Asherton of Dublin

Pros

• The living experience at Asherton was awesome.
• The management staff are always kind and helpful.
• They would not move anywhere else.
• The maintenance team is outstanding and responsive, with staff like Paul helping even on holidays.
• Management helped them explore options when buying a home, and they received the remainder of rent and the full deposit back.
• They went above and beyond for their residents.
• The grounds are always looking nice and the apartments are very clean.
• The staff are very professional and provide quick, helpful service.
• Isabella provided a fantastic property tour and answered questions patiently.
• Dublin’s Asherton is a beautiful, serene community with excellent amenities, and the staff treat residents like family.

Cons

• One reviewer warns prospective residents not to move there, citing dangerous and neglectful management.
• They describe the complex as one of the worst places to live due to poor management.
• The complex is labeled poorly managed and unprofessional, risking residents’ safety.
• Maintenance requests are dismissed or ignored, with urgent issues left unresolved for weeks.
• Communication is described as nonexistent, with emails unanswered and calls unreturned.
• Several statements allege discriminatory or dishonest behavior by staff.
• Rent is criticized as excessive, with claims of inflated and inconsistent pricing.
• The HVAC system is described as failing repeatedly, leaving units cold and bills high.
• Leaks, water damage, and mold are reported as not being promptly repaired.
• Move-in cleanliness is criticized, with pests (mice) and poor drainage noted.

Review

Asherton of Dublin is best suited for mature adults and couples who prize a polished, park-like setting, strong maintenance responsiveness, and a friendlier-than-average front office experience. The community consistently earns praise for its well-kept grounds, attractive apartment layouts, and a calm, pedestrian-friendly atmosphere. Residents often highlight quick maintenance fixes, polite staff, and smooth move-in experiences as key positives. For someone who wants a turnkey living environment with dependable service, Asherton delivers a reassuring baseline: clean common areas, visible landscaping in good order, and a campus feel that makes daily life feel effortless.

This property is less ideal for renters who demand flawless, unwavering management discipline and a fully transparent, predictable repair track record. Across the feedback, several residents describe persistent communication gaps, turnover in maintenance and leasing staff, and in some cases costly, slow-to-address issues. Stories range from delayed fixes on leaks and mold concerns to headaches around heat, energy costs, and even personal interactions with certain staff. Those who require a consistently proactive management team or a transparent, accountable process for problem resolution should consider alternatives where response times and issue ownership are more reliably documented.

The strongest dividends come from Asherton’s tangible amenities and service culture when operations run smoothly. The grounds are repeatedly lauded as pristine, with welcoming exteriors, well-kept ponds, and ample green space that supports walking and outdoor activity. Apartments commonly impress with space and design, and the maintenance crew earns frequent praise for being courteous and timely, when calls land with the right urgency. Tenants note quick responses to urgent problems, sometimes within hours, and several stories recount staff going above and beyond to address practical needs or to assist with move-in orders. In those moments, the combination of a pleasant setting and responsive service creates a genuinely comfortable living experience.

However, the counterweight to those strengths is real and recurring. A sizable portion of reviews recount situations where problems linger, communication falters, and expectations aren’t met. Specific failures cited include water leaks, heat- or cooling-related outages, and ceiling or drywall concerns that drag on without decisive resolution. Complaints also touch on insulation and sound transmission between units, contributing to discomfort for some residents who hear neighbors or contend with drafty spaces. Financial strains appear in a few narratives as well, from perceptions of high rent relative to age and condition of interiors to anecdotes about inconsistent pricing and renewal terms. Taken together, these themes don’t negate Asherton’s appeal, but they do demand a sharp, seller-buyer-like diligence before committing.

On the bestFS terms of service, Asherton tends to shine when the management team demonstrates consistency and a proactive posture. The most credible endorsements come from residents who experienced smooth tours and a straightforward move-in, followed by reliable maintenance support for urgent needs. Those who stay long enough to observe the property’s rhythm describe a core culture of helpful office staff, responsive technicians, and a community that genuinely feels well cared for, at least for stretches. Yet the negative voices are not outliers; they highlight a pattern where responsiveness and accountability waver, and where residents feel their concerns are met with delay, ambiguity, or even dismissiveness. This juxtaposition matters because it frames the decision in terms of risk tolerance: for some, the upside potential is worth the vigilance; for others, avoided stress is worth the price of a different community.

