Sherman House in Findlay, OH

Pros

• The landlords are quick to respond to tenants' needs and questions.
• The apartment complex is clean, well kept, and secure, and residents feel safe living there.
• Management is friendly, accommodating, and professional.
• The owners are incredibly kind and attentive to their tenants.
• The location downtown Findlay is excellent, convenient, and affordable for the area.
• Rent is reasonable and offers good value for the amenities and location.
• Maintenance and repairs are performed quickly and with care.
• The deposit is returned promptly and in full when the unit is left in good condition.
• The overall rental experience is stress-free with strong communication.

Cons

• Rent costs are too high for what is offered; other landlords are cheaper.
• Jill is very rude and unprofessional.
• Jill is arrogant and allegedly refused a rental to a 69-year-old veteran, suggesting possible discrimination.
• The reviewer alleges discriminatory treatment by Jill and calls for an investigation.
• The owner is rude and appears to use bots to post fake reviews.
• The landlord is described as a "slumlord" who invades tenants' privacy by creeping around and staring through windows.
• The reviewer warns others not to stay there, describing the experience as a nightmare.
• The management never returns calls and seems uninterested in gaining tenants.
• The reviewer would not recommend Sherman House.

Review

Sherman House is best suited for budget-conscious renters who want a downtown Findlay address, solid basic amenities, and responsive upkeep without paying premium loft prices. The community often reads as practical, straightforward housing for individuals who value location - within easy reach of restaurants, shops, and university-related activity - plus a secure, quiet environment. Tenants commonly highlight clean, well-kept buildings, reliable maintenance, and a management team that communicates and acts quickly on repairs. For those who want a simple, no-fruss lease with predictable costs and the freedom to stay month-to-month if plans shift, Sherman House fits the bill with notable consistency.

Those weighing alternatives should note that not every tenant experiences the same level of service. A subset of reviews flag concerns about management style, with specific comments about rude interactions and perceptions of unfair treatment by at least one staff member. A few accounts even raise questions about discrimination, though other residents report nothing but courtesy and competence. Prospective renters who demand uniformly polished customer service, highly personalized attention, or a hands-off experience from the landlord may want to compare other downtown options with larger management teams and more standardized processes. It's also wise to verify pet and specific policy details, as those topics don't appear consistently across all comments.

The strongest positives - affordable rent for a downtown location, quick maintenance, and strong security - tend to offset many drawbacks. Several tenants emphasize that rents are very reasonable for the heart of Findlay, with the added value of close proximity to UF and local amenities. Noteworthy is the consistency of upkeep: apartments and common areas are described as clean and well maintained, with contractors addressing issues promptly rather than delivering band-aid fixes. The building's security and quiet environment are repeatedly praised, along with dependable communication from the management team, which helps residents feel settled and respected. For many, these durable advantages make Sherman House a rational choice in a market where price and location drive the decision.

Where the narrative splits is in the day-to-day experience with the landlord team. Some reviewers laud Jill and Brad for their accessibility, proactive problem-solving, and transparent handling of deposits, while others recount frustration over missed calls, curt responses, or a tone that feels overbearing. There are also a few outlier stories about lease enforcement and conduct that can feel punitive, which can erode trust for prospective renters who want a consistently constructive landlord-tenant relationship. The tension between highly positive long-term experiences and negative isolated interactions means that a potential resident should calibrate personal tolerance for variance in service quality when evaluating Sherman House.

From a practical standpoint, the property remains competitive on value, and the downtown footprint combines with features such as an on-site laundry room, elevators, secure entry, and well-kept common areas to deliver a low-stress living experience. The month-to-month flexibility, straightforward leasing, and demonstrated willingness to repair or replace dated components quickly are meaningful benefits for renters juggling co-ops, internships, or job transitions in Findlay. Residents repeatedly note fast responses to maintenance requests and a level of care that signals genuine pride in the property. All told, these operational strengths largely compensate for the more subjective concerns about interpersonal style, provided risk tolerance is moderate and expectations are aligned with a practical, value-driven rental.

In the final assessment, Sherman House serves as a prudent choice for cost-conscious tenants who prize location, security, and dependable upkeep, and who are comfortable navigating occasional managerial friction. Those who insist on consistently flawless customer service, a uniformly neutral tone in all interactions, or a completely pet-friendly, luxury-grade experience should look elsewhere. Prospective residents should test the waters with a short-term arrangement, request current references from current tenants, and confirm policy details before committing. In a market where downtown Findlay rents vary, Sherman House remains a pointedly sensible option for those who value practicality, transparency, and a strong baseline of maintenance and safety.

This area of Findlay, Ohio offers a convenient and diverse range of amenities for seniors looking to settle down. With multiple physicians, pharmacies, and hospitals in close proximity, residents can easily access healthcare services. There are also various dining options such as Alexandria's and Logan's Irish Pub, providing opportunities for socializing and enjoying meals out. For relaxation and recreation, parks like Emory Adams Park and Mound Park offer green spaces for outdoor activities. Additionally, places of worship like Saint Michael the Archangel and Howard United Methodist Church cater to spiritual needs. Overall, this part of Findlay provides a well-rounded community with essential services within easy reach.

Physicians

• Eyes on Main - Findlay (0.2 miles)
• John D. Seng O.D. (0.7 miles)
• ENT & Allergy Specialists of Northwest Ohio (0.9 miles)
• Plastic Surgery & Aesthetics of Northwest Ohio (0.9 miles)
• Shawnee Optical Of Fin (1 miles)
• Findlay Laser & Vein Center (1.1 miles)
• Cascades Women's Health (1.4 miles)

Restaurants

• Alexandria's (0.2 miles)
• Japan West (0.2 miles)
• Logan's Irish Pub (0.2 miles)
• Circle of Friends Resturant (0.2 miles)
• Main Street Deli (0.3 miles)
• Dietsch Brothers (0.3 miles)
• Archies Drive-In (0.4 miles)

Cafes

• We Serve. Coffee (0.2 miles)
• Fern Cafe (0.5 miles)
• Fort Findlay Coffee & Doughnut Shoppe (1.1 miles)
• Panera Bread (2.3 miles)

Pharmacies

• Rite Aid (0.3 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (0.5 miles)
• Kroger Pharmacy (1.3 miles)
• Rite Aid (1.3 miles)
• Scarbrough Pharmacy (1.5 miles)
• Walmart Pharmacy (1.6 miles)
• Kroger Pharmacy (2.5 miles)

Transportation

• U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer (0.4 miles)

Places of Worship

• Saint Michael the Archangel (0.5 miles)
• College First Church of God, Winebrenner Service (0.8 miles)
• Howard United Methodist Church (1.4 miles)
• Connections Church (1.6 miles)
• St John's Evangelical Luth Church ELCA (1.9 miles)
• Tabernacle Church of Christ (2 miles)
• CedarCreek Church (2.1 miles)

Parks

• Emory Adams Park (0.6 miles)
• Mound Park (0.6 miles)
• Swale Park (0.7 miles)
• Riverside Park (1 miles)
• Firestine Park (1.3 miles)

Hospitals

• Blanchard Valley Hospital (0.6 miles)
• Tele-Care (1.7 miles)

Theaters

• AMC CLASSIC Findlay 12 (1.9 miles)