Talk to an advisor (866) 208-4318

Otterbein St. Marys

Otterbein St. Marys is an assisted living and memory care community in St. Marys, OH.

Information last verified:

Otterbein St. Marys

Save

  • Interior

    A cozy open-concept living space featuring a seating area, kitchen, and dining area.
  • Outdoors

    A scenic view of a lakeside area featuring vibrant flowers, cozy houses, and a serene dock.
  • Decor

    A cozy bedroom with a metal-frame bed, decorative pillows, and wall art above the headboard. A nightstand with a lamp sits beside the bed.
  • Living Room

    A cozy living room with traditional decor, featuring armchairs and warm lighting.
  • Building

    A brick building with an overhang at the entrance.
  • Architecture

    A row of suburban houses with well-maintained lawns and driveways.
  • Trees

    A large clock tower building with a spacious driveway and surrounding greenery.
  • Dining

    A cozy dining room with round tables and a fireplace.
  • Landscaping

    A single-story house with a neatly maintained garden and a covered porch.
  • Kitchen

    A cozy kitchen with a dining area, featuring white cabinets and a central light fixture.
  • Outdoor

    A picturesque gazebo overlooking a serene lake, surrounded by lush greenery.
  • Nature

    Two people fishing from a dock by a lake.
  • Exercise Equipment

    An elderly man exercises in a gym, lifting dumbbells while seated and looking at the mirror.
  • Swimming Pool

    People enjoying a swim in an indoor pool.

11230 State Route 364, St. Marys, OH 45885

For more information about senior living options: (866) 208-4318

4.6 from 40 reviews
5 stars
34
4 stars
2
3 stars
0
2 stars
0
1 stars
4

Seniors.FYI Elite Community Awards

Top 5% Senior Living Community in 2016

Add this award to your website

Otterbein St. Marys Costs & Pricing

At Otterbein St. Marys, the monthly costs for accommodation present an appealing value compared to both Mercer County and the broader state of Ohio. For instance, a studio at Otterbein is priced at $1,600, significantly lower than the county average of $4,133 and the state average of $3,727. Similarly, a one-bedroom unit is offered at $2,200, which is more economical than the Mercer County cost of $3,333 and slightly less than the state average of $3,712. Even for two-bedroom accommodations, priced at $2,800 at Otterbein, residents benefit from savings compared to the county's average of $3,305 and the state's $3,501. Overall, these figures highlight Otterbein St. Marys as a cost-effective option for prospective residents seeking quality housing in a competitive market.

Floor plansOtterbein St. MarysMercer CountyOhio
Studio$1,600$4,133$3,727
1 Bedroom$2,200$3,333$3,712
2 Bedrooms$2,800$3,305$3,501

Overall Review of Otterbein St. Marys

differentiator 3 reviews mention this

Pricing runs below regional averages

Pricing is a major reason some families chose this community.

Several reviewers point to cost when explaining their decision, including choosing Otterbein based on price and noting it felt less expensive while still comparable. The community’s pricing also comes in well below both county and state benchmarks across unit types. One review also mentions an investment program designed to lower rent, alongside the broader “security” it offered in their planning.

common 23 reviews mention this

Friendly, helpful staff show up

Residents and families repeatedly describe staff as welcoming and helpful.

Across many reviews, people describe staff as friendly, welcoming, and ready to assist, whether during move-in, everyday questions, or when support is needed. Several reviewers also mention nurses and aides as compassionate and responsive, and a number of families say they never had major problems with staff. Even reviews that criticize other parts of the experience still single out the care team’s kindness.

common 13 reviews mention this

Plenty of activities to join

There are lots of activities for different ability levels.

Residents and visitors describe a steady flow of activities, from scheduled daily events to community-sponsored gatherings and outings. Multiple reviews highlight how easy it is to meet neighbors through these programs, and a few mention enjoying specific events like classes and seasonal gatherings. The community also offers a range of religious and educational options, which shows up in how reviewers talk about day-to-day engagement.

common 5 reviews mention this

Care support is there when needed

Families describe care help as available when physical support is needed.

