Edinlake Apartments

Pros

• The reviewer finds the apartment complex nice and feels safe living there.
• The location is highly valued by residents.
• Common areas seem clean and provide a decent place for residents to gather and mingle.
• Residents are friendly and greet the reviewer when they see them.
• The facility's locked entry points provide security.
• Karaoke on Tuesdays and Fridays, plus activities like video game day and bowling, contribute to a friendly community.
• The people there are good and very nice, and the reviewer would recommend the place to others.
• The place is great for anyone with disabilities, and the management is very good.

Cons

• They describe the facility as disgusting and the management as the worst they've ever seen or heard of.
• They claim the management lacks common sense and competence.
• They report miscommunication around move-in, with delays and the family taking time off work.
• They state the office did not return calls for over a week, leaving them without information.
• They recount a dangerous situation where an elderly relative tripped and fell due to delays and clutter in the apartment.
• They accuse the staff of lying and dereliction of duty.

Review

The collection of notes about this housing complex reveals a place that can feel like a safe, welcoming home to some, while to others it comes with real frustrations and alarming miscommunications. Several reviewers start from a positive baseline: they describe a nice apartment complex in a good location where they feel safe. One person specifically says they love the space, feel secure, and appreciate the location. Another mentions an overall sense of safety with features like locked entry points, and notes that a relative who lives there is part of a community where neighbors know one another and greet each other in passing.

Beyond safety and location, the atmosphere at the property seems to hinge on a robust sense of community. Common areas are described as clean and usable for residents to gather and mingle, which helps residents build familiarity with one another. The social fabric is reinforced by a responsive, friendly resident body - people acknowledge each other when they see one another, and the environment feels welcoming to newcomers and visitors alike. This tone is reinforced by specific routines and programs that give residents regular opportunities to connect, such as social events and organized activities.

A standout positive thread is the reported accessibility and support for people with disabilities. One reviewer explicitly says the place is "great for anyone with disabilities," and they also praise the management as being "very good." This suggests that, for at least some residents, the property offers the necessary accommodations and a management approach that is responsive and supportive. In addition, a long-standing resident notes four years of residence and points to ongoing activities that help build a sense of community: karaoke sessions on multiple days and what appears to be a scheduled mix of entertainment and recreation, including video game day and bowling on Saturdays. The consistency of these events and the described friendliness of other residents contribute to the impression of a stable, resident-focused living environment.

However, there is a starkly contrasting perspective that highlights serious problems with management and logistics. One detailed review is emotionally charged and scathing, painting a picture of gross mismanagement and neglect. The reviewer describes a nightmare scenario: a family member who had been on a waiting list for well over a year was told to move in within two weeks, with the plan to sign papers and collect a key. The family even took time off work to help, only to be informed last minute that the move-in would be postponed because the apartment supposedly needed repairs. What followed was an extended period of unreturned calls and lack of clear communication, leading to mounting anxiety for an elderly relative who would be moving into the unit.

The sequence of events in this account is particularly troubling. The grandmother's move-in was delayed repeatedly, the family spent days waiting for confirmation, and the apartment became a hazard due to boxes and clutter. The reviewer emphasizes that the grandmother, who is 82, ended up tripping and requiring hospital attention - an outcome that could have been avoided with better planning and communication. The narrative accuses the on-site staff of being unavailable or inattentive for an entire week, and it highlights an interaction at an office in Erie where the staff member allegedly claimed to be on vacation, which the reviewer argues is unacceptable and unprofessional. The insult-laden charge - "LIES LIES LIES" - and the claim that a staff member should have fulfilled their duties are part of the raw, emotionally charged lament.

In a further twist to the same story, the reviewer recounts being told that their relative would qualify to move in, only to be told hours later that the person no longer qualified because they supposedly receive too much money each month. The abrupt reversal, followed by the relative's distress and uncertainty about securing housing, is presented as the peak expression of frustration and disappointment with management. The reviewer's anger is palpable, arguing that the staff should have done their job properly and not misled the family, especially given the vulnerable position of an elderly resident facing housing instability.

Taken together, these reviews present a nuanced portrait of the complex. On one hand, you have a place that many residents find safe, clean, and socially vibrant, with a strong sense of community and practical supports for people with disabilities. On the other hand, you have a compelling argument that management practices and communication can be severely lacking - leading to dangerous, avoidable consequences for residents and their families. The higher-trust, community-oriented experiences contrast sharply with the negative account of mismanagement, delays, miscommunications, and alleged dishonesty.

If you're considering moving here, these perspectives suggest you should weigh the positives - safe surroundings, a welcoming community, accessible design, and organized activities - with the caveats raised by the negative review. It appears that the facility can be a homey, supportive place for many, but significant improvements in administrative efficiency, transparency, and accountability are necessary to prevent the kind of distress described by the disgruntled family. The overall takeaway is that this property has real potential, but it also requires substantial attention to management practices to ensure that every resident, especially the more vulnerable ones, can count on timely information, reliable processes, and safe, dignified access to housing.

Restaurants

• Edinboro Lake Resort (0.3 miles)
• Sunset Grill (0.3 miles)
• Lakeside Beach Bar (0.9 miles)
• Dairy Supreme (0.9 miles)
• Edinboro Hotel (1.1 miles)
• Riverside Brewing Company (6.8 miles)
• IHOP (11.2 miles)

Pharmacies

• Lakeside Health Mart Pharmacy (1 miles)
• Health Mart Pharmacy (6.9 miles)
• Waterford Pharmacy (8.1 miles)
• Sam's RX (11.3 miles)
• Walmart Pharmacy (11.5 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (11.6 miles)
• Wegmans (12 miles)

Physicians

• Central Erie Co Paramedics Associations (1.1 miles)
• Heritage Primary Care (8.1 miles)
• Dr kohut and bodoskys office (12 miles)
• Primary Care Partners (12 miles)
• Boscov's Optical (12.4 miles)
• Westminster Family Practice (12.5 miles)
• Forest Hills Family Practice (12.7 miles)

Parks

• Wainer Park (1.9 miles)
• Grotto Park (10.3 miles)

Places of Worship

• Grace Notes International (11.3 miles)
• Wesleyan Church-The Nazarene (11.7 miles)
• Holy Trinity Lutheran Church (11.9 miles)
• First Presbyterian Church of Girard (12.5 miles)
• Littles Corners United Methodist Church (12.8 miles)
• Berean Baptist Church (14 miles)

Hospitals

• Millcreek Hospital (11.4 miles)
• Millcreek Community Hospital (12.9 miles)
• Upmc Hamot (13.7 miles)

Cafes

• Starbucks (11.6 miles)
• Tim Hortons (11.6 miles)
• Panera Bread (11.7 miles)
• Market Café (12 miles)
• Traveler’s Cafe (12.2 miles)
• Starbucks (12.2 miles)
• Big Irene's Little Diner (12.3 miles)

Theaters

• Tinseltown USA (11.9 miles)

Transportation

• Erie International Airport (ERI) (13.7 miles)
• Budget Rent A Car (14 miles)