Cedarlake in Green Bay, WI

Pros

• Residents describe Cedar Lake as a solid place to live since 2017, with spacious apartments featuring in-unit washers and a detached garage for convenience.
• The complex is relatively quiet, and heating costs in winter are surprisingly low.
• Maintenance is responsive, often addressing requests the same day, and the staff are friendly and helpful.
• The grounds are well kept, the lake is accessible, and residents enjoy activities like swimming, boating, and fishing.
• Many tenants say Cedar Lake feels like home and stay for years thanks to a welcoming, caring management team.
• The community hosts well-organized events that foster a friendly neighborhood vibe.
• Management and staff are professional, courteous, and dedicated to maintaining the property.
• The location offers proximity to grocery stores, trails, and other amenities, contributing to a high quality of living.

Cons

• The reviewer notes annual rent increases of about $20–$30 and no fiber internet at the complex.
• They say the management can be very picky about minor rust on vehicles.
• The property is described as basically the HOA of apartments, with restrictions like not drying towels on balconies.
• They accuse staff of spying on tenants and monitoring visitors.
• They report a mold problem from repeated pipe bursts and say it wasn’t properly treated.
• They claim security deposits are routinely withheld for cleaning and not returned in full.
• They allege discrimination and housing violations, including filing a HUD complaint.
• They state that washers and dryers never work.

Review

Cedarlake in Green Bay is best suited for adults who crave lake-adjacent living, a quiet, well-kept campus, and a maintenance-forward experience that makes day-to-day living feel stable and predictable. This community rewards residents who value an expansive, homey apartment with practical conveniences, an in-unit washer and dryer, a detached garage, and a layout that supports easy daily routines. The grounds are consistently well cared for, the lake offers appealing recreation, and the maintenance team is reliably responsive, which translates into fewer interruptions and smoother living. For someone who intends to stay long term, Cedarlake can feel like a settled, reassuring place to call home. It is particularly attractive for residents who want proximity to shops, trails, and Green Bay’s downtown energy without sacrificing the calm that a lakeside setting provides. Those seeking constant high-end modernization or ultra-flexible guest policies will want alternatives.

Alternatives may be worth considering for renters who prize complete transparency and tenant-friendly policies, minimal intrusion, or a more hands-off owner-operator experience. Several reviewers flag governance-like rules that feel overbearing, along with strict expectations around vehicles, visitors, and even what can be displayed or stored on the property. If the priority is immediate, unencumbered freedom, especially around guests or the look and feel of the leasing process, another operator or smaller, owner-managed property could offer a more relaxed environment. Also, for tenants who rely on fiber internet or other high-specifications, Cedarlake’s current connectivity limitation is a practical drawback to weigh against the lake vista and cost efficiency.

On the upside, the strongest positives center on functional livability that directly supports aging in place and everyday comfort. The apartments are large and practical, with in-unit laundry and garage space that reduce clutter and logistics, while the groundskeeping, lake access, and built-in sense of community foster a reassuring routine. Maintenance issues, when they arise, tend to be addressed quickly, and staff interactions are consistently described as friendly and capable. This combination of responsive service and stable surroundings makes Cedarlake an attractive choice for residents who want to avoid the churn and drama that can accompany living in a larger, less resident-focused complex. The heat efficiency mentioned by several tenants also translates into lower seasonal costs, a practical plus for year-round budgeting.

Yet the most pervasive concerns run counter to the otherwise solid day-to-day experience. Rent increases occur annually, sometimes by noticeable margins, which can erode affordability over time for fixed-income households or those evaluating long-term residency. Several tenants report ongoing HOA-like enforcement of rules that feel intrusive, limits on how visitors are treated, what can be parked, and how spaces must be used, creating a climate that feels more prescriptive than protective. Some reviews raise serious red flags about privacy and management’s approach to compliance, including allegations of discriminatory practices and background checks on visitors, which have understandably left prospective renters wary. Add to this the more troubling accounts of delayed repairs in mold-prone situations after service issues, and the risk calculus shifts toward caution for those with greater health or safety sensitivities.

