My Brothers Place in Grove City, OH

Save
My Brothers Place

My Brothers Place in Grove City, OH

2555 Red Rock Blvd, Grove City, OH 43123

For more information about senior living options: (844) 490-3973

4.4 from 109 reviews
5 stars
73
4 stars
19
3 stars
9
2 stars
0
1 stars
8

My Brothers Place Costs & Pricing

My Brothers Place offers competitive pricing for its accommodations compared to both Madison County and the broader state of Ohio. For a semi-private room, the monthly cost at My Brothers Place is $2,500, which stands in stark contrast to Madison County's average of $4,371 and Ohio's statewide average of $3,965. Similarly, private room rates range from $3,000 to $4,350 at My Brothers Place, offering a more affordable alternative when compared to the higher costs of $4,696 and $4,771 found in Madison County and across Ohio respectively. This positioning not only underscores My Brothers Place's commitment to providing value but also highlights its appeal for individuals seeking quality care without the hefty price tag typically associated with similar facilities in the area.

Floor plansMy Brothers PlaceMadison CountyOhio
Semi-Private$2,500$4,371$3,965
Private$3,000 to $4,350$4,696$4,771

Overall Review of My Brothers Place

Pros

  • pro The staff is very friendly and the food is amazing.
  • pro The food is great and the atmosphere is great.
  • pro The burgers are among the best.
  • pro The place is a hidden gem.
  • pro The French Onion Soup is delicious.
  • pro The wings are amazing.
  • pro The bartender makes great cocktails.
  • pro The portions are large.
  • pro The steak dinner is cooked perfectly and the haddock is delicious.
  • pro The seafood dishes are superb.
  • pro The meatloaf dinner is awesome.
  • pro The Cajun Catfish is among the best and the salad is fresh and crisp.

Cons

  • pro They were scowled at for leaving a low tip.
  • pro The service was non-existent; guests had to walk to the bar to order drinks.
  • pro The waitress disappeared, making it hard to get anything during the meal.
  • pro It took two hours to get a hamburger, which felt intentional.
  • pro The stuffed chicken breast stuffing was bread-heavy and lacked flavor.
  • pro The fish sandwich was tasteless and served on a very stale bun.
  • pro The onion rings were swimming in oil and among the worst the reviewer had ever had.
  • pro The berry salad was served without berries and misrepresented.

Review

My Brothers Place in Grove City is best suited for families, friend groups, and sports-watchers who want a hearty, casual dining experience at a reasonable price. The dining room exudes a cozy, neighborhood bar vibe, and the menu leans into generous portions that feed big appetites without breaking the bank. The staff is frequently described as friendly and attentive, and the overall energy supports social meals, celebrations, and pre- or post-event gatherings, especially when a big game is on. This is not fine dining; it is comfort food done well, with enough variety to please a broad crowd, from seafood lovers to burger fans. In short, those seeking a dependable, family-friendly stop with substantial plates and a lively atmosphere will get what they want here.

Those with higher expectations for consistent, flawless service may want to consider alternatives. Reviews reveal a mixed service track record: moments of swift, attentive care sit beside reports of slow refills, misdelivered items, even long delays during peak times or at the bar. The experience can swing with staffing levels, and some tables walk away frustrated. The restaurant also has occasional gaps in reliability, items missing from the salad, bread that arrives stale, or a server who seems pressed beyond capacity. The schedule itself matters: the place is closed Mondays and Tuesdays, which can complicate planning for families used to midweek dining. For diners who prize seamless service, predictability, and consistently high execution, there are other options worth exploring.

On the upside, the core strengths tend to outweigh the occasional misfires for most visits. The kitchen delivers well-executed comfort fare with big flavors and even bigger portions. Burgers shine, wings earn frequent praise, and seafood dishes often land as standout options, especially with the house-made sauces and generous sides. The dining room atmosphere supports lingering meals with friends or family, and the bar scene adds energy, making it a solid spot for watching a big game or celebrating a birthday. Prices align with value in mind, providing a family-friendly option that punches above many rivals in portion size and flavor. The best experiences feel effortless: attentive servers, timely drinks, and a sense that the kitchen knows what it’s doing.

