clear, Newark Manor stands as a practical, protective choice that can deliver the trusted, human-centered care families seek.

Physicians

• Newark-Wayne Community Hospital - Orthopaedic Care (0.1 miles)
• Rochester General Health System (0.1 miles)
• WorkReady - Newark-Wayne Community Hospital (0.1 miles)
• Reed Eye Associates (0.2 miles)
• Westfall Cardiology (0.2 miles)
• Rochester Cardiopulmonary Group PC (0.3 miles)
• Finger Lakes Otolaryngology (1.3 miles)

Pharmacies

• Rite Aid (1.1 miles)
• Wayne Ltc Pharmacy (1.1 miles)
• Newark Village Pharmacy (1.1 miles)
• Wegmans (1.3 miles)
• Walmart Pharmacy (2.2 miles)
• Kinney Drugs (5.3 miles)
• Dobbins Drugs (5.5 miles)

Restaurants

• McDonald's (1.1 miles)
• Tom Wahl's (1.2 miles)
• Subway (5.4 miles)
• McDonald's (5.4 miles)
• Great Wall Chinese Restaurant (5.5 miles)
• Tolleson S Pizzeria (7.2 miles)
• Old Mill Hot Dog Stand (7.4 miles)

Hospitals

• Newark Medical Center (1.3 miles)
• Lipson Cancer Institute (7.3 miles)
• Clifton Springs Cardio Rehab (7.3 miles)
• Pal-Mac Medical Center (9.5 miles)
• Geneva General Hospital (14 miles)
• Finger Lakes Health Foundation (14 miles)
• Canandaigua VA Medical Center (14.1 miles)

Transportation

• East Palmyra Rail Crossing (3.3 miles)
• U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer (8 miles)
• Williamson Flying Club (12 miles)

Parks

• Historic Erie Canal Lock E-56 (3.7 miles)
• Pal-Mac Aqueduct County Park (7.4 miles)
• Gravino Park : (9.7 miles)
• Ginegaw Park (10.7 miles)
• Bullis Park (11.1 miles)
• Farmbrook Park (13.9 miles)
• Sonnenberg Gardens & Mansion State Historic Park (14.3 miles)

Places of Worship

• New Hope Bible Church (5.9 miles)
• Zion Episcopal Church (6.7 miles)
• First Baptist Church (7.1 miles)
• The Sacred Grove (7.3 miles)
• United Methodist Church of Clyde (11.7 miles)
• Christian Community Church (11.9 miles)
• United Methodist Church (12 miles)

Cafes

• Burnap's Farm Market (14 miles)
• Finger Lakes Coffee Roasters (14.3 miles)
• Tim Hortons (14.6 miles)