Mike's Personal Care Home - Sidney

Pros

• This facility did an amazing job helping my Grandmother recoup after a hospital stay.
• The staff treated her really well and were friendly.
• Sidney Care Center has a home-like environment with friendly staff.
• Sidney Care Center is a family-oriented facility.
• They have taken good care of my father.
• They have taken fantastic care of my mother.
• This facility has great nurses and aides.
• They are caring and compassionate for their residents.
• The staff there are dedicated to the care and happiness of the residents.
• Great family oriented facility. Facility was clean and staff were helpful and kind.
• Kitchen staff were friendly and accommodating to the needs of Residents.
• Absolutely wonderful staff. The cleanliness of the facility really stands out.
• Top choice facility for my mother - great care and friendly residents!
• Great nursing home. Thank you.

Cons

• The facility has a strong, persistent odor of urine and waste in the hallways.
• The staff are not particularly friendly and are reported to complain about other staff to residents.
• Call lights are not answered promptly, sometimes taking twenty minutes or more.
• The food is frequently unsatisfactory, causing residents to end up needing meals taken out.
• The facility is accused of using patients for Medicare money and has been linked to fraud investigations and name changes.
• There are reports of visible structural issues (studs showing in walls) and the place being described as a dump with lazy staff.
• Residents are left unattended and not checked on, even during emergencies like cardiac arrest.
• Overall, the reviews would not recommend sending a loved one there.

Review

Mike's Personal Care Home in Sidney, OH is best suited for families seeking a small, home-like environment where care feels personal and staff relationships are often long-standing. It works best for residents who value a family-oriented atmosphere, a cleaner, more intimate campus, and a reputation for compassionate nursing and aide support in a setting that can still handle rehabilitation and long-term custodial care. This is not the choice for those who demand flawless daily operation, ultra-modern amenities, or highly predictable, rapid response across every shift. In short, it serves a niche where heart and continuity matter, and where families can stay closely involved in monitoring and guiding care.

Alternatives are worth considering for families prioritizing consistency, speed, and clinical rigor. Some reviewers flag persistent odor issues, delayed response to call lights, and a staff environment that can feel overwhelmed or less friendly at times. For loved ones requiring robust clinical oversight, complex medical management, or a highly structured rehab pathway with guaranteed punctuality, a larger facility with more resources and standardized protocols may be a better fit. Those who cannot tolerate ongoing cleanliness or odor concerns, or who require highly reliable, 24/7 responsiveness, should compare options carefully and prioritize sites with proven, near-immediate call-light response and consistently positive staff interactions.

The strongest positives at this community are the clean, home-like surroundings and the people who commit to residents with warmth and dedication. Several reviews praise a caring, patient staff and a welcoming atmosphere that feels more like a family than a clinical setting. Long-tenured employees and a kitchen that accommodates dietary needs contribute to a sense of stability and personal attention. For families seeking rehabilitation or ongoing custodial care in a smaller footprint, these attributes can translate into meaningful daily comfort, social connection among residents, and an environment that supports recovery and daily living without feeling institutional or impersonal.

However, the negatives cannot be dismissed. A recurring concern is an overwhelming urine odor in some areas, which for many families becomes a primary impression that colors the entire experience. Reports of delayed call-button responses, occasional staff frustration, and perceptions of inconsistent quality create a tension between the warmth of relationships and the practical reliability of care. Some residents describe crowded rooms and variable dining experiences, while others point to more troubling safety and oversight concerns. In a setting where fundamentals - cleanliness, prompt assistance, and consistent communication - drive peace of mind, these issues are material enough to warrant serious scrutiny.

From a decision-making standpoint, prospective buyers should insist on transparent, current information about staffing levels, shift patterns, and response times. Tour the facility with a critical eye for odor control, room size, and overall maintenance. Ask to speak with multiple caregivers and a family member who currently has a loved one there to gauge consistency in care and communication. Review recent survey results, complaint histories, and any change in ownership or governance, since stability in these areas often aligns with stability in daily care. If rehabilitation is a primary goal, request details on therapy availability, progression plans, and who supervises rehab to ensure expectations align with realities.

