The Caregiver's Choice in Amherst, NY

Pros

• The service connected the family with a knowledgeable staff member who listened to their concerns and needs.
• The caregiver team understood what was wanted for the grandmother and provided the home care they hoped for.
• They have two wonderful caregivers who rotate 4-5 days a week, and the family couldn't be happier.
• The grandmother says these caregivers feel like old friends.
• The person in charge is excellent, personally involved, and consistently communicates, which instills confidence.
• They accommodate having only two caregivers for a 10-hour span, ensuring consistency with fewer different faces.
• They have earned the trust and respect of the person they are caring for.
• The mom appears to like her caregiver.
• The service would be used again in the future if needed.

Cons

• They wish they had heard feedback from the director after the meeting with their mom, but they haven't heard a word from her.
• They are disappointed that there has been no feedback or update from the director regarding the meeting with their mom.

Review

The Caregiver's Choice in Amherst, NY is best suited for families seeking non-medical, in-home support for an aging loved one who thrives on stable, person-centered companionship and practical daily help. The model that emerges from the reviews centers on small, tightly managed caregiving teams, not a hospital-like facility, with a hands-on supervisor who coordinates care and maintains consistent caregiver assignments. This is a clear fit for seniors who want warmth, continuity, and a home-like experience rather than a move into a larger community. When a relative's needs are largely around daily routines, transportation, and social engagement - rather than complex medical procedures - this agency appears well aligned with those expectations.

However, for families whose loved one requires heavier medical oversight, 24/7 monitoring, or rapid escalation of care, alternatives may be worth evaluating. The emphasis on two caregivers for long shifts is a strength for stability but also signals limited coverage windows. Prospective clients should confirm whether this arrangement can scale to evolving needs, including overnight hours or weekend gaps. Also, those who expect highly proactive, frequent leadership feedback after care planning meetings should watch for gaps; at least one reviewer noted a lack of post-meeting communication, a potential friction point for families seeking continuous assurance.

Key strengths revolve around responsiveness, continuity, and relational trust. Intake and placement tend to be quick and well-tailored, with staff listening closely to what matters for the client and family. The appointed supervisor is described as personally involved, communicating regularly by email and phone, and taking responsibility for caregiver performance. The agency can cover roughly 10 hours daily with just two caregivers, reducing turnover and fostering familiarity for the client. That consistency translates into caregivers who feel like old friends to the person receiving care, a dynamic families value highly in home settings.

Notable caveats surface in the softer edges of operation. One reviewer flagged a lack of timely feedback from the director after a meeting with the client, suggesting that proactive updates could be stronger. The tight caregiver roster, though a stability asset, also means scheduling rigidity and potential exposure if someone is unavailable. With a modest six-review sample and a single 3-star note, it helps to approach expectations with a plan for ongoing communication and to confirm capacity for evolving needs before committing.

Overall, the positives largely offset these concerns. The personal leadership touch ensures issues get attention without delays, and caregiver continuity reduces confusion and anxiety for families. The ability to deliver steady coverage with just two caregivers fosters trust, reduces the churn many seniors experience, and supports a dignified daily routine. The high rating across most reviews signals consistent satisfaction among families who value warmth, reliability, and practical help. In short, the model works best when stability and personable care are the top criteria, and the agency delivers on that promise with verifiable results in the Amherst area.

Decision-ready guidance: The Caregiver's Choice is a strong fit for Amherst families prioritizing home-based companionship, routine support, and a trusted, personally managed care team. Prospective clients should confirm their anticipated schedule, whether extended coverage may be needed later, and the degree of caregiver continuity they require. For those who need heavier medical oversight, overnight care, or more expansive supervision, alternatives should be explored to avoid gaps. When ready, engage with leadership early - set expectations for communication cadence, care planning feedback, and a clear escalation path - and rely on the demonstrated caregiver relationships and manager-driven quality control as a rational basis for choosing this option.

This part of Amherst, New York offers a variety of amenities and services that cater to individuals in their golden years. With multiple restaurants such as Carrabba's Italian Grill and Elmo's, as well as cafes like Starbucks and Panera Bread nearby, you can enjoy delicious meals without having to travel far. In terms of healthcare, there are reputable physicians at Amherst Medical Associates and Dent Neurologic Institute within close proximity. Additionally, pharmacies like Top's Pharmacy and Rite Aid are conveniently located for your medication needs. For leisure and relaxation, there are parks like Ellicott Creek Park and Glen Park nearby where you can enjoy outdoor activities. Overall, this neighborhood provides a comfortable and convenient environment for seniors looking to settle down in Amherst.

Restaurants

• Carrabba's Italian Grill (0.2 miles)
• IHOP (0.6 miles)
• McDonald's (1.3 miles)
• Elmo's (2.4 miles)
• Dandelions Restaurant (2.6 miles)
• My Tomato Pie (2.7 miles)
• Siena Restaurant (2.8 miles)

Physicians

• Amherst Medical Associates (0.3 miles)
• Dr. Mark Rodman (0.4 miles)
• Gastroenterology Associates (1.4 miles)
• Northtowns Cardiology (1.6 miles)
• Dent Neurologic Institute (1.8 miles)
• Excelsior Orthopaedics (1.9 miles)
• Suburban Psychiatric Associates (2 miles)

Cafes

• Starbucks (0.4 miles)
• Panera Bread (0.5 miles)
• Tim Hortons (1.1 miles)
• Tim Hortons (1.2 miles)
• Starbucks (1.3 miles)
• Tim Hortons (2.2 miles)
• Wegmans Food Markets (2.9 miles)

Pharmacies

• Tops Pharmacy (0.5 miles)
• Top's Markets (0.5 miles)
• Wegmans (0.7 miles)
• Walmart Pharmacy (1.1 miles)
• Rite Aid (1.3 miles)
• Rite Aid (1.4 miles)
• Walgreens (1.5 miles)

Theaters

• AMC Maple Ridge 8 (0.5 miles)

Places of Worship

• Newman Center at UB (1.4 miles)
• The Chapel (4.7 miles)

Parks

• Ellicott Creek Park (1.8 miles)
• North Tonawanda Gateway Park (3.7 miles)
• South Long Park (4 miles)
• Glen Park (4.1 miles)
• Island Park (4.2 miles)

Hospitals

• Degraff Memorial Hospital (3.2 miles)
• Millard Fillmore Suburban NICU (4.1 miles)
• Millard Fillmore Suburban Hospital (4.1 miles)
• Erie County Medical Center (5.2 miles)