Decision-makers should approach Asherton with a practical checklist. First, scrutinize a current, occupied unit to assess insulation, sound transfer, and HVAC reliability. Ask for written commitments on service timelines for major problems (plumbing, HVAC, leaks), and verify recent maintenance response times with current residents. Inquire about rent increases and what is truly included in the monthly rate, since several comments point to premium pricing tied to an older interior aesthetic and fluctuating charges. Seek clarity on the leasing staff’s responsiveness and any recent leadership changes, and request candid references about how disputes are resolved. Finally, evaluate the surrounding ecosystem: proximity to schools, recreation facilities, shops, and walking trails, and whether the community’s social fabric , including pet-friendly features or a dog-friendly plan , aligns with personal lifestyle needs.

In the end, Asherton of Dublin stands as a compelling option for those who value a refined, low-stress environment, strong groundskeeping, and a maintenance culture that, when invoked, acts quickly and cordially. It is less compelling for anyone who cannot tolerate uneven management performance, inconsistent repair accountability, or a premium price tag tied to aging interiors. Families who need rock-solid, noise-controlled living and a consistently proactive management team may find the tradeoffs too risky. For those who can tolerate occasional service gaps in exchange for a quiet, aesthetically pleasing setting and a generally supportive staff, Asherton remains a credible choice, especially if due diligence is conducted up front and concrete assurances are captured in writing before signing.

This part of Dublin, Ohio offers a variety of amenities that may appeal to seniors looking to live in a vibrant and well-connected community. With several parks nearby, there are plenty of opportunities for outdoor recreation and leisurely walks. In terms of healthcare, there are several physicians and pharmacies within a short distance, providing convenient access to medical services. Additionally, the presence of cafes and restaurants catering to different tastes ensures that residents can enjoy dining out without having to travel far. For those who value spiritual well-being, places of worship are also easily accessible in the area. Overall, this part of Dublin offers a mix of convenience and leisure options that may make it an attractive choice for seniors seeking a comfortable and engaging living environment.

Parks

• Coffman Park (1 miles)
• Avery Park (1.2 miles)
• Glacier Ridge Metro Park (3.5 miles)
• Carriage Place Park (4.3 miles)
• Concord Park (5.2 miles)
• Homestead Park (5.3 miles)
• Jerome Township Community Hall (5.5 miles)

Places of Worship

• Saint Brigid of Kildare Catholic Church (1.2 miles)
• Saint Brendan Catholic Church (4.8 miles)
• Scioto Ridge United Methodist Church (5.2 miles)

Physicians

• Pediatrics Ophthalmology Associates - Nationwide Children's Close to home center (1.4 miles)
• Jennifer Shoenfelt, MD (1.8 miles)
• Rainbow Pediatrics (1.8 miles)
• TLC Laser Eye Centers (1.8 miles)
• Dermatology and Cosmetic Surgery of Dublin (1.9 miles)
• Midwest Retina (2 miles)
• Emerald Pediatrics (2.2 miles)

Restaurants

• First Watch (1.5 miles)
• Matt the Miller's Tavern (1.6 miles)
• McDonald's (1.6 miles)
• Burger King (1.6 miles)
• Wendy's (1.7 miles)
• The Pearl (1.8 miles)
• Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams (1.8 miles)

Pharmacies

• Market District Supermarket (1.6 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (1.7 miles)
• Walgreens (1.7 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (2.5 miles)
• Walgreens (3.6 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (3.6 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (4.2 miles)

Cafes

• Kona Craft Kitchen (1.8 miles)
• Tim Hortons (2.4 miles)
• Dells Homemade Ice-Cream & Coffee (2.7 miles)
• Starbucks (3 miles)
• Starbucks (3.4 miles)
• Starbucks (3.5 miles)

Hospitals

• Columbus Oncology Associates (2.1 miles)

Transportation

• The Ohio State University Airport at Don Scott Field (OSU) (4.5 miles)