Service quality, however, remains the most variable factor. Several reviews highlight genuinely pleasant, capable servers who keep drinks refilled and meals arriving promptly; other guests report hurried, distracted staff, miscommunications about what’s on the table, or even zero-star anecdotes about delays and disinterest. A few diners note the owner’s presence behind the bar as a positive touch that curates a friendly, unpretentious vibe; yet others describe an uneven bar service and instances where the dining room felt under-staffed. Those hoping for an efficient, high-precision service line should plan for variability and perhaps request a steady server when possible. The combined effect is a restaurant that can feel like a hidden gem one visit and a hit-or-miss experience the next, depending on that night's crew.

Menu breadth is a double-edged sword here. The kitchen handles a broad range of staples, from Cajun catfish to stuffed chicken and strong pasta dishes, with generally favorable results. Critics call out some dishes as standout, like crab-stuffed seafood when done right, and others warn about misfires: bread that disappoints, burgers with an egg that lands oddly, or salads arriving missing components. The critic who loves big, bold plates will find plenty to celebrate, including hearty sides and desserts, while those seeking culinary refinement or perfectly consistent seafood quality may encounter more ups and downs. The consistent themes are big flavor, generous portions, and a willingness to experiment with comfort-food staples, which keeps the place lively even when every dish isn’t flawless.

In the final assessment, this is a practical choice for families, groups, and social diners who want value, heartiness, and a welcoming, convivial setting. It is less ideal for anyone whose priority is consistently pristine service, meticulous plating, or a predictable, high-end dining experience. For planning purposes, consider the hours and the variability in staffing: call ahead for large parties, anticipate possible delays, and be prepared for occasional misses that can be redeemed by a strong kitchen performance. Those who appreciate a casual, neighborhood-feel atmosphere and are content with robust, crowd-pleasing dishes will likely return often, while those who crave a consistently polished operation may want to explore other nearby options.

Features

Types of Care

  • Board and Care Home Board and Care HomeBoard and care homes provide a smaller, more intimate setting for seniors who require assistance with daily tasks but do not need the level of care offered by a nursing home. They offer personalized care, meals, and social activities in a homelike environment, ensuring that seniors receive individualized attention and support in their golden years.

Amenities

  • Activities off-site Activities off-siteEngaging in off-site activities is crucial for seniors to maintain social connections, stay active, and stimulate their minds. It promotes overall well-being and helps combat feelings of isolation and loneliness.
  • Activities on-site Activities on-siteActivities on-site are important for seniors because they provide opportunities for socialization, mental stimulation, physical activity, and overall well-being. Engaging in activities can help seniors stay active, maintain their independence, and improve their quality of life.
  • Bath tubs Bath tubsBath tubs are important for seniors because they provide a safe and relaxing way to bathe, helping to prevent slips and falls while promoting independence and overall well-being.
  • Indoor common areas Indoor common areasIndoor common areas are crucial for seniors as they provide a space for socialization, recreation, and community engagement, promoting overall well-being and reducing feelings of isolation and loneliness.
  • Outdoor common areas Outdoor common areasOutdoor common areas are important for seniors as they provide a space for socialization, physical activity, and relaxation. Being outside in nature can improve mood and overall well-being, while also encouraging movement and engagement with others. These spaces can help combat feelings of isolation and promote a sense of community among residents.
  • Private PrivatePrivacy is important for seniors as it allows them to maintain their independence, dignity, and sense of control over their own lives. It also gives them the space and freedom to relax, reflect, and engage in activities that bring them joy and fulfillment. Creating private spaces within senior living facilities is crucial for promoting overall well-being and quality of life.
  • Private bathrooms Private bathroomsPrivate bathrooms are important for seniors in senior living communities because they provide independence, dignity, and comfort. Having a private bathroom allows seniors to maintain their personal hygiene routines without the need for assistance, promoting a sense of autonomy and privacy. Additionally, private bathrooms help prevent the spread of infections and provide a safe and clean environment for seniors to navigate safely.