Some reviewers talk about being able to live with independence while knowing help is available if needs change, including assistance with daily tasks and medical routines. Others specifically praise nursing care and say their loved ones were well cared for, with compassion highlighted as part of the experience. One review also describes moving through care levels within the community, including access to hospice.

common 3 reviews mention this

Food is a frequent positive

Dining shows up positively in multiple reviews.

Reviewers mention food they enjoyed, including a standout fish dinner at an event and positive comments about day-to-day meals. A couple of families say they either haven’t heard complaints or describe meals as very good. The community offers restaurant-style dining along with prepared meals and support for special dietary restrictions, matching what residents describe about dining.

caveat 4 reviews mention this

Some families report care breakdowns

A subset of reviews raises concerns about care continuity and staffing.

Not all experiences are positive: a few reviewers describe situations involving missed personal care needs and overall neglect. Another review calls out understaffing and overwork, while still acknowledging the kindness of nurses and aides. There are also complaints about management decisions around care level moves and a lack of timely communication, which some families say added stress during an already difficult time.

How we summarize

Counts show how many written reviews mention each theme; a review can touch several themes, and only frequently mentioned themes are displayed.

Features

Housing

  • 101 resident community capacity 101 resident community capacity

Types of Care

  • Active Adult Communities (55+) Active Adult Communities (55+)
  • Assisted Living Assisted Living
  • Continuing Care Retirement Community (CCRC) Continuing Care Retirement Community (CCRC)
  • Independent Living Independent Living
  • Memory Care Memory Care
  • Respite Care Respite Care
  • Skilled Nursing Facility Skilled Nursing Facility

Pets

  • Cats allowed Cats allowed
  • Dogs allowed Dogs allowed

Amenities

  • Activities off-site Activities off-site
  • Activities on-site Activities on-site
  • Air-conditioning Air-conditioning
  • Bath tubs Bath tubs
  • Beautician on-site Beautician on-site
  • Beauty salon Beauty salon
  • Cable or satellite TV Cable or satellite TV
  • Computer center Computer center
  • Devotional services off-site Devotional services off-site
  • Devotional services on-site Devotional services on-site
  • Fitness room Fitness room
  • Full kitchen Full kitchen
  • Fully furnished Fully furnished
  • Gaming room Gaming room
  • Garden Garden
  • Ground floor units Ground floor units
  • Handicap accessible Handicap accessible
  • Housekeeping services Housekeeping services
  • Indoor common areas Indoor common areas
  • Kitchenette Kitchenette
  • Move-in coordination Move-in coordination
  • Outdoor common areas Outdoor common areas
  • Outdoor space Outdoor space
  • Private bathrooms Private bathrooms
  • Respite or short term stays offered Respite or short term stays offered
  • Restaurant-style dining Restaurant-style dining
  • Small library Small library
  • Swimming pool / hot tub Swimming pool / hot tub
  • Telephone Telephone
  • Wellness center Wellness center
  • Wheelchair accessible showers Wheelchair accessible showers
  • Wi-Fi/high-speed internet available Wi-Fi/high-speed internet available

Transportation

  • Community operated transportation Community operated transportation
  • Transportation arrangement Transportation arrangement
  • Transportation arrangement (non-medical) Transportation arrangement (non-medical)

Care Services

  • 24-hour call system 24-hour call system
  • 24-hour supervision 24-hour supervision
  • Activities of daily living assistance Activities of daily living assistance
  • Assistance with bathing Assistance with bathing
  • Assistance with dressing Assistance with dressing
  • Assistance with transfers Assistance with transfers
  • Diabetes diet Diabetes diet
  • Diabetic care Diabetic care
  • High acuity care High acuity care
  • Incontinence care Incontinence care
  • Meal preparation and service Meal preparation and service
  • Medication management Medication management
  • Special dietary restrictions Special dietary restrictions

