Pinewood Apartments

Pros

• The food was delicious, especially the Oscar Halibut.
• The service was conscientious and attentive.
• The servers were pleasant and skilled at their jobs.
• Joan the owner made the guests feel warmly welcomed.
• Pinewood Supper Club is an absolute gem.
• The food was fabulous and the staff was amazing.
• The atmosphere was outstanding with lake views.
• Chris at the bar made delicious cocktails.
• Sandy, the server, was a major highlight.
• The lake views were awesome.
• The shrimp and the steak were consistently excellent.
• They would definitely return.

Cons

• The steak was the worst the reviewer had ever had.
• It was very overpriced for what was served.
• The chowder was not good.
• Empty finished plates were left on the table long after the courses were finished.
• A busser ignored a guest's request to clear plates.
• Karen was very unfriendly.

Review

Pinewood Supper Club on the Wisconsin River has clearly become a darling for many who crave a classic, lakeside supper club experience, and the visits shared here read like a love letter to a place that consistently delivers both warmth and fine dining. On a Saturday in early October 2025, a party of fifteen gathered for dinner and found the evening to be a standout: the Oscar Halibut was singled out as a highlight, and the kitchen seemed to have prepared everything to perfection for the entire group. The greeting from Joan, the owner, left guests feeling wonderfully welcomed, setting a tone of hospitality that recurred in many of the reviews. The consensus was unanimous that the experience was top-tier from start to finish.

Time after time, the staff earns high praise for their attentiveness, knowledge, and genuine friendliness. Multiple guests praised the servers for being pleasant, skilled, and incredibly helpful with special needs - whether navigating food allergies at the table or guiding the evening with deft timing. Chris at the bar and Sandy, notably referred to as a star in the "book," are remembered for elevating the evening with approachable charm and expert service. Prominent servers such as Kaylee, Diane, Brandon, Holly, and Danielle pop up in memory as people who made guests feel valued and cared for, often transforming an already good dinner into a highly memorable one. Even when a guest was teasingly told that the dining room could get a bit crowded, the staff's commitment to hospitality shone through, reinforcing Pinewood as a place where people feel they're in capable, friendly hands.

The menu in these accounts reads like a portfolio of classic supper club fare, executed with care. Diets and preferences are acknowledged with appreciation, and the kitchen seems adept at delivering both conversation-starting starters and crowd-pleasing mains. Favorites include seafood specials - walleyes and halibuts - alongside steak options such as tenderloin and filet mignon, as well as a celebrated array of accompaniments and upgrades. Dishes like almond-fried lobster, French onion soup (singled out as a "house specialty" or worth the upgrade), and gator balls appear repeatedly as must-tries. Desserts, ice cream drinks, and well-crafted cocktails from a well-stocked bar are mentioned as perfect finishing touches to an evening that blends traditional charm with a touch of indulgence. The kitchen's emphasis on generous portions, quality ingredients, and a steady rhythm of courses is a through-line in the glowing feedback.

Ambience and setting are consistently praised as integral parts of the Pinewood experience. Reviewers describe an elegant, lakeside atmosphere with views that elevate the dining experience, a pretty garden backdrop, and a warmth that makes guests feel at ease - whether they're there for a romantic night, a family gathering, or a pre-wedding celebration. Several guests note how the decor and vibe encourage lingering and conversation, a hallmark of a true supper club. Parking is occasionally called out as modest - "a little difficult with the parking lot being small" - but even that is framed as a minor caveat rather than a deterrent, given the overall charm and quality on offer. For some guests, the corner booth with its two windows becomes a particularly beloved repeat experience, a small detail that underscores the blend of comfort and special touches Pinewood tends to deliver.

Not every impression was perfectly unblemished, and a few reviews provide a needed counterpoint to the overwhelming positivity. One guest recounted a string of issues: the prime rib was okay but not exceptional, the chowder fell short, and several dishes were overpriced relative to what was delivered. Plate clearing was inconsistent, with empty plates left on the table too long, and a lack of help from bussers during a busy service became a friction point for that diner. A different guest noted a floor that felt a bit chilly and a sense of being rushed - entrees arriving while first courses were still being enjoyed - an occurrence that can temper what is otherwise a seamless flow. Another comment highlighted a standout server eclipsed by an inattentive bartender, reminding readers that even in strong establishments, the balance of staff performance can vary in a single evening. Finally, one guest mentioned an unfriendly interaction with a member of the front-of-house staff, a reminder that in service-heavy venues, personal demeanor can color the experience just as strongly as food and setting.

