10441 S Nicholson Rd, Oak Creek, WI 53154
To contact a resident: (414) 762-5118
For more information about senior living options: (866) 208-4318
Schmidt Home Costs & Pricing
At Schmidt Home, the monthly costs for accommodations present a competitively appealing option when compared to both Milwaukee County and the broader state of Wisconsin. For semi-private rooms, Schmidt Home charges $2,211, significantly lower than Milwaukee County's average of $4,341 and even more favorable than the state average of $3,977. Similarly, the pricing for studio rooms at Schmidt Home is set at $3,413, which is also less than the county's rate of $3,841 and slightly below Wisconsin's average of $3,999. These cost advantages make Schmidt Home an attractive choice for individuals seeking quality care without the financial strain often associated with similar facilities in the region.
| Floor plans | Schmidt Home | Milwaukee County | Wisconsin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Semi-Private | $2,211 | $4,341 | $3,977 |
| Studio | $3,413 | $3,841 | $3,999 |
Overall Review of Schmidt Home
Pros
The staff is amazing, compassionate, and caring.- The facility is beautiful and always clean.
- The communication between staff, families, and medical professionals is excellent.
- The team coordinates elderly care well and offers frequent fun activities and enrichment programs.
- The staff truly cares about residents’ well-being and treats them like family.
- The care team provides exceptional care and makes families feel valued.
- The dining is well-liked, and residents love the food.
- The hospice team adds supportive, positive involvement to residents’ care.
Cons
The reviewer notes the facilities are chronically understaffed, sometimes with only two workers on second shift and one on third for about 20 residents.- They report the building can be completely dark at night, with a caregiver asleep on a couch and no other staff on duty.
- They allege abuse occurred on the very first night, documented by a Ring camera, with the owner denying it and the caregiver continuing to work there.
- They claim the website misrepresents the facility as “Memory Care,” and that caregivers lack appropriate Alzheimer's training.
- They accuse the owner of downplaying abuse and blaming medication mistakes on the pharmacy.
- They advise against choosing Elizabeth Residence, pointing to leadership issues and noting all locations are owned by the same individual.
- They describe a staff member as abusive and mean to residents, including an incident where abuse was witnessed and resulted in a four-day suspension with pay.
- They label the facility as horrible and say management did nothing to stop the abuse, strongly suggesting not sending loved ones there.
- They urge readers to watch videos before considering the facility, implying it is not a safe environment.
Review
Schmidt Home in Oak Creek is best suited for families seeking a warm, person-centered environment where caregivers build real relationships with residents, daily life centers on engagement, and the atmosphere feels like a small, comfortable home. The strongest signals from multiple families describe a staff that is compassionate, attentive, and genuinely invested in residents’ well‑being. Residents are praised for enjoyable activities, clean surroundings, and a sense that staff know them by name and treat them with care. For families who value open lines of communication and a facility that emphasizes enriching programs, Schmidt Home presents as a place where daily life is purposeful and residents are treated with respect.
Yet, there are clear signals that should steer some buyers toward alternatives. A subset of reviews highlights serious concerns about safety, staffing consistency, and leadership. Allegations of nights with minimal staffing, caregiver weariness or sleep, and even abuse complaints point to meaningful gaps in supervision and accountability. These reports matter, especially for families whose loved ones require vigilant monitoring, dependable night coverage, or dementia-specific oversight. In short, the positives can shine brightly, but the shadows cast by staffing and governance concerns cannot be dismissed.
The key pros, compassionate, family-like care; strong communication with families and medical teams; consistent cleanliness and enrichment activities, do provide real value. For residents who thrive on personal attention, predictable routines, and engaging programming, these strengths can greatly improve daily quality of life and emotional well-being. However, the weight of the main cons, particularly reports of under-staffing on multiple shifts and serious behavioral or safety concerns, can erode trust and raise legitimate safety questions. The degree to which the positives can offset these risks will hinge on the facility’s ability to demonstrate reliable staffing, transparent incident handling, and robust dementia care practices.
Families evaluating Schmidt Home should insist on concrete, current assurances. Request a detailed staffing schedule that shows two-person coverage on critical shifts, a recent state inspection record, and a transparent log of any incidents with corrective actions. Observe a shift change and a night check to gauge how well the team monitors residents after hours. Ask for dementia-care training credentials for frontline aides, protocols for managing challenging behaviors, and a plan for rapid escalation if concerns arise. Inquire about how meals are planned and monitored for dietary needs, and request to speak with current residents and families about how safe and respected they feel day to day.
This community appears to work best for seniors who prize social engagement and a home‑like atmosphere, and whose families can actively participate in ongoing care decisions. It suits residents who do not require highly structured memory-care environments or constant oversight and who place high value on caregiver warmth and program variety. Those with significant memory‑care needs, high safety risk, or a history of caregiver misconduct concerns may want to explore options with more demonstrable staffing stability and stronger governance. The choice should hinge on safety first, followed by the alignment of daily life with the resident’s preferences and needs.
Ultimately, Schmidt Home can be a compelling fit for families prioritizing connection and enrichment, provided that staffing reliability and leadership transparency can be verified and maintained. If current families’ experiences are indicative, the facility can deliver a comforting, engaged environment that residents come to love. However, the prudent path requires pressing for hard data on overnight coverage, incident resolution, and dementia‑care training. When those assurances are in place, Schmidt Home becomes a credible, strong option; if not, broader exploration for safer, steadier care may be warranted.
Assisted Living
Activities on-site
Devotional services off-site
Indoor common areas
General Mitchell International (6 miles away)
Ambulatory care
Diabetic care
Meals provided
How and When Medicaid May Cover Assisted Living Costs
A Detailed Exploration of Assisted Living Medicaid Waivers Across the United States
Comprehensive Residential Support and Assisted Living Solutions for Individuals with Disabilities