391 Clark Dr, Circleville, OH 43113
To contact a resident: (740) 474-6036
For more information about senior living options: (866) 208-4318
Overall Review of Pickaway Manor Rehabilitation Center Skilled Nursing and Assisted Living
Pros
The community is described as impressive and homey.- Megan Webb is noted as very helpful.
- The facility avoids a hospital-room feel.
- Residents are paired by interests to prevent conflicts, showing thoughtful planning.
Cons
The phone does not get answered.- They have to physically drive over to speak with anyone.
- The reviewer is not happy.
- The dinner served to the reviewer’s papaw consisted of a half-cup of carrot soup and only one slice of lunch meat on bread.
- The meal was described as absolutely disgusting.
Review
Pickaway Manor Rehabilitation Center Skilled Nursing and Assisted Living in Circleville is best suited for families seeking a compact, homey atmosphere where social harmony and a non-clinical feel take priority over institutional polish. The community seems to shine for residents who prefer semi-private living, personalized roommate matching based on interests, and a setting that feels more like a lived-in home than a hospital ward. In short, this is the option to consider when a warm, intimate environment and deliberate social pairing are the central criteria for choosing care.
Those who may want to consider alternatives are families for whom reliable administrative responsiveness and consistently high dining standards are non-negotiable. The most reliable caution from current observations is that phone communication can be difficult, with instances of being unable to reach staff by phone and a need to visit in person for basic inquiries. For families who require prompt answers, streamlined intake, or a dining program that consistently delivers, other communities with stronger front-desk and administrative systems may be a better fit.
The strongest positives here are the home-like vibe, the effort to avoid a hospital feel, and the emphasis on resident compatibility. The semi-private rooms align with many retirees’ expectations for a comfortable, less clinical setting, and the practice of pairing residents by shared interests reduces friction and supports social engagement. Additionally, at least one staff member, Megan Webb, receives direct praise for helpfulness, suggesting that attentive, person-centered staff can be found within the community and can make a meaningful difference in daily life.
Conversely, the main drawbacks are tangible and not easy to overlook. The occasional difficulty in reaching administrative staff by phone points to potential gaps in communication and responsiveness, which can be stressful when questions arise or urgent needs occur. Dining quality is highlighted in one review with strong negative language, meals described as “absolutely disgusting” with insufficient portions, indicating that nutrition and satisfaction may vary and require proactive oversight by families or residents. The limited number of reviews also means the full scope of daily care and consistency is hard to gauge from outside.
Still, the favorable elements can somewhat offset the drawbacks for residents who prize comfort, social compatibility, and a homey daily rhythm. For families prioritizing a stress-free, non-hospital environment, the ability to pair residents thoughtfully and to foster meaningful small-community interactions can yield a higher quality of life than a more clinical setting. The apparent presence of responsive individuals within the team, like Megan Webb, suggests that when staff engage, they can deliver notable warmth and practical help, which is a meaningful offset to the administrative friction described by others.
In deciding, the key question is what matters most: a true home-like feel with social matching, or consistently responsive administration and dependable dining quality. If the answer leans toward atmosphere, individualized attention, and a pace that feels less institutional, Pickaway Manor warrants careful consideration. If dependable communication, steady meals, and a uniformly polished operation are paramount, it is prudent to explore other options first, while keeping this community on the radar for a visit to observe how staff interact with residents and how meals are served on a typical day.
Assisted Living
Skilled Nursing Facility
Activities on-site
Devotional services off-site
Indoor common areas
Ambulatory care
Diabetic care
High acuity care
Meals provided
Comprehensive Residential Support and Assisted Living Solutions for Individuals with Disabilities
Comprehensive Supportive Living Arrangements for Adults with Disabilities
Funding and Affording Assisted Living: A Thorough Overview