Sojourner Cottage in Lodge, MT

Pros

• Red Lodge Rentals is awesome and goes above and beyond to help guests.
• Laura and Heather are amazing and saints for their help and responsiveness.
• Laura at Red Lodge Rentals is an angel to guests in need.
• The properties are spacious, well-stocked, and comfortable with thoughtful touches.
• The home and staff provide excellent, attentive service from reservation to stay.
• Red Lodge Rentals delivers exquisite care to both homes and guests, with attention to detail second to none.
• Guests would highly recommend Red Lodge Rentals and would rent from them again.
• The homes are large, modern, and feel like home, often with features like hot tubs.
• The owners and employees are attentive, kind, and professional.
• Journey KOA and Red Lodge Rentals properties offer beautiful, clean sites with friendly, helpful staff.

Cons

• They were extremely disappointed with Laura's customer service.
• They paid a thousand dollars per night, yet the lawn had not been mowed.
• Laura kept giving excuses for why no one could mow the lawn.
• They would have mowed it themselves if a mower had been provided.
• Laura ruined their grandparents' 50th anniversary weekend by telling some family members they couldn't come.
• She claimed the rules prohibited their family gathering, even though it wasn't a party, and threatened involving the city.
• The staff allegedly tried to force customers to wear masks at the register, which was criticized.

Review

Sojourner Cottage in Lodge, MT is best suited for multi-family groups or sizeable gatherings that want a home-away-from-home base with real room to spread out. It clicks for families or friends who value a full kitchen, multiple sleeping areas, and common living spaces where people can linger, cook together, and share downtime without stepping into a hotel corridor. The layout and amenities are clearly designed for groups, not individuals or couples seeking boutique, hotel-like consistency. Those who thrive on flexible, self-directed stays will find it a strong match. In short, this property earns its stripes when a family-friendly, budget-conscious, group-oriented setup is the main goal.

Those who may want to consider alternatives are guests who require flawless, high-touch service and fully predictable communication. The reviews show that responsiveness and policy enforcement can be inconsistent, with anecdotes of miscommunications and uneven guest experiences. For travelers who prize a dedicated on-site manager, rapid issue resolution, or highly regimented rules explained clearly in advance, this property may feel unreliable at times. If the plan hinges on a seamless, concierge-level experience, it’s prudent to explore other options with stronger, more consistent management and clearer resident points of contact.

The strongest positives here center on space, practicality, and the ability to host groups comfortably. The homes described in this peer set tend to be well-stocked, with kitchens ready for family meals, ample sleeping arrangements, and social areas that support gathering after days of activity. A hot tub and a sense of “home,” rather than a sterile hotel feeling, frequently appear in favorable notes. When hosts are responsive and accommodating, guests repeatedly express appreciation for the care shown and the ease of check-in. For groups intent on a relaxed, self-directed stay, these practical strengths can outweigh more fragile aspects of service.

Conversely, the main drawbacks rest on uneven customer service and occasional missteps in communication. Several reviews recount experiences where expectations were not met, requests were not promptly addressed, or rules and policies appeared inconsistently enforced. In a setting designed for family gatherings, unclear guidelines or perceived rigidity about gatherings can color the overall experience negatively. These tensions are not universal, but they are recurring enough to warrant caution: they remind potential bookers that the success of a stay may hinge on proactive, direct coordination with the management team well before arrival.

When the pros align with the right mindset, the positives can offset the cons effectively. A well-equipped, spacious retreat supports large groups with minimal friction, enabling families to carve out their own rhythm without feeling cramped or rushed. The home-away-from-home feel, complete with thoughtful extras and a warm hosting approach when it’s available, can make a big difference in the overall satisfaction. For those who can tolerate occasional service gaps, the payoff is a comfortable, value-conscious base from which to explore the surrounding Montana outdoors and local attractions.

The bottom-line guidance is practical and clear: Sojourner Cottage is a solid, value-driven option for families or friend groups that want significant space, a functional kitchen, and the flexibility to manage their own schedule. Its appeal is strongest for guests who can navigate varying levels of service with clear expectations and solid planning. If reliability and uninterrupted, proactive guest support are non-negotiable, consider alternatives with proven, consistent management. For those who can pair independence with the comfort of a large, well-equipped home, Sojourner Cottage offers a practical, appealing gateway to a Montana stay.

Hospitals

• Beartooth Billings Clinic (0.1 miles)
• Memorial Hospital Association (0.1 miles)
• Red Lodge Clinic (1.7 miles)
• Cedar Wood Villa (1.7 miles)
• Beartooth Hospital and Health Center (2.4 miles)
• Absarokee Medical Clinic (23.5 miles)

Places of Worship

• Southern Baptist Convention (0.6 miles)
• Church Of The Rockies Rl (0.6 miles)
• Hope Chapel Four Square Church (0.9 miles)
• Calvary Episcopal Church (1.7 miles)
• Saint Agnes Church (1.7 miles)
• Roberts United Methodist Church (10.9 miles)
• Church Of The Rockies Roberts (11 miles)

Restaurants

• Sam's Tap Room & Kitchen (0.6 miles)
• Red Lodge Mountain Resort (0.9 miles)
• Red Lodge Ales (1.3 miles)
• Sam's Tap Room (1.3 miles)
• Mas Taco (1.5 miles)
• Hardwood Smoke House (1.6 miles)
• Ox Pasture (1.7 miles)

Parks

• Coal Miners Memorial Park (1 miles)
• Lyons Park (1.4 miles)
• Double Ditch Dog Park (1.6 miles)
• Cooney Reservoir (16 miles)
• Joliet City Park (23 miles)

Cafes

• City Brew Coffee (1.3 miles)
• Caffe La Vida (1.5 miles)
• The Wild Table (1.6 miles)
• Phoenix Pearl Tea (1.6 miles)
• Roberts Cafe (10.9 miles)
• Perkatory (17 miles)
• Fishtail Grind (21 miles)

Pharmacies

• Red Lodge Drug Store (1.5 miles)
• Iga (1.5 miles)

Transportation

• Red Lodge Airport (1.7 miles)
• Red Lodge Tour & Taxi (1.8 miles)
• U-Haul Moving & Storage (17.1 miles)
• Coleman's Taxidermy (23.6 miles)

Physicians

• St Vincent Healthcare (2.3 miles)
• Riverstone Health (23.3 miles)