9508 South Street, Le Roy, NY 14482
To contact a resident: (585) 768-8862
For more information about senior living options: (866) 208-4318
South Street Senior Care Costs & Pricing
South Street Senior Care offers competitive pricing for its services when compared to both Monroe County and the broader New York state averages. For semi-private accommodations, residents pay $2,750 per month, significantly lower than the county's average of $3,412 and the state average of $4,389. Similarly, for private rooms, South Street maintains an attractive rate of $3,500, which is slightly above the county average of $3,375 but considerably more affordable than New York's state average of $5,159. These rates reflect South Street's commitment to providing quality care at a value that is accessible to seniors in the community.
| Floor plans | South Street Senior Care | Monroe County | New York |
|---|---|---|---|
| Semi-Private | $2,750 | $3,412 | $4,389 |
| Private | $3,500 | $3,375 | $5,159 |
Overall Review of South Street Senior Care
Pros
Visitors are greeted with smiles and warmth upon entering the home.- The owner takes time to speak personally with family members, helping them feel the home could be theirs.
- The home atmosphere encourages socializing, with meals shared together and an always-open kitchen.
- Staff are attentive, helping residents with phones and TV issues and ensuring everyone stays hydrated with water and juice.
- The home is safe, clean, and well organized.
- The environment is bright, clean, and distinctly feels like a true home rather than a large, impersonal facility.
- Cindy and her helper are highly qualified and genuinely love what they do.
Cons
It is quite expensive for a one-bedroom and shared bathrooms.- There are no openings.
- Some of the bedrooms are small.
- The tour suggested that residents did not have major mobility issues, implying limited suitability for mobility-impaired individuals.
Review
South Street Senior Care in Le Roy is best suited for older adults who want a true home-like setting where caregivers treat residents as family, meals are shared, and daily life feels intimate rather than institutional. This community earns its appeal with warmth, a small-house atmosphere, and robust social opportunities that keep residents engaged. It works particularly well for seniors who are active, enjoy light outdoor time, and value personal connections with the owner and care team. Those prioritizing maximum privacy, large private rooms, or intensive medical nursing should consider alternatives, as the setting leans toward a family-oriented, semi-private experience rather than a clinical footprint.
The strongest selling points center on atmosphere and relationships. First impressions are consistently positive: greetings are warm, and the owner often connects directly with families, signaling a genuine investment in residents’ sense of belonging. The home feels safe, clean, and well organized, with a kitchen that remains open for social dining and a steady flow of snacks, water, and juices. Staff willingness to help with phones, TV issues, and day-to-day conveniences reinforces the sense that care is attentive and personal. Residents stay involved through socializing, outdoor time, and regular walking, all of which support both safety and mood in a setting that feels like a welcoming household.
Cost is a recurring theme, but not a simple drawback. Reviewers note that the price point is in line with similar options in the region, which does not position South Street as a bargain, nor as overpriced outliers. The living space, while bright and homey, can include smaller bedrooms and shared bathrooms. Yet those trade-offs are offset by the value of a close-knit, family-like culture and the reassurance of attentive staff who clearly enjoy their roles. The care team, including Cindy and her helper, is described as highly qualified and genuinely invested in residents’ happiness and well-being, a factor that often makes the cost feel more justified to families seeking a loving environment.
However, realism matters: several reviewers flag practical limits. Some bedrooms are small, and the absence of private baths may be a deal-breaker for those who prioritize privacy. A notable caveat is the impression that the community does not primarily serve residents with major mobility issues; this raises questions for families with dads or moms who need more intensive assistance or accessible design features. Availability can also be an issue, one review notes no openings, a reminder that this is a small, intimate setting with limited capacity. Finally, the upsell of social participation means families should expect to engage in activities rather than rely on a turnkey program.
These strengths and limitations align to deliver a practical verdict: the home-like, person-centered environment offsets the smaller rooms and higher price for families who value daily warmth, social engagement, and visible, loving caregiving. The key to satisfaction lies in active participation, families should anticipate contributing to activities and fostering a sense of community alongside staff. The overall experience is less about clinical oversight and more about a comforting, family-oriented routine, with safety, cleanliness, and thoughtful touches reinforcing that tone.
Prospective residents who require extensive medical nursing, private accommodations, or a highly structured clinical schedule may want to consider alternatives. Facilities with larger, private rooms, more formal medical staffing, or memory-care capabilities may suit those needs better. For seniors who thrive in a small, neighborly setting and who can benefit from shared meals, social programming, and daily walks, South Street Senior Care stands out as a compelling choice. With openings occasionally limited, families should act promptly when a fit appears, scheduling multiple visits to observe interactions, tour the living areas, and confirm that the pace and philosophy align with the senior’s priorities and care needs.
Board and Care Home
Cats allowed
Dogs allowed
Activities off-site
Bath tubs
Devotional services on-site
Indoor common areas
Outdoor common areas
Private
Private bathrooms
Respite or short term stays offered
Wheelchair accessible showers
Greater Rochester International (19 miles away)
Ambulatory care
Diabetic care
High acuity care
Medication management
Meals provided
Supportive Employee Benefits That Help Caregivers Attain Better Work-Life Harmony
Top Cars for Senior Drivers and Essential Safety Innovations
A Closer Look at Private Pay Home Care