Transportation

  • John Glenn Columbus International Airport (11 miles away) John Glenn Columbus International Airport (11 miles away)

Care Services

  • Ambulatory care Ambulatory care"Ambulatory care services provide essential medical support and treatment to seniors without requiring hospitalization, allowing them to maintain their independence and quality of life while managing chronic conditions or receiving routine medical care."
  • Incontinence care Incontinence careIncontinence care is essential for seniors to maintain their dignity, hygiene, and overall quality of life. By addressing incontinence issues promptly and effectively, seniors can enjoy a sense of independence and comfort in their daily activities.
  • Medication management Medication managementMedication management is crucial for seniors to ensure they are taking the right medications at the correct dosages and times. This helps prevent adverse drug interactions, reduces the risk of medication errors, and promotes overall health and well-being. Proactive management also allows for adjustments as needed based on changing health conditions or new prescriptions.

Dining

  • Meals provided Meals provided"Meals provided" are crucial for seniors in assisted living communities as it ensures they have access to nutritious, balanced meals without the stress of meal planning and preparation. This can help promote overall health and well-being for seniors who may have limited mobility or cognitive abilities.

Activities

  • Activities off-site Activities off-siteEngaging in off-site activities is crucial for seniors to maintain social connections, stay active, and stimulate their minds. It promotes overall well-being and helps combat feelings of isolation and loneliness.
  • Activities on-site Activities on-siteActivities on-site are important for seniors because they provide opportunities for socialization, mental stimulation, physical activity, and overall well-being. Engaging in activities can help seniors stay active, maintain their independence, and improve their quality of life.

Description

My Brothers Place in Grove City, OH is an assisted living community that offers a range of amenities and care services to meet the needs of its residents. The community provides activities on-site to keep residents engaged and entertained, promoting a sense of socialization and well-being. The presence of bath tubs allows for relaxing and comfortable bathing experiences.

Indoor common areas provide communal spaces where residents can gather, socialize, or simply unwind. Outdoor common areas offer opportunities for fresh air and outdoor activities in a safe and secure environment. Each resident enjoys the privacy of their own space with private rooms that include private bathrooms.

The community also offers care services tailored to individual needs. Incontinence care is provided to ensure the comfort and dignity of residents dealing with this challenge. Medication management is available to assist residents in taking their medications correctly and at the appropriate times.

In terms of location, My Brothers Place benefits from its proximity to various amenities and services. There are several cafes, parks, pharmacies, physicians, restaurants, places of worship, and hospitals nearby. This accessibility enhances the convenience for residents and their families alike.

Overall, My Brothers Place in Grove City, OH provides a supportive environment that combines essential care services with engaging activities while also being conveniently located near necessary amenities and services in the surrounding area.

Nearby Places of Interest

This part of Grove City, Ohio offers a variety of amenities and services that would be beneficial for seniors looking to live in the area. With several parks nearby, such as Stoneridge Park and Goodale Park, there are plenty of opportunities for outdoor activities and relaxation. In terms of healthcare, there are multiple pharmacies and hospitals in close proximity, ensuring easy access to medical services. Additionally, there are several dining options ranging from casual eateries like Roosters and Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen to more upscale choices like Milestone 229 and Schmidt's Restaurant und Sausage Haus. For those interested in cultural or recreational activities, there is a selection of cafes, theaters, and places of worship within a short driving distance. Overall, this part of Grove City provides a convenient and diverse environment for seniors to enjoy their retirement years.

Parks

  • Stoneridge Park (0.6 miles)
  • Schiller Park (4.2 miles)
  • Scioto Mile - Promenade/Riverfront (4.5 miles)
  • Freedom Park (4.5 miles)
  • Goodale Park (5.2 miles)
  • Quarry Trails Metro Park (6.9 miles)

Pharmacies

  • CVS Pharmacy (1.6 miles)
  • Walgreens (1.6 miles)
  • CVS Pharmacy (2.3 miles)
  • Walgreens (2.3 miles)
  • Walgreens (3 miles)
  • CVS Pharmacy (3.3 miles)
  • Solutions Care Pharmac (3.7 miles)

Physicians

  • Flowers Family Practice (2 miles)
  • Ohio Hospital for Psychiatry (3 miles)
  • West Side Health Center (3 miles)
  • Hilltop Family Health (3 miles)
  • The Eye Center of Columbus (4.7 miles)
  • Doctors Hospital (4.8 miles)
  • Nationwide Children's Hospital Livingston Ambulatory Center (4.8 miles)

