Pinewood Apartments in Mosinee, WI

Pros

• The French onion soup is worth the hype.
• The potato skins appetizer is really delicious.
• The food and drinks are good and reasonably priced.
• Pinewood Supper Club is worth a stop for a special occasion dinner.
• The atmosphere is outstanding, and the staff are warm and attentive.
• The service is consistently excellent, and the staff are friendly and skilled.
• Everything is amazing, from the food to the cocktails.
• It is a top-notch Wisconsin supper club with superb lake views.
• The bar serves great drinks, and the bartenders are engaging.
• Guests leave feeling welcomed and eager to return.

Cons

• The steaks were chewy, and it seemed hard to get a good steak lately.
• They described the replacement steak as the worst they had ever had.
• The portions were small and not very flavorful.
• The chowder was not good.
• It was very overpriced for what was offered.
• Finished plates were left on the table long after the courses were completed.
• The bartender was inattentive and seemed to be going through the motions.
• Guests did not receive their meals at the same time and had to wait.
• The value wasn't there for the price.
• The Bearnaise sauce was not on the side and did not taste like Bearnaise.

Review

Pinewood Supper Club in Mosinee is best suited for couples and groups seeking an immersive, classic Wisconsin dining experience. This is the destination for those who prize a warm, lake-view setting, a polished bar program, and a menu that leans into seafood and steak with a distinctly clubby, celebratory vibe. Diners who crave a refined, old-world supper-club atmosphere, where multiple courses unfold with attentive service and a capable wine-and-celtic-bar scene, will find the strongest value here. It is especially well-suited for anniversaries, milestone dinners, and gatherings where atmosphere and tradition carry equal weight to culinary prowess. The combination of intimate lighting, a fireplace, and views of the water creates a singular ambiance that elevates even familiar dishes into a memorable evening. For those chasing a casual night out, or a quick bite with no frills, alternative venues will likely feel simpler and more economical.

That said, not everyone will find Pinewood the right fit every time. Price sensitivity is a critical consideration; several reviews flag the meals as pricey for what is delivered, and portions can feel underwhelming relative to the bill on certain visits. The highly praised menu includes standout options, but a few guests report inconsistent satisfaction with specific entrees, especially steaks that arrive chewy or not up to the level expected for the price. Parking, while manageable on weeknights, can be tight during peak windows, and the dining pace can skew toward rushed service when the house is crowded. For diners who value unfailingly steady pacing, perfectly uniform portions, or the lowest possible price point, alternatives that emphasize speed, casual fare, or value-oriented pricing may be a better fit.

The core strengths of Pinewood offset its rougher edges in several meaningful ways. The atmosphere consistently earns top marks: lake-side seating, elegant décor, and a warmth that makes conversations easy and celebratory feel natural. The service staff is repeatedly praised for knowledge, courtesy, and attentiveness; exceptions exist, but the baseline is a level of hospitality that feels personalized rather than transactional. The menu delivers a broad, distinctive mix of seafood and steak options, with signature items like the French onion soup, walleye, halibut, and a tenderloin Oscar regularly cited as anchors. The bar program shines, with standout cocktails and old-fashioneds that regulars insist on. The ability to host large groups, pre-western wedding dinners, or intimate anniversaries with reliable coordination is another major plus, making the value proposition compelling for those prioritizing experience alongside food.

Where gaps appear, they tend to center on value, consistency, and pacing. Several reviews note that some dishes do not justify their price in terms of portion size or flavor intensity, and a few entrees have fallen short of peak performance on busy nights. The risk of uneven experiences is heightened by uneven service during peak hours, with instances of missed prompts or slower bussing that can leave diners feeling neglected between courses. One frequent reminder is to lean into the strengths: reserve a table in advance, request staff members who have earned strong reputations (for example, experienced servers who remember regulars), and choose reliably praised dishes rather than venturing into items that have shown inconsistency. Parking remains a practical concern, and a portion of the experience hinges on managing expectations about pacing and table turnover during busy periods.