To make a sound decision, prospective renters should enter Cedarlake with a clear checklist and firm expectations. Key questions should cover the exact annual rent escalation schedule and what it covers, the policy on security deposits and what constitutes allowable deductions for cleaning or wear, and the specific rules that govern guest parking and access. Demand a straightforward, written remediation plan for any past mold or water-related incidents and insist on a documented maintenance timeline for issues that affect health and safety. For those who require fiber or higher-speed internet, verify current offerings and costs upfront. Finally, seek out current residents to gauge consistency of experience across units and buildings, and request a formal move-in and move-out walkthrough to minimize disputes over deposits and charges later.

In practical terms, Cedarlake represents a strong value proposition for the right resident: a lakeside, low-maintenance lifestyle with solid maintenance support, quiet surroundings, and a sense of community that endures over years. The flip side is a governance-heavy environment where annual price bumps and restrictive policies can become meaningful friction points, especially for households that prioritize flexibility and privacy. If the decision favors stability, predictable upkeep, and an environment that feels like home rather than a transactional rental, Cedarlake stands up well. If, however, quick, frictionless guest access, cutting-edge amenities, or tenant-rights transparency are nonnegotiable, alternative options should be explored first. The choice hinges on balancing the tangible daily comforts against the more contentious policy and price dynamics that color the long view.

This part of Green Bay, Wisconsin offers a variety of amenities and services that cater to a senior lifestyle. With a range of restaurants including Subway, Taco Bell, and Kroll's East within close proximity, seniors can enjoy convenient dining options. Additionally, there are several pharmacies such as Walgreens and Aurora Pharmacy nearby for easy access to medications. For healthcare needs, there are reputable physicians like Forefront Dermatology and Prevea Clinic, as well as hospitals like Brown County Community Treatment and Aurora BayCare OB/GYN in the vicinity. The area also boasts parks like Farlin Park and Christa McAuliffe Park for leisurely outdoor activities, as well as cafes such as Julie's Cafe & Catering for social gatherings. Overall, this part of Green Bay provides a well-rounded environment for seniors looking to reside in a convenient and comfortable neighborhood.

Restaurants

• Escapades (0.2 miles)
• Subway (0.6 miles)
• Taco Bell (0.6 miles)
• McDonald's (1.7 miles)
• Kroll's East (1.7 miles)
• Pauly G's (1.9 miles)
• McDonald's (1.9 miles)

Pharmacies

• Walgreens (0.7 miles)
• Aurora Pharmacy (1.9 miles)
• Walgreens (2 miles)
• Walgreens (2.4 miles)
• Streu's Pharmacy Bay Natural (2.6 miles)
• Aurora Pharmacy (2.7 miles)
• Walgreens (2.8 miles)

Physicians

• Milo C Huempfner Department of Veterans Affairs Outpatient Clinic (0.7 miles)
• Nicolet Psychiatric Center (1.5 miles)
• Forefront Dermatology Green Bay, WI - Superior Road (2.1 miles)
• Donald Massenburg, MD, PhD (2.3 miles)
• Prevea Clinic (2.3 miles)
• Rai Ashok Prevea Orthopedics (2.3 miles)
• Northeast Wisconsin Community Clinic (2.6 miles)

Hospitals

• Brown County Community Treatment (0.8 miles)
• Aurora BayCare OB/GYN (2.2 miles)
• Pediatrics Intensive Care Unit At St Vincents (2.7 miles)
• Aurora BayCare Emergency Department (2.9 miles)
• Abmc - Nicu (2.9 miles)
• Bellin Health Cardiology Associates - Green Bay (3 miles)
• ABMC Resource Library (3 miles)

Parks

• Dog Walking Street (1.4 miles)
• Farlin Park (1.5 miles)
• Christa McAuliffe Park (2 miles)
• Leicht Memorial Park (3.2 miles)

Cafes

• Julie's Cafe & Catering (1.7 miles)
• Panera Bread (2.1 miles)
• Kavarna (3.3 miles)

Theaters

• Green Bay East Cinema Green Bay, Wi (2.4 miles)