Haycreek Apartments

Pros

• The town houses are quite lovely.
• The apartments are quiet, clean and secure, and have recently been updated.
• The place is great to live in.
• The property is always well lit with a cozy look from the sidewalk.
• Residents note positive experiences and praise the management for show?ing concern that is above and beyond.

Cons

• Not a good place to be.
• Horrible place.
• Bad service.
• The doors have to be locked from the outside, and only management has keys, raising security concerns.
• The resident returned home to a door locked with keys inside and later found the apartment vandalized.
• The apartment was vandalized: drawers emptied, food and supplies missing, and various items scattered or stolen.
• Electronics and appliances were damaged or stolen (thermostat, oven burners, antenna, power cords cut, etc.).
• The rent is not worth the dwelling; it felt like a prison and kids couldn't play outside.
• The pet policy discriminates between seniors and younger adults; management enters without 24-hour notice and tenants feel treated horribly.
• Worst management ever - the vehicle was towed from the lot.

Review

The place described by residents runs the gamut from glowing praise to severe criticism, creating a kaleidoscope of opinions about what it's really like to live here. Some reviewers paint a picture of a well-kept, comfortable community: quiet, clean, secure, with updates to apartments and a streetside ambiance that feels inviting when you view it from the sidewalk. Others, however, see it as a far less hospitable environment, where safety worries, restrictive rules, and questionable management sour the experience. The contrasts aren't small - the spectrum runs from "great place" to "not a good place to be," with a number of in-between shades that reflect real, lived experiences.

In one harrowing narrative, a resident recounts falling seriously ill while already in a precarious health situation, only to face a cascade of security headaches that compounds the stress. The person describes battling Covid and pneumonia, requiring ER visits and hospital admissions as organs started to fail. Each time they returned home, doors were locked and keys were inside, with the unsettling detail that doors have to be locked from the outside and that only management appears to hold the keys. The situation worsened when, after a 3 a.m. hospital visit, "the 2 fliers with the lockout # gone," and on another occasion the door was unlocked as the tenant left but the apartment had been vandalized. Inside, belongings were tossed and stolen: dressers emptied, a heavy bag of cat food and litter scattered, the thermostat and various cords and electronics vanished, a blanket disappeared to leave the resident cold, and even a new bag of chocolate almonds went missing. The account closes with the suggestion that even during an attempt to rest and recover, the vulnerability persisted, underscoring a fearsome lack of security during what should have been a period of healing.

A separate, more schematic line of praise notes that the townhouses themselves are quite lovely and that the overall environment can feel comfortable - an impression reinforced by a reviewer who adds that the townhouses are private without being austere, and that the complex feels "quiet, clean and secure." Another quick snapshot emphasizes curb appeal and familiarity: it is "always well lit with a cozy look from the sidewalk," a small detail that contributes a sense of welcome from the outside and a degree of reassurance about the area's nighttime ambiance.

Yet the picture is far from uniform. A long critique focuses on cost, restrictions, and a perceived mismatch between price and experience. The reviewer argues that "max rent isn't worth the dwelling" and characterizes the place as more prison-like than a home. They describe a series of prohibitions and inconveniences: kids restricted to backyards, no skates, rollerblades, or bikes; fines for sticks or rocks in the yard and for trash that allegedly never got broken; the impossibility of working on vehicles with cars requiring relocation two blocks away daily in winter; and what they describe as "special privileges" enjoyed by management. The pet policy is accused of discriminating between seniors and younger adults, and there are reports of management entering units without a 24-hour notice while attempting to manage every facet of residents' lives. The sentiment is stark: after moving in, the person felt deeply disappointed and still voices a strong wish to leave Haycreek.

Counterbalancing that negative view is a more positive stream from another reviewer who claims that, so far, the property has earned "all thumbs up" and that every visit has been a positive experience - even when the reviewer's mood wasn't the best. They highlight the care and concern shown by staff and management, describing the quality of service as "above and beyond measure." It's a distinctly different tone from the previous assessment, suggesting that interactions with staff and the way residents are treated can dramatically alter the overall impression of living there.

