Fiddlesticks Country Club

Pros

• The courses are always in good condition.
• Fiddlesticks is beautifully landscaped and has two outstanding golf courses, many amenities, and an outstanding dining room.
• The cabana bar across the street is great for after golf.
• It's a tight-knit community where the members are great and all know each other.
• The staff are amazing - kind, helpful, attentive, and funny.
• The dining experiences are wonderful with top-notch staff.
• The golf courses are well maintained and challenging.
• The overall atmosphere is outstanding and the staff and members are extremely friendly.
• The property is beautiful and well kept.
• Pasta night is the best.

Cons

• The review describes Fiddlesticks as having a culture of profound racism and bigotry, which ruins it for the reviewer.
• It claims MLK Day and Juneteenth are the only federal holidays residents are not allowed to celebrate.
• On Juneteenth, the security head woke the reviewer and demanded they remove decorations, claiming authority to enter and remove them.
• The reviewer states, "If you like Jim Crow laws, you'll love Fiddlesticks," implying explicit racism.
• Staff interactions are described as rude, including the cleaning lady and a tennis shop attendant gossiping about members.
• The course is described as dry and in poor condition, leaving the reviewer disappointed.
• The property is criticized for being high-priced with questionable value.

Review

Fiddlesticks presents itself as a resort-like enclave, where lush grounds and meticulous upkeep set the stage for a life that's as much about social polish as it is about golf. The property features two notable courses - Long and Mean and Loch Ness - that residents and visitors alike describe as well-maintained and pleasantly challenging. The ambience is complemented by a cabana bar just across the street that becomes a natural magnet after a round, offering a relaxed backdrop for conversation, cold drinks, and friendly banter. Taken together, the setting feels cohesive: a well-kept, upscale neighborhood with a calling card that's as much about the outdoors and dining as it is about the golf.

The golfing experience is repeatedly highlighted as a core strength. Reviews talk about two outstanding courses - impeccably designed, with enough water and sand to demand smart shot selection, yet inviting enough that even casual players feel comfortable. Commenters emphasize the care that goes into maintenance, the thoughtful layout, and the role of skilled staff who support the rounds on both the golf course and the dining-and-beverage sides. Several reviewers reference the landscape as beautifully designed and maintained, with many pointing out that the courses live up to the hype through consistent upkeep and challenging play that still feels welcoming to a broad range of skill levels.

Beyond the greens, the social fabric at Fiddlesticks is a major draw. The community is described as tight-knit, with members who know one another and share a sense of belonging. The cabana bar across the street is a frequent post-round destination, a little haven for informal mingling and conversation. Reviewers repeatedly note the warmth of the staff and the welcoming atmosphere: "the staff though are AMAZING - so kind, helpful, attentive, and funny," one guest wrote after a baby shower, while others describe the overall environment as "laid back - amazing people - calm and inviting." The dining rooms earn praise as well, with people calling out top-tier service, delicious food, and a sense that the clubhouse is a staple of the community's daily life.

However, a long-time resident offers a starkly different perspective that underscores a darker thread running through the experience for some. After 25 years in the area, this reviewer describes Fiddlesticks as a place of extraordinary beauty and impeccable facilities, yet shadowed by a culture they label as profoundly racist and bigoted. They assert that MLK Day and Juneteenth are the only federal holidays residents are not allowed to celebrate, and recount a specific incident in which they were awakened by banging at their door on Juneteenth. They claim Head of Security Ryan Bell told them they had to remove holiday decorations, asserting that residents had no right to recognize the holiday and that the board gave "full authority" to enter premises and remove items. The account goes on to say that review of federal holidays with Ryan concluded the only other prohibited holiday was MLK Day, a claim the reviewer says was delivered in a rude and dismissive manner, even as the decorations were stacked neatly by the door.

That same narrative crescendos with a pointed indictment: "IF YOU LIKE JIM CROW LAWS, you'll LOVE Fiddlesticks!" It's a jarring counterpoint to the otherwise polished image of the club, a stark reminder that for some, the culture within the community undermines the otherwise enviable amenities. The reviewer's words carry a sense that the beauty and professionalism of the facilities are overshadowed by a troubling social climate, prompting a decision to move on despite the allure of the grounds and the courses.