On balance, the mood across these reviews is overwhelmingly positive, with Pinewood Supper Club emerging as a reliable favorite for celebrations, anniversaries, and casualdedicated nights out alike. Several parties emphasize how well the team accommodates large groups, making guests feel cared for from the initial greeting to the final lift of the espresso martini or grasshopper. Pre-wedding family dinners and anniversary celebrations were described as flawlessly handled, with generous portions and a warm, welcoming atmosphere that helped set a joyful tone for the rest of the festivities. The commitment to hospitality - evident in the staff's friendliness, the owner's gracious presence, and the way the bar and dining room contribute to a cohesive, celebratory mood - consistently shines through in these narratives.

In the end, Pinewood Supper Club appears to offer something special for fans of traditional supper clubs: a scenic, lakeside setting paired with dependable, well-executed food, attentive and often exemplary service, and a sense of hospitality that can turn a routine dinner into a memorable occasion. It's a place where guests feel welcomed, well cared for, and inclined to return - whether they're drawn by a signature dish like the Oscar Halibut, the lure of a perfectly executed onion soup, or the simple pleasure of a well-made cocktail beside a lake-lit view. As with any popular destination, there are moments of misalignment and room for improvement, but the prevailing sentiment here is clear: Pinewood Supper Club is a gem worth seeking out for those hoping to experience the best of Wisconsin's classic supper club tradition.

This part of Mosinee, Wisconsin offers a variety of amenities that cater to seniors looking for a peaceful and convenient living environment. There are several places of worship nearby, including St Paul Religious Education and Immanuel Lutheran Church, providing spiritual support and community engagement. The area also features a range of dining options such as Mosinee Brewing Company and Culver's, making it easy for seniors to enjoy delicious meals close to home. Additionally, there are several parks in the vicinity like Edgewood Park and Rib Mountain State Park, offering opportunities for outdoor recreation and relaxation. Seniors can easily access pharmacies like Pick 'n Save Pharmacy and medical facilities such as Aspirus Kronenwetter Clinic for their healthcare needs. With reliable transportation options like Delta Connection and Lamers Bus Station, as well as theaters like Cedar Creek Cinema Rothschild nearby, this neighborhood provides convenience and entertainment for seniors looking to settle down in a welcoming community.

Places of Worship

• St Paul Religious Education (0.1 miles)
• Immanuel Lutheran Church (1 miles)
• St John's Evangelical Lutheran Church (6.9 miles)
• Bouldin Sid Rev & Joan (7.2 miles)
• Highland United Methodist Church (8 miles)
• St Therese Catholic Church (8.7 miles)
• St Peter Ev Lutheran Church-Wels (9.5 miles)

Restaurants

• Mosinee Brewing Company (0.1 miles)
• Hodge's Place (0.8 miles)
• Subway (1.1 miles)
• Denny's (5.9 miles)
• Culver's (6 miles)
• Relocation Pub & Eatery (6 miles)
• 21 Pub (7.9 miles)

Parks

• Edgewood Park (0.9 miles)
• Kronenwetter Community Park (2.7 miles)
• Shooting Range County Park (3.7 miles)
• Nine Mile Recreation Area (6 miles)
• George Street Park (7.4 miles)
• Kort Street Boat Launch and Park (8.6 miles)
• Rib Mountain State Park (8.9 miles)

Pharmacies

• Marshfield Clinic Mosinee Center (1.3 miles)
• Pick 'n Save Pharmacy (6.1 miles)
• Shopko Rothschild Pharmacy (8.6 miles)
• Trig's Pharmacy (8.9 miles)
• Walmart Pharmacy (9.1 miles)
• Walgreens (9.4 miles)
• Puramed Bioscience (9.5 miles)

Transportation

• Delta Connection (2 miles)
• Lamers Bus Station (5.5 miles)
• U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer (8.4 miles)
• U-Haul (11.2 miles)

Physicians

• Wisconsin Valley Improvement (4.8 miles)
• Aspirus Kronenwetter Clinic (6.1 miles)
• Bone & Joint Clinic (8.5 miles)
• Ministry Medical Group (9.1 miles)
• Marshfield Clinic Weston Center (9.1 miles)
• Kuhn Hearing Center (9.5 miles)
• Fehrman Orthodontics (9.5 miles)

Theaters

• Cedar Creek Cinema Rothschild, Wi (6.1 miles)

Cafes

• Starbucks (8.8 miles)
• Starbucks (8.9 miles)

Hospitals

• St Clares Ministry Health Weston (9 miles)
• Ascension St Clare's Hospital (9.1 miles)
• St Clares Hospital Of Weston (9.1 miles)
• Ministry Health Care (9.2 miles)
• North Central Health Care (10.2 miles)