Bottom line: this community can be an excellent match for families who want a smaller, family-centric setting where caring staff and a clean, home-like environment can deliver meaningful quality of life for both long-term residents and rehab patients. The upside - genuine warmth, staff devotion, and intimacy - can offset some operational rough edges when monitored by engaged families. For those who cannot tolerate persistent odors, inconsistent call-light response, or signs of staff strain, alternatives with stronger clinical rigor, faster responsiveness, and proven odor-control and cleanliness protocols are prudent. In the right match, Mike's Personal Care Home offers a dignified, compassionate option; in the wrong fit, the same factors become the decisive reasons to look elsewhere.

This part of Sidney, Ohio offers a convenient and comfortable setting for senior living. With several parks nearby such as Roadside Park, Tawawa Park, and Custenborder Field, residents can enjoy outdoor activities and leisurely strolls. There are also a variety of restaurants to choose from including The Bridge, Bruno's, Murphy's Craft Bar & Kitchen, Papa John's Pizza, Lee's Chinese Cuisine, Spot Restaurant, and Little Caesars Pizza. For those seeking spiritual fulfillment, there are several places of worship in close proximity such as First Presbyterian Church, First Baptist Church, Sidney Church of God, La Iglesia Hispana De Sidney, Sidney Wesleyan Church, Holy Angels Catholic Church, and First United Methodist Church. Medical care is easily accessible with physicians like Kristi Pedler MD and Haldeman Mark T MD located within half a mile and the nearby Wilson Memorial Hospital offering comprehensive healthcare services. Additionally, pharmacies like CVS Pharmacy and Walgreens ensure that medication needs are met. Overall, this area provides a balanced mix of amenities and services to support a fulfilling lifestyle for seniors.

Parks

• Roadside Park (0.3 miles)
• Tawawa Park (0.7 miles)
• Custenborder Field (0.8 miles)

Restaurants

• The Bridge (0.3 miles)
• Bruno's (0.4 miles)
• Murphy's Craft Bar & Kitchen (0.4 miles)
• Papa John's Pizza (0.4 miles)
• Lee's Chinese Cuisine (0.4 miles)
• Spot Restaurant (0.4 miles)
• Little Caesars Pizza (0.6 miles)

Places of Worship

• First Presbyterian Church (0.4 miles)
• First Baptist Church (0.4 miles)
• Sidney Church of God (0.5 miles)
• La Iglesia Hispana De Sidney (0.5 miles)
• Sidney Wesleyan Church (0.5 miles)
• Holy Angels Catholic Church (0.5 miles)
• First United Methodist Church (0.8 miles)

Physicians

• Kristi Pedler, MD (0.5 miles)
• Haldeman Mark T MD (0.5 miles)
• Wilson Care Ob-Gyn (0.5 miles)
• Eric J Prenger, MD (0.5 miles)
• Sarah Marshall, MD (0.5 miles)
• Premier Plastic Surgery & Dermatology Associates (0.5 miles)
• Anigbogu Joseph (0.5 miles)

Hospitals

• Wilson Memorial Hospital (0.5 miles)
• Wilson Memorial Birthing Center (0.6 miles)
• Houston Rescue (9.7 miles)
• Valley Regional Surgery Center (10.2 miles)
• Outpatient Care Center North (10.2 miles)

Pharmacies

• CVS Pharmacy (0.6 miles)
• Walgreens (0.9 miles)
• Medicine Shoppe (0.9 miles)
• Walmart Pharmacy (9.8 miles)

Cafes

• Tim Hortons (0.8 miles)
• High Grounds Cafe (0.9 miles)
• Winans Chocolates & Coffees (10.6 miles)
• Winans Carriage House Candies (10.7 miles)

Transportation

• U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer (1.9 miles)
• U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer (3.2 miles)