Brookeville House II At Sunshine in Brookeville, MD

Memory care communities with a similar price nearby

• from -$1050 / mo

  Avalon House on Laburnum Street

  5 from 91 reviews

  $4,950 / month

  20.3 miles away
• from +$615 / mo

  The Residence at Colvin Run

  5 from 30 reviews

  $6,615 to $10,225 / month

  21.1 miles away
• from -$800 / mo

  Avalon House On Laburnum Street

  5 from 15 reviews

  $5,200 / month

  20.3 miles away
• from -$500 / mo

  Glen Hill

  5 from 11 reviews

  $5,500 / month

  2.7 miles away
• from +$1050 / mo

  Maple Ridge Group Home

  5 from 11 reviews

  $7,050 / month

  7.2 miles away

Pros

• The staff are professionals and friendly, making the residents feel at home and at peace.
• The care team is well organized and quickly sets up care, consistently exceeding expectations.
• Brookeville House is highly recommended, with a superb manager and very caring staff.
• The facility is wonderful, with great staff and an outstanding management team delivering attentive care.
• The on-site staff are available 24/7, and a nurse visits regularly to ensure thorough care.
• Evelyn, the co-owner, provides frequent updates and promptly arranges elder-care doctors for residents.
• Brookeville House is beautiful inside and out, staffed with compassionate employees, and residents participate in meals and activities daily.
• The caregivers and staff are among the best encountered, and residents love the place.

Cons

• The staff’s handling of the fall was irresponsible at best and negligent at worst.
• There was never a word of acknowledgement of the father’s death from Brookeville House.
• Unappetizing food, mixed-up laundry, ill-fitting bedsheets, and lackadaisical cleaning were observed.
• There was a disconcerting lack of accountable oversight by management.
• Residents were left unattended on several occasions, with day staff outside together.
• Roaches in the bathroom and bedroom, plus unattended repairs and missing call buttons, highlighted ongoing neglect.

Review

Brookeville House II at Sunshine is best suited for families seeking a small, home-like assisted living environment where personal attention and a warm, neighborly atmosphere matter most. This community works well for seniors who are largely independent but need help with daily tasks, medication reminders, meals, and light supervision, delivered with genuine kindness. The setting, an intimate eight-resident house, makes it feasible for caregivers to know residents well and tailor routines accordingly. The on-site registered nurse and around-the-clock staff create a steady safety net without the feel of a large campus, which can ease families worried about impersonal care. When the priority is a personable, comfortable day-to-day experience rather than high-level medical complexity, Brookeville House II delivers.

Those weighing alternatives should consider how much medical oversight and memory-care support will be needed. For residents with significant cognitive impairment, high fall risk, or complex nursing needs, this may not be the strongest option. The most critical questions involve oversight and accountability: if a loved one requires aggressive fall prevention, clear incident reporting, and consistently reliable supervision, the broader market may offer facilities with more formalized protocols. Families facing ongoing behavioral or safety challenges, or who demand a more structured, larger-scale operation, may find more suitable alignment elsewhere.

The strongest positives center on the staff and the sense of care they convey. Reviews repeatedly praise professional, friendly caregivers who treat residents like family, and a nurse who “goes above and beyond.” Families report quick care setup, ongoing follow-through, and a level of organization that supports peace of mind. The combination of a dedicated on-site presence, frequent updates from the co-owner, and on-call nurse coverage reinforces trust for daily needs, medical coordination, and emergency responsiveness. Food quality and social programming, library outings, family nights, and regular opportunities to socialize, also contribute to a dignified, active living experience.

Yet long-form feedback cannot be ignored. A recurring theme among detractors concerns safety and oversight gaps: a notably serious fall incident followed by disputed handling, questions about staff availability at critical moments, and a perception that management is stretched thin or ad hoc. Specific complaints cite a lack of a reliable call-button system, staff distraction (earbuds in use during resident calls), and routine housekeeping lapses. Some families describe the environment as dated or “tired,” with roach issues and maintenance delays affecting comfort and safety. These concerns undercut the otherwise warm atmosphere and create legitimate questions about risk tolerance for certain residents.

In practical terms, the pros do offset the cons only for a subset of families. For those prioritizing a homey, intimate setting with strong daily attentiveness and a capable nurse presence, Brookeville House II can be a good match, so long as expectations align with the realities of a smaller operation. However, for anyone whose loved one requires rigorous safety protocols, highly proactive fall prevention, meticulous housekeeping, or transparent, responsive management during crises, the negatives loom large enough to warrant serious consideration of alternatives. The decision hinges on whether the resident’s needs fit a small, personal environment or demand the assurances that come with larger, more systematically run communities.

Actionable guidance for families facing this choice: conduct a thorough, unhurried visit with multiple staff members, and request a clear, written care plan that delineates who is responsible for what during day and night shifts. Verify the reliability of the call system and intercom, and ask to see recent incident logs and follow-up protocols. Tour House 1 and House 3 to compare space, lighting, and upkeep, and ask about the frequency of managerial rounds and maintenance schedules. Discuss fall-prevention measures, including walker safety and room layouts, and confirm photo-ready emergency plans. If memory care or high medical needs are anticipated, prioritize facilities with dedicated memory-care units or more robust clinical staffing, even if it means considering alternatives outside the Brookeville family.