Independence Square

Pros

• It is a great place for seniors.
• Residents feel like family because of the people there.
• The place is beautiful.
• The community is well-kept, very clean, and friendly.
• It is a safe and secure place to live for the elderly and disabled.
• The staff are friendly and welcoming.
• There are engaging activities (e.g., bingo) and on-site doctor visits that create a welcoming atmosphere.
• It is considered the best place in Evansville for disabled or retired residents.

Cons

• They wished there was more to do.
• They experienced a prolonged, unanswered delay after being told an apartment would become available, with no follow-up.
• They were told two blemishes on their 35-year rental history were under review, but weeks passed with no update.
• They were accused of obscene language in the designated smoking area, and staff did not believe their side of the story.
• There was a staff clique that dismissed those outside it and acted as if others were lying.
• Management claimed ownership of sidewalks and surrounding streets, enforcing rules as if they controlled public spaces.
• They moved there because of black mold and 20+ stairs, and the situation was unsuitable for someone with a Parkinson's diagnosis.

Review

Independence Square appears to be a community that many seniors and disabled residents find truly appealing on the surface: a beautiful, well-kept, and secure place where neighbors feel like family and where safety and cleanliness are repeatedly highlighted. Several residents praise the sense of hominess and the friendly atmosphere, noting that the people living there contribute to a warm, welcoming feel. For some, the property's charm is obvious from the start, with comments like "This is a BEAUTIFUL place!" and "Nice place for elderly & disabled people to live" underscoring a visual and environmental appeal. The notion of living somewhere that feels safe and well maintained is a strong through-line in several reviews, and for many, that aspect alone makes Independence Square a compelling option.

Yet beneath the initial charm, experiences diverge sharply. A number of reviewers recount struggles surrounding the application and notification process. One prospective resident described an extended, confusing delay after being asked to complete more paperwork and then receiving no follow-up contact for weeks, only to learn that there were "two blemishes on our 35 year rental history" under review by management. The tone conveys disappointment and frustration, especially given a vulnerable situation - moving after issues like black mold and a medical diagnosis (Parkinson's) that were part of the decision to relocate. The disparity between the hopeful visit and the protracted, uncertain follow-through raises questions about communication and responsiveness in the leasing process.

Management interactions also feature prominently in the critiques. A resident recounts an incident in which they were accused of obscene language in a designated smoking area and explains that, despite stating their side, the office staff seemed to doubt them. The account suggests a perceived division or "click" within the staff and management, with the resident expressing concern that truth alone was not enough to be believed. There is even a provocative claim about ownership of sidewalks and nearby streets, framed as a humorless reflection on control and policy - an insinuation that management exercises outsized influence beyond the property lines. Taken together, these anecdotes point to a culture where rules and enforcement feel opaque, and where residents worry that dissenting voices may be dismissed or marginalized.

Despite these tensions, many residents are quick to foreground the positive: Independence Square as a commendable option for disabled or retired individuals, praised for safety, cleanliness, and overall living conditions. A heartfelt statement, "Best place in Evansville for those of us who are disabled or retired!" captures a sentiment of relief and affirmation from those who feel supported and secure. Other reviews emphasize the consistent sense of care from staff, calling the living environment "friendly" and the building "well kept" and secure, with surveillance contributing to a feeling of ongoing safety. For several residents, the combination of careful maintenance and reliable security cameras creates a dependable home base.

Personal experiences of length of stay add further texture to the picture. One resident notes a six-year tenure with strong affection for the community's safety, while another describes a more introspective approach to participation, saying they live there and regularly complete the posted feedback or surveys. The contrast between being a long-term, settled resident and the sense of ongoing change suggests that the community's emotional resonance can endure even as individual experiences with staff or programs shift over time. In these testimonials, stability and security are valued, but the daily lived reality - how residents engage with programs, services, and neighbors - varies widely.

