Liberty Square in Ammon, ID

Pros

• The community is described as amazing with supportive management and staff.
• The apartments are clean, very spacious, and modern.
• Residents feel safe thanks to security cameras and locked building access.
• The property is pet-friendly and has an awesome dog run.
• Underground parking and basement parking options are available.
• Amenities include a gameroom, hot tub, veranda, theater room, and library.
• Management is understanding, accommodating, and treats residents like family.
• Maintenance is quick and reliable, with issues addressed promptly.
• The area feels quiet with kind neighbors and good privacy.

Cons

• The manager is a horrible person.
• The apartments are overpriced given how outdated the appliances are.
• The shower doors fell down, risking injury to the residents.
• Requests are only partially fixed when made.
• The shower door remained swinging open after move-out.
• It takes a long time for anyone to come take a look at issues.
• They take advantage of their tenants and are very rude.
• Chris, the owner, is a manipulative person who twists words to use against residents.
• He questions tenants and may illegally charge for ESAs.
• They charged for carpet damage despite the carpet being at least ten years old.
• Security deposits were not returned within the 30-day lease period.
• The complex did not return the security deposit after five months and did not respond to calls or messages.
• Management is very inactive; they do not answer phones or return calls.
• The lawn needs to be kept up and the property is not properly cared for.

Review

Liberty Square in Ammon is best suited for independent seniors and families who want a spacious, amenity-rich rental option that feels like a secure, small-town community. It works well for residents who value safety features, proximity to work or social circles, and the flexibility of pet-friendly living without stepping into a traditional care setting. The property offers large, sometimes modern-feeling apartments and robust common areas that invite keeping life social and comfortable - think a theater room, library, game room, and a veranda that doubles as a front-row seat for summer fireworks. Underground parking and in-building spaces address practical needs in winter and for households with mobility considerations. In short, Liberty Square markets itself as practical, family-friendly independent living with a resort-like touch.

Alternatives should be considered by those who need consistent, high-touch management and transparent, error-free financial handling. Several reviews surface concerns about the on-site leadership, including personalities described as difficult and inconsistent responsiveness from management and maintenance. Prospective tenants should be cautious if a strict, timely security-deposit return and a flawless service record are non-negotiable, because some residents report delayed or withheld deposits and disputes over charges for carpet wear. Those who require predictable, proactive service and direct escalation should compare Liberty Square to properties with stronger, documented maintenance SLAs and clearer dispute-resolution processes. For households with complex health needs or plans to transition to assisted living, this housing option may complicate timelines and expectations.

On the plus side, the community builds value through amenities and atmosphere that many independent-living buyers want. Pet-friendly policies accommodate dogs and a dedicated dog run, a meaningful perk for households prioritizing emotional well-being and continuity with companions. The management and maintenance teams shine when functioning, delivering prompt repairs and maintaining a clean, quiet living environment. Residents consistently praise attractive common areas, straightforward parking in basement or garage spaces, and security features like cameras and controlled access that boost peace of mind for families with older relatives. The apartments themselves are repeatedly described as spacious and, in many cases, modern, with elevator access and ample storage to feel homelike. For households seeking social and recreational opportunities at home, Liberty Square delivers a compelling package.

Yet the downsides are real and sometimes jarring. Reports of rude or manipulative behavior by some managers create a red flag for tenants expecting straightforward, respectful interaction. Inconsistent maintenance responsiveness ranges from rapid fixes to long delays, a risk when health or mobility concerns are present. Financial friction points appear as charges for older carpet, deposit refunds that lag or fail to materialize, and difficulty reaching management by phone or email when problems arise. Outdoor upkeep can also fall short at times, signaling broader grounds-maintenance challenges beyond unit-level concerns. While the property can look polished, these recurring management and maintenance gaps erode confidence and complicate housing decisions for seniors who prize reliability and clear communication.

Nevertheless, the pros can meaningfully offset the cons for families who anchor expectations in reality. When a reliable, empathetic manager is in place, communication improves, maintenance becomes predictable, and the sense of community - quiet neighbors, respectful ambiance - translates into fewer headaches. The blend of private space, in-unit storage, and amenities like a game room or hot tub creates a quality of life that makes Liberty Square a favorable option for independent living, especially for households needing safe, contained spaces with social outlets. Underground parking, security-conscious design, and pet accommodations reduce daily stress and are hard to match in many rental markets. The caveat remains that this balance depends on a consistently responsive management team and a lease that clearly spells out deposit and repair procedures. The right unit paired with dependable management can tilt the scale decisively.

For families weighing assisted living options, Liberty Square offers a bridge to independence with solid safety and social infrastructure, but it is not a substitute for on-site care. It serves best those who want to stay autonomous, maintain an active social calendar, and avoid ongoing facility-level expenses - provided the management track record is clear and deposit processes are transparent. If care needs are likely to escalate or require regular hands-on supervision, alternatives with built-in care services may be more appropriate. Prospective renters should demand clarity on maintenance timelines, seek direct references about the managers, and walk through a few apartments to confirm fit. In the right circumstances, Liberty Square provides practical, comfortable living that can support a deliberate plan to reevaluate housing needs as care requirements evolve.

Located in the heart of Ammon, Idaho, this area offers a variety of amenities and services that cater to senior living needs. With several physicians, pharmacies, and hospitals in close proximity, residents have easy access to medical care. Additionally, the abundance of restaurants and cafes provides plenty of options for dining out or grabbing a coffee with friends. For entertainment, there are theaters nearby for enjoying movies or live performances. Overall, this part of Ammon offers convenience and a range of services that would make it a comfortable and practical choice for seniors looking for a vibrant community to call home.

Physicians

• Teton Retinal Institute (0.4 miles)
• Simpson DermCare & Family Medicine (0.4 miles)
• Pinnacle Health Systems (0.7 miles)
• RHS Family Medical (0.9 miles)
• BioLife Plasma Services (1 miles)
• Mental Wellness Center (1.2 miles)
• Spine Idaho (1.2 miles)

Parks

• McCowin Park (0.4 miles)

Pharmacies

• Heartland Pharmacy (0.5 miles)
• Pharmease (0.5 miles)
• Walgreens (0.5 miles)
• Teton Pharmacy (0.6 miles)
• Albertsons Sav-On Pharmacy (1 miles)
• Walmart Pharmacy (1.3 miles)
• Teton Pharmacy (1.4 miles)

Restaurants

• Domino's Pizza (0.5 miles)
• Jersey Mike's (0.9 miles)
• Fuji Sushi & Hibachi (1 miles)
• Cafe Rio Mexican Grill (1 miles)
• Costa Vida (1 miles)
• Johnny Carino's (1.1 miles)
• Cupcake Factory (1.1 miles)

Cafes

• Dutch Bros Coffee (0.9 miles)
• Starbucks (1.1 miles)
• Panera Bread (1.1 miles)

Theaters

• Regal Edwards Grand Teton (1 miles)
• Paramount Theatre (1.5 miles)

Hospitals

• Creekside Ambulatory & Surgery Center (1.2 miles)
• Idaho Falls Community Hospital (1.2 miles)
• Mountain View Hospital (1.2 miles)