2345 West 86th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46260
For more information about senior living options: (866) 208-4318
Overall Review of St Augustine Home For The Aged
Pros
It is the most loving, compassionate place filled with incredible sisters and caregivers.- The staff is caring, patient-focused, and willing to go the extra mile.
- Residents receive a high level of love and care.
- The facility is exceptionally clean and well maintained.
- The Little Sisters of the Poor are loving, caring, and wonderful to be around.
- Their vow of hospitality shows in daily work, making everyone feel comfortable.
- They bring great joy and comfort to residents at the end of life.
- The kitchen staff prepare healthy, nutritious meals, with community support meeting residents' needs.
- The activities team keeps residents engaged with events, music, and daily structure.
- The home is a true melting pot of faiths, races, and nationalities.
Cons
The food was a little mushier than what the reviewer was used to, though it was tasty.- The facility looks older, having been built in 1967, which may be seen as a drawback.
Review
St Augustine Home For the Aged is best suited for families seeking a deeply compassionate, hands-on care environment where staff relationships with residents are intentional and long-lasting. The campus is a quietly devoted, faith-informed community that prioritizes warmth, patient focus, and consistent oversight. It provides both assisted living and full-time care, with an atmosphere that feels intimate rather than institutional. Cleanliness is repeatedly celebrated, giving families confidence that residents live in a hygienic, well-tended setting. The Little Sisters of the Poor anchor daily life with hospitality, routine, and meaningful touchpoints, meals, worship, and social gatherings, that help residents feel seen and respected. For families who value a close-knit, service-oriented culture and a steady, predictable cadence to each day, this community is a compelling match.
That said, this campus is not the best fit for every family. Those seeking the absolute newest building with cutting-edge rehab technology or an expansive, highly specialized memory-care wing should compare alternatives. The facility dates to 1967, and while it is well maintained and slated for future modernization, its look and feel may feel dated to residents accustomed to newer interiors. For families prioritizing maximum independence with minimal on-site medical oversight, other campuses with broader menus of therapy options and more aggressive rehab programming may be preferable. It’s also worth assessing how religious programming aligns with family expectations, even though care here welcomes residents of diverse faiths.
On balance, the core advantages largely offset the drawbacks of an older structure. The nursing and CNA teams are consistently described as top-notch, with medical updates communicated clearly to families and clinicians who stay closely involved in care plans. Maintenance staff are praised for responsiveness and helpfulness, from routine repairs to finding a dropped remote, underscoring how operational reliability supports daily peace of mind. Nutritious meals are a constant priority, prepared to meet health guidelines while responding to resident preferences. The activity team builds daily structure through events, music, and celebrations, an important counterbalance to the clinical routine and a strong antidote to social isolation.
The environment itself reinforces the value proposition. Spacious rooms and a campus that includes a chapel with stained glass and a second-story balcony contribute to a sense of continuity, ritual, and dignity. Residents enjoy a welcoming garden and a calendar full of social opportunities that foster purpose and engagement. Although rooted in Catholic hospitality, the community’s care is inclusive, serving residents of various faiths and backgrounds. Leadership transitions, including the retirement of the Director of Nursing, appear to be managed smoothly, with experienced staff stepping into key roles to preserve continuity and quality of care.
Where the conversations tend to surface concerns, it helps to acknowledge a few practical notes. Some families may prefer a more modern ambiance or turn-key rehab facilities, and the age of the building can feel limiting in that regard. A review mentioning meals that were “mushier” than expected suggests a potential area for customization, taste and texture can vary, so touring with a specific meal plan and dietary needs in mind is prudent. Leadership changes, while not destabilizing in reported experience, are a reminder to confirm the current clinical leadership and how care plans are coordinated with families. Overall, these are manageable considerations next to the consistent, heartfelt care that dominates most feedback.
In the end, St Augustine Home For the Aged stands out as a reliable, purpose-built option where residents are treated like family and care is delivered with real warmth and competence. It suits families who place a premium on caregiver devotion, a clean and orderly environment, and a community anchored by hospitality and ritual. Those who require the most modern amenities, or who insist on a completely secular setting, should keep scanning options and compare carefully. A thoughtful tour, asking about memory-care capabilities, dietary customization, and the structure of clinical leadership, will reveal whether the culture and daily rhythms align with the resident’s needs. With a 4.7 rating across 18 reviews, this campus offers seasoned reliability, clear devotion to residents, and a caring community that many families will want to call home.
67 resident community capacity
Assisted Living
Skilled Nursing Facility
Activities on-site
Air-conditioning
Beauty salon
Cable or satellite TV
Computer center
Devotional services off-site
Dining room
Fitness room
Fully furnished
Gaming room
Garden
Housekeeping services
Indoor common areas
Kitchenette
Move-in coordination
Outdoor space
Private bathrooms
Restaurant-style dining
Small library
Telephone
Wellness center
Wi-Fi/high-speed internet available
Indianapolis International (14 miles away)
Community operated transportation
24-hour call system
Ambulatory care
Assistance with bathing
Assistance with dressing
Assistance with transfers
Diabetes diet
Diabetic care
Medication management
Special dietary restrictions
Concierge services
Planned day trips
When to Transition from Assisted Living to Memory Care: Key Indicators, Steps, and Finding the Right Community
Assisted Living and Memory Care: Understanding Their Core Differences
Beyond the Bingo Hall: 50+ Enriching Activities for Seniors in Assisted Living
