Colonial Manor Nursing Home in Youngstown, OH

Pros

• Generations was described as absolutely amazing, with staff going above and beyond for a loved one and keeping the family informed.
• Generations’ staff are consistently friendly, helpful, and compassionate, providing strong support to patients and families.
• The medical and psychiatric teams at GBH are thorough and patient-centered, with treatment teams focused on improving patients’ mental health.
• The facility gave a patient his life back, with nurses and techs going above and beyond and doctors keeping patients and families informed.
• Families praised Generations for treating children kindly and for polite, attentive communication.
• The director of nursing was prompt to meet and provided the needed answers with care.
• Tiffany was highlighted as a great nurse who made the stay well worth it.

Cons

• The facility is described as abusive, belittling, and ridiculing patients.
• A friend was allegedly kidnapped for admission and held for eight days, with staff appearing uncaring.
• The majority of staff are said to act as if they have better things to do and fail to help patients.
• Medications are withheld or mismanaged, causing withdrawals and distress.
• The place is characterized as a dumping ground when beds are scarce, with patients treated poorly.
• The environment is traumatizing and dehumanizing, with staff yelling and patients left without basic needs.
• Privacy and patient rights are alleged to be violated, including unconsented intern visits and improper sharing of information.
• Food and basic nourishment are reportedly poor and insufficient, with meals cold and lacking vegetables.
• The facility is described as severely understaffed and underfunded, leading to unsafe, neglectful care.

Review

Colonial Manor Nursing Home in Youngstown is not a fit-for-most families. If the choice must be made, this community is best avoided for anyone needing reliable psychiatric care, consistent medication management, or a respectful, transparent care environment. Only in a true bed-crisis situation, where no other options exist and a family can maintain relentless, hands-on oversight, would it be reasonable to consider placement here as a short-term, highly monitored stopgap. In other words, this is a facility to be pursued only as a last resort, with explicit plans for rapid transfer to a higher-quality setting as soon as possible.

Anyone seeking a standard of safety, dignity, and patient advocacy should look elsewhere. The reviews repeatedly describe abuse, neglect, and a disturbing pattern of mismanagement that jeopardizes basic wellbeing. Families should consider alternatives if a loved one requires attentive crisis stabilization, consistent access to prescribed medications, or compassionate staff who consistently respond to needs. Those with a strong advocacy network, family members who can monitor care, document incidents, and push for timely physician involvement, may find some temporary safeguards, but even with vigilance, the risk of harmful experiences remains unacceptably high.

The limited positives in the feedback do not outweigh the overwhelming drawbacks. Several accounts acknowledge that some staff members are courteous or that certain nurses or physicians respond with care in isolated moments. Yet these rare good interactions are dwarfed by accounts of medication delays or omissions, staff who appear disengaged, and environments that foster fear rather than recovery. The prevailing impression is a facility where staffing shortages, inconsistent supervision, and a culture that minimizes patient concerns undermine any potential therapeutic benefit. In short, favorable anecdotes do not translate into reliable, day-to-day quality of care.

Safety and rights concerns emerge as a consistent throughline. Reports describe coercive practices, alleged coercion into stays, and episodes that raise serious questions about informed consent and patient autonomy. Allegations include seclusion in bare, cement rooms, improper handling of seizures or other medical events, and disputes over who can access a patient’s information or even a patient’s own belongings. Several reviews claim the facility mishandles medical records and fails to provide timely physician oversight, with accusations that administrative staff and on-site caregivers do not follow basic legal and ethical standards. Such themes point to systemic risk rather than isolated incidents.

For families actively evaluating options, concrete steps matter most. Begin with a candid tour focused on staffing levels, daily routines, and how quickly concerns reach supervisors or physicians. Request the current administrator or director of nursing to review patient-care plans and medication administration records, and demand clear channels for family communication. Check state and local inspections, complaint histories, and third-party reviews to triangulate risk, then prepare a concrete transition plan that prioritizes a move to a facility with proven safety records and transparent family engagement. If choosing Colonial Manor becomes unavoidable, insist on a structured oversight plan, frequent family updates, and a defined timeframe for discharge or transfer.

The bottom line is decisive: Colonial Manor presents substantial, well-documented risks that outweigh any nominal benefits. This is a facility to be considered only in the most constrained circumstances and under relentless, proactive oversight. Families should actively compare alternatives with stronger safety profiles, better medication management, and more consistent, compassionate staffing. When in doubt, pursue options that prioritize patient dignity, rights, and proven outcomes, and reserve Colonial Manor for urgent bed needs with an explicit plan to transition to a higher-quality setting as soon as possible.

This part of Youngstown, Ohio offers a convenient location with a variety of amenities within close proximity. There are several physicians, pharmacies, and hospitals nearby, providing easy access to medical care. The area also features a range of dining options including Italian specialties at Jimmy's and traditional American fare at Bob Evans and Wendy's. For recreation, residents can enjoy the beautiful Fellows Riverside Gardens or explore Tod Park and Wick Recreation Area. Overall, this neighborhood offers a mix of healthcare services, dining options, and outdoor spaces that cater to the needs and interests of seniors looking for a comfortable and convenient place to live.

Physicians

• Chi Sown Ko (0.2 miles)
• Mid American Court Services (0.3 miles)
• Uday K Dasika MD (0.4 miles)
• Michael Sekman (1.1 miles)
• The Kidney Group (1.4 miles)
• Associates In Women's (1.5 miles)
• Dr Iskander (1.5 miles)

Restaurants

• Jimmy's Italian Food Specialties (0.3 miles)
• Bob Evans (1 miles)
• Wendy's (1.1 miles)
• The Landmark Restaurant (2.2 miles)
• Noble Creature Cask House (2.7 miles)
• Margherita's Grille (2.7 miles)
• Avalon Downtown Pizzeria (2.7 miles)

Pharmacies

• Allen's Pharmaserv (0.3 miles)
• Qol Meds (2.3 miles)
• Rite Aid (2.6 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (3.1 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (4.2 miles)
• Berry's Pharmacy (4.4 miles)
• Marc's Stores (4.9 miles)

Hospitals

• Valley Care Health System-Ohio (0.4 miles)
• Tod Childrens Hospital Forum Health (0.4 miles)
• Belmont Pines Hospital (1.6 miles)
• St Elizabeth Health Center (1.7 miles)
• St Elizabeth Health Center - Pre Op (1.7 miles)
• Akron Children's Hospital NEO (1.7 miles)
• American Renal Associates (1.7 miles)

Cafes

• Saint E's Cafe (1.7 miles)
• Starbucks (5.6 miles)
• Panera Bread (6 miles)

Parks

• Fellows Riverside Gardens (2.8 miles)
• Tod Park (2.8 miles)
• Wick Recreation Area (3.9 miles)
• Harding Park (4.9 miles)