Odd Fellows Home

Pros

• The staff are friendly, helpful, and caring.
• The facility is clean, inviting, and nicely decorated.
• Residents receive excellent care, and their health and happiness improve.
• Visitors are welcomed, and the environment feels home-like.
• The staff provide a full range of services and engaging activities for residents.
• The courtyard is beautiful and the overall atmosphere is peaceful.
• The facility is regarded as one of the best nursing homes and rehab facilities in the Green Bay area.

Cons

• The CEO and management do not care about the residents or their workers.
• Housekeeping basically doesn't exist.
• A resident had feces all over his toilet for over a week after they emptied his bedpan; the urinal was never cleaned and was left on a bedpan for over an hour.
• Transfers were mishandled, with a resident dropped four times in five months.
• Food was always cold and portions were not big enough.
• There were many unknown charges on the bill and they would never return phone calls when questioned.
• The state had to visit the facility three times in five months.

Review

The collection of experiences surrounding Odd Fellows paints a picture that is far from uniform. On one hand, there are harsh, troubling accounts that speak to neglect, hygiene lapses, and a management attitude that some families feel is disengaged from the realities of resident care. One family member endured feces on a toilet for more than a week after a bedpan was emptied, and another review describes a urinal that was never cleaned, left on a bedpan for over an hour, and several dangerous mishaps during transfers - twice in a single period and multiple times in a few months. Food is repeatedly described as cold and inadequately portioned, with concerns about how bills are handled and unexplained charges that the facility would not clarify over the phone. Such experiences prompted state visits to the facility, underscoring the perception that resident well-being and transparent administration were not being adequately safeguarded.

Against those hard-edged concerns, many other voices offer a strikingly different tone. A large number of reviewers praise the staff for being friendly, helpful, and genuinely caring. They describe the facility as very clean, bright, and inviting, with a welcoming atmosphere that makes visitors feel comfortable. Several reviewers point to the architectural and environmental aspects - beautiful courtyards, tasteful decorations, a tidy entrance, and pleasant surroundings - that contribute to a sense of a "home-like" environment. Visitors frequently note that the check-in process runs smoothly, there is easy access to loved ones, and the staff's demeanor remains positive and supportive, even when addressing scheduling or logistical questions.

There is also a strong thread of satisfaction regarding long-term care and daily life for residents. Numerous comments highlight that the staff take time to know residents personally, attend to their needs, and maintain a high level of respect and dignity. In particular, several accounts mention mothers or grandmothers receiving attentive, compassionate care, with improvements in health and happiness over the course of their stay. Families recount activities that are engaging and meaningful, and they praise staff responsiveness to concerns raised by relatives. Some reviewers mention that their loved ones with dementia or other conditions are in capable hands, and that family presence is accommodated with accommodating visiting practices, including temperature checks at entry and a general receptiveness to visitors.

Yet even among these positive experiences, there are cautions and pockets of critical observation. Some reviewers describe the facility as having insufficient housekeeping and cleanliness in certain areas, echoing a sense that a polished exterior can mask deeper operational problems. There are references to odors, some interior furniture being in poor condition, and a perception that certain areas of care - such as the kitchen or patient rooms - could benefit from more consistent staffing and attention. One account details significant concerns about the physical environment, including a room that smelled of urine, a chair that broke during a visit, furniture that appeared dirty or damaged, and visible issues with bed controls and electrical wiring. Another reviewer notes a lack of security and supervision in the building, framing it as a broader pattern of insufficient oversight.

There are also outlier voices that bring up broader workplace or regulatory concerns, independent of the resident experience. One review cites OSHA-related violations and practices around lunch breaks that allegedly undermine labor standards, while another recounts a firsthand impression of systemic issues that would warrant investigation - phrases such as "it should be investigated" and references to ongoing inquiries by the BBB appear in the same thread of critique. These comments are not about the resident experience per se, but they color the overall sense of the facility's operations and compliance in the eyes of some readers.

Despite the intensity of both praise and critique, there is a prevailing view that Odd Fellows can be a place of considerable warmth and care when things run smoothly. Several reviews call it "the best" or "one of the best nursing homes and rehab facilities in the Green Bay area," especially in the context of long-term care, activities, and the personal attention residents receive. Families recount how staff members are kind, gentle, and patient, and how a calm, home-like environment helps residents feel at ease. The facility is repeatedly described as a place where staff treat residents "like family," where visitors are welcomed, and where the day-to-day atmosphere can feel both peaceful and respectful. Some reviewers even express a strong, unwavering endorsement, stating that they would recommend Odd Fellows to others and that they felt fortunate to have their loved ones there during challenging health journeys.

In a broader sense, the reviews converge on a common truth: capacity for genuine care exists within Odd Fellows, but it coexists with significant concerns about cleanliness, safety, and administrative transparency. The facility's strengths - its friendly staff, clean and inviting spaces, engaging activities, and visible dedication to resident well-being - are repeatedly highlighted. At the same time, recurring stories of neglect in basic hygiene, communication gaps about charges, and safety-related issues point to serious areas in need of ongoing oversight and improvement. For anyone considering Odd Fellows, the message is clear in both the praise and the warnings: visit multiple times, assess both the warmth of the caregiving environment and the rigor of the facility's cleanliness and safety protocols, speak with staff about how concerns are handled, and review the most recent state inspections and quality metrics to form a holistic impression.

Restaurants

• Plia's Kitchen (0.1 miles)
• Nukeo Thai Restaurant (0.2 miles)
• Zambaldi Beer (0.4 miles)
• McDonald's (0.7 miles)
• Fox Harbor (1.1 miles)
• St Brendan's Inn (1.1 miles)
• Cranky Pat's Pizzeria (1.3 miles)

Physicians

• Bellin Health Ear, Nose and Throat (0.3 miles)
• Prevea Health (0.4 miles)
• Maymoona Attiyat, MD (0.4 miles)
• Green Bay Oncology (0.4 miles)
• Mcdonough, Patrick Dr - Saint Vincent Hospital Pathology (0.4 miles)
• Patrick McDonough, MD (0.4 miles)
• Green Bay Radiology SC (0.4 miles)

Hospitals

• St Vincent Hospital (0.4 miles)
• St Vincent's NICU (0.4 miles)
• HSHS St. Vincent Hospital (0.5 miles)
• Bellin Health Cardiology Associates - Green Bay (0.5 miles)
• St Vincent Hospital (0.6 miles)
• Pediatrics Intensive Care Unit At St Vincents (0.7 miles)

Pharmacies

• Children's Promise (0.8 miles)
• Walgreens (1 miles)
• CVS In The Pharmacy (1.1 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (1.1 miles)
• Walgreens (1.2 miles)
• Streu's Pharmacy Bay Natural (1.5 miles)
• Aurora Lab (1.6 miles)

Cafes

• Kavarna (1.5 miles)
• Julie's Cafe & Catering (1.8 miles)

Parks

• Leicht Memorial Park (1.6 miles)
• Heritage Hill State Park (1.7 miles)
• Green Isle Park (2 miles)
• Farlin Park (2.1 miles)
• Fisk Park (2.1 miles)
• Henry S. Atkinson Park (2.5 miles)

Theaters

• Bay Park Cinema Ashwaubenon, Wi (2.3 miles)

Places of Worship

• Nativity Of Our Lord Parish (2.4 miles)