Social life within the community emerges as a mixed bag. Some reviewers recall a welcoming, bustling atmosphere with activities such as bingo and doctor visits, and they remember coming in with a strong first impression of friendliness and opportunity. Others reflect that the once-abundant activities have dwindled or failed to sustain momentum, noting that "there used to be a lot of things to do," but "nothing really sticks" for long. The sense of community can feel vibrant and communal at times, yet fragment into cliques or groups where being in the "right group" matters for how residents are treated. One person highlights the moment of a fresh arrival - impressed by the welcome extended to a new friend - while other voices caution that the social scene can become less inclusive or less consistently engaging over time.

A final strand of commentary emphasizes both caution and praise about the physical and operational environment. Several residents describe the building as clean, well kept, and well protected, with a secure setting reinforced by cameras. The broader area around the property is referenced in ways that suggest ongoing construction and local dynamics, but the immediate living space is repeatedly framed as pleasant, orderly, and safe for elderly and disabled residents. The overall tone suggests a community that offers a strong foundational appeal - beauty, safety, and a sense of belonging - while simultaneously showing that administrative processes, interpersonal dynamics, and the consistency of social programming can be uneven.

Taken together, Independence Square presents a portrait of a community with a strong core: beauty, safety, and a capable staff that many residents rely on and appreciate. At the same time, the reviews reveal real challenges in communication, administrative responsiveness, and social consistency. For prospective residents and their families, the place promises a serene, well-maintained home with a friendly atmosphere that can feel like family. It also warrants careful consideration of how leasing decisions are communicated, how conflicts are resolved, and how robust the ongoing activity calendar is to ensure that the energy and engagement seen at entry continue to thrive for the long term.

This part of Evansville, Indiana, offers a convenient and diverse range of amenities for seniors looking to settle in the area. There are several reputable healthcare facilities nearby, including Deaconess Hospital and Evansville Heart Center, ensuring top-notch medical care. Additionally, there are pharmacies like CVS and Walgreens within a short distance for easy access to medications. For dining options, there is a variety of restaurants ranging from Mexican cuisine at Hacienda to burgers at Bru Burger Bar, providing choices for different tastes. Cafes such as Donut Bank Bakery and Starbucks offer cozy spots to relax with a cup of coffee. Overall, this part of Evansville presents a balanced mix of healthcare services, dining options, and leisure activities for seniors to enjoy in their retirement years.

Physicians

• Terry W Talley (0.1 miles)
• Evansville Pulmonary Associates (0.1 miles)
• Orthopaedic Associates (0.1 miles)
• Evansville Radiology PC (0.1 miles)
• Deaconess Critical Care (0.1 miles)
• Deaconess Clinic (0.1 miles)
• Evansville Heart Center (0.2 miles)

Hospitals

• Deaconess Hospital (0.2 miles)
• Deaconess ICU (0.2 miles)
• St Marys Womens Hospital (3.7 miles)
• Evansville State Hospital (3.7 miles)
• St Mary's Auxiliary and Gift Shoppe (3.8 miles)

Places of Worship

• Gethsemane Church (0.3 miles)
• St Boniface Catholic Church (1.5 miles)
• Lutheran Church of Our Redeemer (2.2 miles)

Pharmacies

• CVS Pharmacy (0.4 miles)
• Walgreens (1.8 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (2 miles)
• Target Pharmacy (2.2 miles)
• Walgreens (2.9 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (3.2 miles)
• Schnucks (3.5 miles)

Restaurants

• Hacienda Mexican Restaurants (0.4 miles)
• McDonald's (0.5 miles)
• Someplace Else Night Club (0.6 miles)
• Lamasco Bar (0.9 miles)
• Bru Burger Bar (0.9 miles)
• Corner Pocket (1 miles)
• Brew Brothers Tap House (1 miles)

Cafes

• Donut Bank Bakery and Coffee Shop (1.6 miles)
• Donut Bank Bakery and Coffee Shop (1.8 miles)
• Starbucks (3.6 miles)
• Starbucks (4.1 miles)
• Starbucks (4.1 miles)