Amid the divergent experiences, other voices emphasize the positive, day-to-day reality of life at Fiddlesticks. A variety of guests and members relay infectious enthusiasm about their visits: the environment can be elegant and welcoming, the service consistently strong, and the dining and event spaces capable of handling everything from baby showers to casual breakfasts and casual get-togethers. "Amazing staff," "great service," and "beautiful setting" recur in these testimonials, with comments about the golf staff, the course maintenance, and the general hospitality painting a picture of a community that functions smoothly for those who fit the circle. Many reviewers note the resort-like quality of the experience, from the breakfast service to the pool and other amenities.

Specific praise runs deep. Reviewers call out the two courses as top-tier, with many noting thoroughly kept greens and challenging layouts that nonetheless reward careful play. The dining rooms and bar areas are repeatedly described as outstanding, with guests highlighting friendly, attentive servers and bartenders - such as Anthony, who works at the bar and cabana - and a general sense that the staff genuinely enjoys what they do. Several comments celebrate the landscape, the architecture of the clubhouse, and the overall ambience as a wonderful setting to spend time with family and friends. Even the everyday interactions - friendly greetings, efficient service, and easy access to facilities - are cited as reasons the community feels like a "top-notch" experience.

In the end, Fiddlesticks emerges as a place of remarkable contrasts. On the one hand, it is described as a beautifully designed, meticulously maintained community with two outstanding golf courses, excellent dining, and a cohesive social life that makes living there feel almost like being on a permanent resort stay. On the other hand, there is a deeply felt critique about culture and inclusivity, with accounts that paint a picture of a climate that can feel exclusive or hostile to some residents. The dichotomy is hard to ignore: the grounds, the clubs, the dining, and the camaraderie draw people in and keep them coming back, while personal experiences of bias, real or alleged, cloud the overall sense of belonging for at least a portion of the community. For anyone considering a future at Fiddlesticks, the place promises a refined, active lifestyle - paired with a clear reminder that the social climate matters as much as the scenery and the service.

This section of Fort Myers, Florida, offers convenient access to various amenities and services that may be of interest to seniors. With multiple pharmacies within a few miles, transportation options for running errands or traveling are readily available. There are also cafes and restaurants nearby for dining out or grabbing a quick bite to eat. Places of worship are within reach for spiritual needs, while physicians and hospitals in the vicinity provide healthcare support. Additionally, parks and theaters offer opportunities for leisure activities in the area. Overall, this part of Fort Myers presents a well-rounded community with essential resources that could cater to the needs of seniors looking for a comfortable and convenient living environment.

Pharmacies

• CVS Pharmacy (2 miles)
• Walgreens (2.1 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (2.5 miles)
• Walgreens (2.6 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (2.8 miles)
• Lee Pharmacy - Gulf Coast Medical Center (2.8 miles)
• Gulf Coast Medical Pharmacy (2.8 miles)

Transportation

• Fox Rent A Car Fort Myers (2 miles)
• Hertz Rent A Car (3.5 miles)
• Concourse D (3.5 miles)
• American Airlines Ticket Counter RSW (3.6 miles)
• Delta Air Lines (3.6 miles)
• Avis Rent A Car (3.6 miles)
• Security Checkpoint (3.6 miles)

Cafes

• Starbucks (2.1 miles)
• Panera Bread (2.6 miles)
• Starbucks (5 miles)
• Panera Bread (5.7 miles)

Restaurants

• McDonald's (2.1 miles)
• Chick-Fil-A (2.3 miles)
• Cracker Barrel (2.3 miles)
• BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse (2.4 miles)
• Pei Wei Asian Kitchen (2.5 miles)
• Twin Peaks (2.5 miles)
• Connors Steak & Seafood (2.6 miles)

Places of Worship

• Unitarian Universalist Church of Fort Myers (2.1 miles)
• Blessed Pope John the XXIII Catholic Church (2.4 miles)

Physicians

• Headache & Pain Management (2.6 miles)
• Vascular & General Sur Spec-Fl - Brian D Kurland MD (2.6 miles)
• Nagesh B Ravipati (2.6 miles)
• Millennium Physician Group: Kim Schurman, MD (2.7 miles)
• Lee Health Neurodiagnostics - Plantation Rd (2.8 miles)
• Millennium Physician Group (2.9 miles)
• Florida Skin Center (3 miles)

Parks

• RSW Aircraft Observation Area (3 miles)

Theaters

• Regal Belltower (4 miles)

Hospitals

• Gulf Coast Hospital (4.6 miles)