Cedarlake in Green Bay, WI

Pros

• Cedar Lake is described as an amazing place to live, with a caring and responsive staff.
• The maintenance team is quick to respond and keeps common areas well maintained.
• The lake, grounds, and trails offer a scenic and peaceful living environment.
• The apartments are clean and well maintained.
• The office and maintenance staff are friendly, welcoming, and professional.
• Polly is praised as the friendliest leasing agent, helping new residents feel at home.
• The community is touted for its safety, cleanliness, and well-kept surroundings.
• Many residents say Cedar Lake feels like home and would recommend it.

Cons

• They note a burst water pipe caused mold, and management delayed addressing it, plastered over the hole without treating the mold, leading to odors and respiratory problems.
• They describe the landlord Brenda Bott as snobby and hostile, dismissing mold concerns with statements like "mold takes years to grow."
• They feel the rent increases were unfair, with billing errors and an unexpected outstanding balance after initial charges were omitted.
• They allege Toonen prioritizes money over tenants, including unlawful discrimination related to an ESA and questionable eviction practices.
• They claim security deposits were kept for general cleaning rather than actual damages, sometimes after threatening to sue.
• They report washers and dryers that never work and maintenance that is slow or ineffective.
• They advise others to avoid the property and say they would not recommend Cedar Lake due to consistent issues and poor treatment.

Review

Cedarlake in Green Bay is best suited for renters who want a lakefront, park-like setting with dependable maintenance and a strong sense of community, without chasing luxury. The property delivers a practical, affordable option where the lake, trails, and well?kept grounds are easy to access, and maintenance crews tend to respond promptly when called. For adults who prize a serene, walkable environment, a quiet residential vibe, and reliable project-level upkeep, Cedarlake offers a straightforward, livable baseline. The property's 3.8 rating from 46 reviews reflects a solid core appeal, but also signals notable caveats tied to management and policy consistency. It is a choice that pays off for those who can tolerate some variability in how rules are enforced and how tensions with management are handled.

Those who should consider alternatives are renters who demand crystal-clear transparency in pricing, renewals, and deposits, or who cannot tolerate uneven treatment or documented disputes with landlords. Multiple reviews recount billing mistakes, unexpected rent increases, and delayed or disputed charges around move-out expenses. Instances of housing discrimination complaints and a history of aggressive administrative responses suggest a risk profile that may unsettle tenants who rely on predictable policy enforcement and straightforward, rule-based interactions. Families with kids or tenants needing flexible pet or accommodation policies may also want to compare other Green Bay options where guardrails around rules and deposits feel firmer.

On the upside, maintenance and operations stand out as reliable strengths. Several tenants commend quick, responsive maintenance and friendly office staff, along with grounds that are consistently well kept. The lakefront access and opportunities for outdoor recreation - swimming, fishing, and seasonal enjoyment - add tangible, lifestyle-oriented value. A number of long-term residents describe a sense of stability and belonging, with staff who are known quantities and a familiar, established routine. For residents who value timely fixes, courteous service, and a campus that feels cared for, Cedarlake delivers a practical, low-drama living experience.

The downside is real and substantial in several reviews. Mold and water-damage concerns tied to a burst pipe exposed shortcomings in remediation, and the perceived lack of decisive, thorough treatment left some tenants exposed to ongoing discomfort and health worries. Management interactions in these scenarios are described as slow or combative, sometimes culminating in distrust or dissatisfaction with how problems are handled. More troubling are repeated complaints about security deposits - retention, itemized charges, and disputes over what constitutes "cleaning" versus damage. Legal complaints and eviction-style pressure around accommodations further complicate the picture, suggesting that the financial and personal costs of moving in and out can be heavier here than at comparable properties.

Whether the positives outweigh the negatives depends on risk tolerance and due diligence. For tenants who can secure a unit with minimal exposure to serious maintenance issues and who are prepared to document communications and charges, Cedarlake's advantages - lake access, safety, dependable maintenance, and a cohesive community - still offer meaningful value. Yet the specter of mold, management friction, and deposit disputes can erode daily satisfaction and financial predictability. Prospective residents should seek explicit, written policies on deposits, renewals, and remediation, and consider requesting recent maintenance logs and a clear walkthrough of the unit before signing. A thorough, unit-by-unit inspection can help distinguish well-run spaces from those carrying latent trouble.

In the final assessment, Cedarlake serves as a practical, location-forward option for adults prioritizing a scenic, peaceful setting and reliable upkeep, with maintenance realities that consistently prove manageable in the absence of major disputes. However, it is not a fit for those who require ironclad transparency, predictable financial terms, and uniformly fair treatment. For families or individuals who prize rights, clarity, and trouble-free deposit handling, exploring other Green Bay communities with stronger tenant-rights histories is prudent. If the priority remains a lake-adjacent lifestyle supported by responsive service and a welcoming environment, Cedarlake remains a reasonable choice - provided careful due diligence and tempered expectations align with the documented experiences.

This part of Green Bay, Wisconsin offers a variety of amenities and services that cater to a senior lifestyle. With a range of restaurants including Subway, Taco Bell, and Kroll's East within close proximity, seniors can enjoy convenient dining options. Additionally, there are several pharmacies such as Walgreens and Aurora Pharmacy nearby for easy access to medications. For healthcare needs, there are reputable physicians like Forefront Dermatology and Prevea Clinic, as well as hospitals like Brown County Community Treatment and Aurora BayCare OB/GYN in the vicinity. The area also boasts parks like Farlin Park and Christa McAuliffe Park for leisurely outdoor activities, as well as cafes such as Julie's Cafe & Catering for social gatherings. Overall, this part of Green Bay provides a well-rounded environment for seniors looking to reside in a convenient and comfortable neighborhood.

Restaurants

• Escapades (0.2 miles)
• Subway (0.6 miles)
• Taco Bell (0.6 miles)
• McDonald's (1.7 miles)
• Kroll's East (1.7 miles)
• Pauly G's (1.9 miles)
• McDonald's (1.9 miles)

Pharmacies

• Walgreens (0.7 miles)
• Aurora Pharmacy (1.9 miles)
• Walgreens (2 miles)
• Walgreens (2.4 miles)
• Streu's Pharmacy Bay Natural (2.6 miles)
• Aurora Pharmacy (2.7 miles)
• Walgreens (2.8 miles)

Physicians

• Milo C Huempfner Department of Veterans Affairs Outpatient Clinic (0.7 miles)
• Nicolet Psychiatric Center (1.5 miles)
• Forefront Dermatology Green Bay, WI - Superior Road (2.1 miles)
• Donald Massenburg, MD, PhD (2.3 miles)
• Prevea Clinic (2.3 miles)
• Rai Ashok Prevea Orthopedics (2.3 miles)
• Northeast Wisconsin Community Clinic (2.6 miles)

Hospitals

• Brown County Community Treatment (0.8 miles)
• Aurora BayCare OB/GYN (2.2 miles)
• Pediatrics Intensive Care Unit At St Vincents (2.7 miles)
• Aurora BayCare Emergency Department (2.9 miles)
• Abmc - Nicu (2.9 miles)
• Bellin Health Cardiology Associates - Green Bay (3 miles)
• ABMC Resource Library (3 miles)

Parks

• Dog Walking Street (1.4 miles)
• Farlin Park (1.5 miles)
• Christa McAuliffe Park (2 miles)
• Leicht Memorial Park (3.2 miles)

Cafes

• Julie's Cafe & Catering (1.7 miles)
• Panera Bread (2.1 miles)
• Kavarna (3.3 miles)

Theaters

• Green Bay East Cinema Green Bay, Wi (2.4 miles)