Restaurants

  • Roosters (2.5 miles)
  • Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen (3.3 miles)
  • BrewDog Franklinton (4.1 miles)
  • Land-Grant Brewing Company (4.1 miles)
  • Milestone 229 (4.4 miles)
  • Schmidt's Restaurant und Sausage Haus (4.5 miles)
  • Katzinger's Delicatessen (4.5 miles)

Cafes

  • One Line Coffee (4 miles)
  • Starbucks (5.1 miles)
  • Starbucks (5.6 miles)
  • Starbucks (5.9 miles)
  • Fox in the Snow Cafe (6 miles)
  • Panera Bread (6.8 miles)
  • Starbucks (7.5 miles)

Hospitals

  • Mount Carmel Grove City (4.1 miles)
  • Nationwide Children's Hospital (5.4 miles)
  • Select Specialty Hospital (5.7 miles)
  • Richard M Ross Heart Hospital (6.1 miles)
  • OSU Harding Hospital (6.2 miles)
  • Ohio State University Hospital East (6.6 miles)

Places of Worship

  • Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church (4.6 miles)
  • St Christopher Church (5.2 miles)
  • Holy Name Church (7.4 miles)

Theaters

  • AMC Starplex Columbus 10 (6.6 miles)

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to live at My Brothers Place in Grove City, OH?
Where is My Brothers Place?

Nearby Communities

  • West Park Care Center

    West Park Care Center

    Columbus, OH

    4 from 70 reviews
     

    pro Caring, professional staff with strong physical therapy and a clean, safe environment with engaging activities.

  • West Park Rehabilitation Center Skilled Nursing and Memory Care

    West Park Rehabilitation Center Skilled Nursing and Memory Care

    Columbus, OH

    4 from 66 reviews
    $4,860 / month

    pro Competitive private room pricing with memory care and skilled nursing in a convenient Columbus location.

  • Columbus West Park Ctr-Adult

    Columbus West Park Ctr-Adult

    Columbus, OH

     
     

    pro Convenient access to dining, parks, and healthcare in a vibrant Columbus area.

  • Woodview Care And Rehabilitation

    Woodview Care And Rehabilitation

    Columbus, OH

    3.1 from 69 reviews
    $5,070 / month

    pro Private rooms with extensive on-site amenities and 24-hour care.

  • Village Place

    Village Place

    Columbus, OH

    5 from 6 reviews
     

    pro Excellent access to healthcare, pharmacies, parks, and dining.

  • Bending Brook

    Bending Brook

    Grove City, OH

    3.1 from 64 reviews
     

    pro Excellent access to nearby amenities.

  • Visiting Angels

    Visiting Angels

    Grove City, OH

    4.8 from 97 reviews
     

    pro Convenient Grove City location with nearby amenities and healthcare access.

  • The Ashford of Grove City

    The Ashford of Grove City

    Grove City, OH

    4 from 48 reviews
    $3,545 to $4,950 / month

    pro Beautiful, clean facility with friendly staff and engaging activities.

  • Homestead Village

    Homestead Village

    Grove City, OH

    4.5 from 24 reviews
    $1,171 to $1,419 / month

    pro Friendly staff and a welcoming, amenity-rich community.

Related Resources

  • does medicare cover home health careNavigating Medicare Coverage for In-Home Care Services

    Medicare covers in-home health care services, which are medical and provided by licensed professionals under a physician's supervision, whereas non-medical personal assistance is generally not covered unless part of a broader skilled care plan. Eligibility for benefits depends on being homebound and needing intermittent skilled services from a Medicare-certified agency, with specific coverage limitations and additional resources available for navigating options.

  • how much does private home care cost per hourIn-Home Care Costs in 2025: A Detailed State-by-State Exploration

    In-home care is increasingly sought after by older adults for maintaining independence, with average private home care rates in 2025 varying by state and service type, reflecting geographical and local labor market influences. As demand rises, families are considering funding options like Medicaid waivers and long-term care insurance to manage costs effectively while ensuring quality care.

  • what is home health careUnderstanding Home Health Care: A Comprehensive Guide

    Home health care has become essential for supporting independence among the aging population, offering diverse services such as skilled nursing and rehabilitation in familiar environments, while also incorporating technology for personalized care. Despite its benefits, including improved recovery rates and emotional well-being, challenges like safety, staff availability, and insurance navigation must be managed for effective implementation.