Dining

  • Anytime dining Anytime dining
  • Diabetes diet Diabetes diet
  • Gluten-free Gluten-free
  • Guest meals Guest meals
  • Low / no sodium Low / no sodium
  • Meals provided Meals provided
  • No Sugar No Sugar
  • Professional chef Professional chef
  • Restaurant style dining Restaurant style dining
  • Room service Room service
  • Special dietary restrictions Special dietary restrictions
  • Special dining programs Special dining programs
  • Vegetarian Vegetarian

Activities

  • Art classes Art classes
  • Catholic services Catholic services
  • Community-sponsored activities Community-sponsored activities
  • Concierge services Concierge services
  • Cooking classes Cooking classes
  • Day trips and outings Day trips and outings
  • Devotional activities offsite Devotional activities offsite
  • Devotional activities on-site Devotional activities on-site
  • Educational speakers / life long learning Educational speakers / life long learning
  • Fitness programs Fitness programs
  • Karaoke Karaoke
  • Live well programs Live well programs
  • Other religious services Other religious services
  • Planned day trips Planned day trips
  • Protestant services Protestant services
  • Resident-run activities Resident-run activities
  • Scheduled daily activities Scheduled daily activities
  • Visiting chaplain or priest Visiting chaplain or priest

Nearby Places of Interest

This part of St. Marys, Ohio offers a variety of amenities and services that cater to seniors looking for a comfortable and convenient living environment. With several restaurants, cafes, and pharmacies nearby, you will have easy access to dining options and healthcare services. The presence of parks and places of worship provides opportunities for relaxation and spiritual growth. Additionally, the proximity to hospitals and medical centers ensures that you will have access to quality healthcare when needed. Overall, this area is well-equipped to meet the needs of seniors looking for a safe and vibrant community to call home.

Restaurants

  • Rustic Haven (0.6 miles)
  • Xcaret Mexican Restaurant (2.3 miles)
  • Domino's Pizza (2.4 miles)
  • Behm's Restaurant (2.4 miles)
  • Daves BBQ (2.5 miles)
  • Varsity Lanes (2.8 miles)
  • Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill (3 miles)

Transportation

  • Enterprise Rent-A-Car (2.3 miles)
  • M & M Logistics (7.2 miles)

Physicians

  • Orthopaedic Institute of Ohio (2.4 miles)
  • Alliance For Women's Health (3.3 miles)
  • Maurice K Chung MD (3.3 miles)
  • Southland Family Medicine Assocs (3.4 miles)
  • New Day Pain Management Center (3.6 miles)
  • Pediatric Health Care Center (3.6 miles)
  • Grand Lake Primary Care At St Marys (3.6 miles)

Parks

  • Grand Lake St Marys State Park (2.4 miles)
  • K. C. Geiger Park (3.1 miles)
  • Chickasaw Park (6.7 miles)
  • Eastview Park & Recreation (6.8 miles)
  • Dog Park (7.8 miles)

Places of Worship

  • Nwo Nazarene District Office (2.6 miles)
  • Nazarene District Center (2.6 miles)
  • St Paul's United Church of Christ (2.7 miles)
  • Living Hope Ag Church (3 miles)
  • Holy Redeemer Church (6.1 miles)
  • Precious Blood Catholic Church (6.3 miles)
  • New Life Apostolic (7 miles)

Pharmacies

  • Rite Aid (3 miles)
  • Sipes Wellness Center (3 miles)
  • Kroger Pharmacy (3.7 miles)
  • Kroger Grocery Pickup and Delivery (3.7 miles)
  • Schwieterman Pharmacy (3.7 miles)
  • Schwieterman Pharmacy (5.8 miles)
  • Schwieterman's Drug Store (5.8 miles)

Cafes

  • Green Thumb Farm Fresh Cafe (3.5 miles)
  • Starbucks (3.7 miles)
  • Biggby Coffee (7.2 miles)
  • Biggby Coffee (7.2 miles)
  • Brew Nation (7.9 miles)

