1009 Nicholson Avenue, South Milwaukee, WI 53172
For more information about senior living options: (866) 208-4318
Overall Review of Rem Wisconsin II Nicholson
Pros
It was an amazing one-bedroom apartment.- Wright Weber worked with tenants.
- The company is fully trustworthy.
- It is a great place to live and rent from.
- It offers 1- and 2-bedroom homes, some with fireplaces, and balconies or patios for flowers.
- It is very nice and clean.
- It seemed very peaceful with a friendly management team.
- It is a great place to live with quick maintenance, professional management, and a quiet trail nearby.
Cons
The leasing office is unresponsive and never answers the phone for days.- Communication is poor, with no one talking to anyone and a loud neighbor disrupting the building.
- Wright Weber Corp is dishonest, does not return calls, and bullies tenants.
- The company is deceitful and tries to take advantage of renters.
- The property trespasses into residents' property when they are not home.
- Faucets leak constantly and walls are paper-thin, leading to noise and water issues.
- Rent has increased as many as three times in one year.
- Car break-ins occur yearly, and safety concerns are raised.
- Tenants are belittled and talked down to by management.
Review
Rem Wisconsin II Nicholson in South Milwaukee is best suited for budget-minded adults who want straightforward, low-frills rental living with quiet grounds and convenient access to outdoor space. The community offers one- and two-bedroom layouts, with some units featuring fireplaces and balconies where residents can plant flowers or enjoy fresh air on a private perch. Several residents praise the character of the apartments themselves and note that, when quiet, the grounds and location can be a solid match for someone who values steadiness over flash. For seniors or independent adults who can manage their own maintenance needs and don’t require on-site care, this property can be a practical, affordable choice that delivers simple comfort without the frills.
Those who should consider alternatives are individuals who prioritize consistently reliable management, prompt repairs, and strong resident protections. A frequent thread in the feedback is uneven leasing and maintenance communication, with reports of unanswered calls and slow or inconsistent responses. Safety and privacy concerns appear in some accounts, including complaints about break-ins and intrusive management practices. Rent- and policy-related fluctuations, such as multiple increases cited by some tenants, also stand out as a signal that predictability may be limited. In short, if dependable, transparent operation and proactive service are nonnegotiable, this is a property where closer scrutiny or a different option may be warranted.
The main pros here, affordability, a peaceful setting, and a sensible physical footprint, do offer meaningful offset for certain renters, but only under specific conditions. When management is responsive, problems get addressed quickly, and tenants can enjoy a quiet, well-kept environment that feels safe and neighborly. The proximity to a trail and the ability to tailor outdoor space (balconies or patios with planters) enhance daily living without adding cost. Several tenants have described quick repairs and cordial, professional interactions when issues were handled promptly, which reinforces the value angle: you get a lot of space and a decent apartment for the price if communication is solid and issues stay manageable.
However, the guarded bottom line remains: the inconsistencies in communication and service can erode the value proposition quickly. Frequent complaints about unanswered calls, difficulty scheduling tours, and perceived unprofessionalism from staff members highlight a fragility in the operating system that can leave residents frustrated. Privacy concerns, noise from nearby units, and occasional security worries compound the risk, especially for seniors who may be more vulnerable to disruptive behavior or slow responses. When these gaps appear after move-in, they can tilt the balance away from affordability toward ongoing negotiation with the property team.
Prospective renters should approach a visit with a clear set of expectations and a plan to verify the pattern of service. It is worth requesting a tour time that aligns with staff availability, asking for current resident contact to gauge consistency in responses, and inquiring about typical maintenance turnaround times and after-hours coverage. Prospective tenants should also inspect soundproofing between units, verify the condition of faucets and fixtures, and confirm the building’s safety measures and entry notification practices. A written, signed communication protocol and a defined escalation path for urgent repairs can help anchor satisfaction if moving forward.
In the end, Rem Wisconsin II Nicholson delivers a combination of value and livability that can suit a specific buyer: someone who wants affordable, uncomplicated apartment living in a quiet, convenient corner of South Milwaukee and is prepared to tolerate imperfect management at times. It is a practical option for independent adults who can self-manage minor issues and do not require frequent, proactive intervention from the staff. For families, seniors needing reliable on-site assistance, or anyone who prizes consistent communication and a consistently protected resident experience, it is wise to explore alternatives that promise steadier service and stronger accountability.
6 resident community capacity
Assisted Living
Cable or satellite TV
Dining room
Fully furnished
Garden
Housekeeping services
Move-in coordination
Outdoor space
Telephone
Wi-Fi/high-speed internet available
General Mitchell International (2 miles away)
24-hour supervision
Activities of daily living assistance
Assistance with bathing
Assistance with dressing
Assistance with transfers
Diabetes diet
Meal preparation and service
Medication management
Special dietary restrictions
Transportation arrangement (medical)
Transportation to doctors appointments
8 Key Indicators That Suggest It May Be Time to Transition from Assisted Living to Skilled Nursing Care
Vibrant Senior Living: A Comprehensive Guide for Active Older Adults
When to Transition from Assisted Living to Memory Care: Key Indicators, Steps, and Finding the Right Community