In another notable observation, a casual note underscores the practical and aesthetic aspects of the property: the complex is described as well lit, with a cozy, inviting appearance from the curbside. This comment aligns with the other pleasant cues about safety and comfort in the public-facing spaces, implying that the exterior presentation can be a strong selling point even if concerns exist inside. The emphasis on lighting and curb appeal provides a tangible counterweight to the more troubling accounts of security breaches or heavy-handed management.

Perhaps the most starkly negative episode centers on a single incomplete but telling incident: a resident recounts visiting a friend, parking in the complex's lot, and when leaving, discovering that their truck would not start. After retrieving tools by taxi, the resident returns an hour later only to find the vehicle towed to an impound - an experience framed as an example of "Worst management ever." The story captures a pattern of experiences that feel cold, impersonal, and punitive, illustrating how management decisions and policies can seriously disrupt daily life and cause lasting frustration.

Taken together, these accounts sketch a property that can offer comfort, security, and a sense of well-being to some residents while presenting significant challenges to others. The positive remarks about cleanliness, updated interiors, ample lighting, and courteous, responsive staff contrast sharply with troubling tales of door lockouts, vandalism, and invasive, punitive policies. The lay of the land is complicated by inconsistent experiences with management - some days appreciated for kindness and helpfulness, other days criticized for their rigidity and the perception of overreach. The resulting impression is of a place that can be comfortable and attractive in its design and public-facing aspects, yet simultaneously fraught with safety concerns and governance questions that leave residents feeling exposed, uncertain, and divided about whether it truly meets their needs.

This part of Menominee, Michigan offers a convenient and well-rounded community for seniors. With several restaurants within close proximity, such as A&W Restaurant and Watermark Restaurant and Bakery, residents have a variety of dining options to choose from. Additionally, there are multiple places of worship nearby for spiritual support and community engagement. The area also features several parks like John Henes Park and Veterans' Memorial Park, providing opportunities for outdoor recreation and relaxation. For healthcare needs, there are hospitals like US Veterans Medical Center and pharmacies such as CVS Pharmacy in the vicinity. Transportation services like M & M Taxi Service are readily available for easy mobility. Overall, this part of Menominee provides a mix of amenities essential for senior living in a peaceful and accessible setting.

Restaurants

• A&W Restaurant (0.2 miles)
• Watermark Restaurant and Bakery (0.7 miles)
• Perkins Restaurant and Bakery (0.9 miles)
• Thai Express (0.9 miles)
• Chang's Buffet (1.1 miles)
• Jozwiak's Bar & Grill (1.4 miles)
• Col K's Pasty Shop (1.7 miles)

Cafes

• 35th & Coffee (0.3 miles)
• Zinger Coffee & Tea (3.6 miles)

Places of Worship

• Lakeside Assembly of God (0.6 miles)
• Menominee Church of God (0.6 miles)
• Resurrection Catholic Church (0.7 miles)
• North Shore Baptist Church (0.8 miles)
• Seventh-Day Adventist Church (1.4 miles)
• Christ Evangelical Lutheran Church (1.8 miles)
• Holy Spirit (1.8 miles)

Parks

• John Henes Park (0.8 miles)
• Veterans' Memorial Park (1.7 miles)
• Stephenson Island (2.4 miles)
• Mason Park (2.6 miles)
• Higley Field (3 miles)
• Red Arrow Park (3.4 miles)
• Seagull Bar State Natural Area (4.1 miles)

Transportation

• Enstrom Helicopter (1.2 miles)
• M & M Taxi Service (1.8 miles)
• U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer (3.2 miles)
• Taxi (3.5 miles)

Hospitals

• US Veterans Medical Center (1.7 miles)
• Menominee Medical Clinic (1.7 miles)
• Bay Area Medical Center (4.3 miles)
• Bay Area Orthopaedic Consultants (4.3 miles)
• Bellin Health NorthReach OB/GYN (4.3 miles)

Pharmacies

• CVS Pharmacy (1.7 miles)
• Walgreens (2.7 miles)

Physicians

• Dr. Peter J. Kurtz Optometrist (2 miles)
• Valenta Dental (2.6 miles)
• Adapt Clinic (2.7 miles)
• John P Briody (3.1 miles)
• Wisconsin Michigan Physicians (3.4 miles)
• Insight Vision Center (3.8 miles)
• Bay Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery (3.9 miles)