Hospitals

  • Joint Twp Dist Memorial Hosp (3.6 miles)
  • Wound Care Center (3.7 miles)
  • Lima Memorial Hospital Outpatient Dialysis (3.8 miles)
  • Grand Lake Occupational Medicine (3.8 miles)
  • Kidney Services-W Central Oh (7.2 miles)
  • Joint Twp Dist Memorial Hosp (7.2 miles)
  • Kidney Services of West Central Ohio (7.3 miles)

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to live at Otterbein St. Marys in St. Marys, OH?
Where is Otterbein St. Marys?
Does Otterbein St. Marys provide care for residents with dementia or Alzheimer's disease?
Does Otterbein St. Marys allow residents to have pets?
What photos are available for Otterbein St. Marys in St. Marys, Ohio?

Nearby Communities

  • Grande Lake Healthcare Center

    Grande Lake Healthcare Center

    Saint Marys, OH

    2.8 from 17 reviews
     

    pro Comprehensive memory care with 24/7 supervision and engaging activities.

  • Vancrest of St Marys

    Vancrest of St Marys

    Saint Marys, OH

    3.9 from 16 reviews
     

    pro Fully furnished apartments with 24/7 supervision and a mental wellness program.

  • Vancrest Of St Mary's

    Vancrest Of St Mary's

    St Marys, OH

    4 from 13 reviews
     

    pro Active social environment with restaurant-style dining, outdoor spaces, and convenient amenities.

  • Transitional Care Unit

    Transitional Care Unit

    Saint Marys, OH

    3.1 from 110 reviews
     

    pro Small, personalized 15-bed unit with furnished rooms, nutritious meals, and 24/7 ADL/supervision support.

  • Elmwood Assisted Living Of New Bremen

    Elmwood Assisted Living Of New Bremen

    New Bremen, OH

    5 from 3 reviews
     

    pro Strong memory care program with extensive on-site amenities.

  • The Gardens at Celina

    The Gardens at Celina

    Celina, OH

    4.9 from 100 reviews
    $2,999 to $3,579 / month

    pro Friendly staff and accommodating tour guide

  • Celina Manor

    Celina Manor

    Celina, OH

    3.3 from 63 reviews
     

    pro 24/7 supervision with nursing support and restaurant-style dining in a fully furnished setting.

  • Briarwood Village

    Briarwood Village

    Coldwater, OH

    4.3 from 15 reviews
    $2,875 to $8,100 / month

    pro Caring, responsive staff in a clean, community-focused setting.

  • Ohio Living Dorothy Love

    Ohio Living Dorothy Love

    Sidney, OH

    4.4 from 81 reviews
    $3,509 to $6,060 / month

    pro Compassionate staff in a clean, welcoming, and engaging community.

Assisted Living in Nearby Cities

Related Resources

  • dementia and angerWhen Dementia Sparks Anger and Aggression: Understanding the Connection and Ways to Cope

    Dementia leads to cognitive impairment and can cause emotional and behavioral changes, including aggression that arises from frustration, confusion, or fear. Effective coping strategies for caregivers include understanding dementia's nature, recognizing triggers, using empathetic communication, and employing non-pharmacological interventions like music and art therapy.

  • dementia behaviorsDementia Behaviors: In-Depth Understanding and Effective Coping Strategies

    Dementia causes cognitive decline and challenging behaviors that caregivers must manage, necessitating an understanding of the neurological basis of these issues. Effective strategies and self-care for caregivers can enhance support for those with dementia and improve their daily lives.

  • does my mom have dementia quiz5 Early Indicators of Dementia and What You Can Do

    The content outlines five key early indicators of dementia, including significant memory loss and confusion about time and place, while emphasizing the need for professional evaluation and emotional support for both individuals showing symptoms and their caregivers. It encourages family members to monitor these signs closely and use online quizzes for initial awareness.

Call a senior care advisor
By clicking submit, you agree to our Partner's Terms of Use. You also consent to receive calls and texts, which may be autodialed, from our Partner. Your consent is not a condition to using our Partner's service. Please visit our Partner's Privacy Policy for information about their privacy practices.