Putting it all together, Pinewood Supper Club represents a premium, highly memorable option for discerning diners who value atmosphere, consistency in service, and a curated menu anchored by seafood and high-quality steaks. The strong points, the lakeside vibe, the beverage program, the staff who can elevate a meal with expert recommendations, and the opportunity to celebrate in a setting that feels both exclusive and welcoming, make the occasional premium feel justified. For those seeking a reliable, high-end Wisconsin supper-club experience, it remains a standout choice. The recurring themes across reviews, that the place can spark awe, that the kitchen can deliver spectacularly when running well, and that staff relationships deeply shape the experience, signal the restaurant’s enduring appeal.

For decision-making, this is a clear pick when the priority centers on a special-occasion dinner, a memorable date night, or a large gathering where ambiance and guest experience carry as much weight as the menu. It is less compelling for patrons who must tightly manage cost, require perfectly uniform portions, or need a brisk, no-frills meal. In those cases, consider alternatives that prioritize value or speed while still offering quality. In all cases, a well-timed reservation is essential, and noting which staff members have earned a reputation for excellence can transform the evening from good to exceptional. Pinewood is not just a meal; it is a thoughtfully orchestrated supper-club ritual that rewards those who approach it with anticipation and a bit of planning.

This part of Mosinee, Wisconsin offers a variety of amenities that cater to seniors looking for a peaceful and convenient living environment. There are several places of worship nearby, including St Paul Religious Education and Immanuel Lutheran Church, providing spiritual support and community engagement. The area also features a range of dining options such as Mosinee Brewing Company and Culver's, making it easy for seniors to enjoy delicious meals close to home. Additionally, there are several parks in the vicinity like Edgewood Park and Rib Mountain State Park, offering opportunities for outdoor recreation and relaxation. Seniors can easily access pharmacies like Pick 'n Save Pharmacy and medical facilities such as Aspirus Kronenwetter Clinic for their healthcare needs. With reliable transportation options like Delta Connection and Lamers Bus Station, as well as theaters like Cedar Creek Cinema Rothschild nearby, this neighborhood provides convenience and entertainment for seniors looking to settle down in a welcoming community.

Places of Worship

• St Paul Religious Education (0.1 miles)
• Immanuel Lutheran Church (1 miles)
• St John's Evangelical Lutheran Church (6.9 miles)
• Bouldin Sid Rev & Joan (7.2 miles)
• Highland United Methodist Church (8 miles)
• St Therese Catholic Church (8.7 miles)
• St Peter Ev Lutheran Church-Wels (9.5 miles)

Restaurants

• Mosinee Brewing Company (0.1 miles)
• Hodge's Place (0.8 miles)
• Subway (1.1 miles)
• Denny's (5.9 miles)
• Culver's (6 miles)
• Relocation Pub & Eatery (6 miles)
• 21 Pub (7.9 miles)

Parks

• Edgewood Park (0.9 miles)
• Kronenwetter Community Park (2.7 miles)
• Shooting Range County Park (3.7 miles)
• Nine Mile Recreation Area (6 miles)
• George Street Park (7.4 miles)
• Kort Street Boat Launch and Park (8.6 miles)
• Rib Mountain State Park (8.9 miles)

Pharmacies

• Marshfield Clinic Mosinee Center (1.3 miles)
• Pick 'n Save Pharmacy (6.1 miles)
• Shopko Rothschild Pharmacy (8.6 miles)
• Trig's Pharmacy (8.9 miles)
• Walmart Pharmacy (9.1 miles)
• Walgreens (9.4 miles)
• Puramed Bioscience (9.5 miles)

Transportation

• Delta Connection (2 miles)
• Lamers Bus Station (5.5 miles)
• U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer (8.4 miles)
• U-Haul (11.2 miles)

Physicians

• Wisconsin Valley Improvement (4.8 miles)
• Aspirus Kronenwetter Clinic (6.1 miles)
• Bone & Joint Clinic (8.5 miles)
• Ministry Medical Group (9.1 miles)
• Marshfield Clinic Weston Center (9.1 miles)
• Kuhn Hearing Center (9.5 miles)
• Fehrman Orthodontics (9.5 miles)

Theaters

• Cedar Creek Cinema Rothschild, Wi (6.1 miles)

Cafes

• Starbucks (8.8 miles)
• Starbucks (8.9 miles)

Hospitals

• St Clares Ministry Health Weston (9 miles)
• Ascension St Clare's Hospital (9.1 miles)
• St Clares Hospital Of Weston (9.1 miles)
• Ministry Health Care (9.2 miles)
• North Central Health Care (10.2 miles)