3297 State Road 580, Safety Harbor, FL 34695
For more information about senior living options: (866) 208-4318
Overall Review of Evergreen Manor Retirement Home
Pros
Evergreen Manor is a caring place where the staff take great care of residents.- Montice is fabulous and runs a tight ship.
- Residents are treated as individuals, not just numbers.
- The staff are a blessing and lead with love of Jesus for everyone.
- Evergreen Manor offers fair pricing with attentive care.
- The facility feels home-like and cozy, with a warm, attentive staff.
- The meals are tasty, and the chef is dedicated to making meals delicious and adjustable as needed.
- Residents have their own separate rooms and can enjoy walks outside.
Cons
The reviewer notes that moving their uncle from ALF to ALF resulted in negative results and even dangerous neglect.
Review
Evergreen Manor Retirement Home in Safety Harbor is best suited for families seeking a warm, intimate, home-like setting where seniors receive daily care, close supervision, and genuine, caring relationships with staff. The environment is driven by attentive leadership, and caregivers are described as not treating residents as numbers but as members of an Evergreen family. Montice, who runs the operation, is repeatedly praised for keeping a tight, well-organized program while ensuring personal attention. The community seems to excel at end-of-life and frail-elder care, with families reporting strong communication, consistent updates, and a culture of respect and kindness. For families facing the emotional task of selecting a home with sensitive care needs, Evergreen stands out as a trusted option.
However, Evergreen Manor may not be the first choice for every situation. For residents requiring advanced medical oversight, complex rehabilitative therapies, or broad programming on a large campus, alternatives with wider clinical capacity may be more appropriate. Similarly, families seeking a secular or more programmatic environment with a wider selection of activities or more formal medical teams might prefer other facilities. The faith-forward, family-centric culture described in reviews can be a strength for many, but it may not align with every resident’s preferences. In short, Evergreen shines in personalized, compassionate care; those prioritizing scale, diversity of services, or secular programming may want to consider other options.
Key advantages center on intimate, attentive care. Reviews emphasize that staff are genuinely caring, with Montice leading a tightly run operation where communication with families is constant and specific about each resident’s needs. Residents have their own rooms, and the setting feels like a home rather than a clinical unit. The culinary team is praised for tasty meals and menu adjustments, which supports daily nutrition and satisfaction. The environment includes opportunities for outdoor excursions and regular engagement in activities, reinforcing a sense of belonging. These elements create a dependable, reassuring framework: the main pro, personalized attention, acts as a powerful offset to concerns about neglect or impersonal treatment that plague larger facilities.
Another strong point is the blend of warmth and professionalism. The staff’s responsiveness and availability to answer questions day-to-day create a reliable support system for families and residents alike. The atmosphere is described as cozy, with residents treated as part of a family rather than as mere occupants. Cleanliness and respect are recurring notes, reinforcing trust that care is consistent and dignified. The home's structure supports residents with separate rooms that preserve privacy while enabling small-group interactions and shared experiences. The emphasis on engaging residents, through walks, social activities, and a menu that adapts to preferences, helps mitigate the risk of isolation and boredom, common complaints in more institutional settings. In practice, these strengths convert into steady, dependable care that families value.
Even with these strengths, the decision hinges on the trade-offs of scale and medical depth. Evergreen’s smaller footprint means fewer on-site specialists and a potentially narrower range of high-intensity services than larger senior-care campuses. Yet, the reviews indicate that the intimate team compensates for that gap: constant communication, proactive oversight, and a genuine commitment to residents’ daily lives reduce the likelihood of neglect and create a sense of security for families. Fair pricing and transparent conversations about each loved one’s situation further offset financial and care anxieties. For end-of-life or short-stay transition scenarios, Evergreen’s model often yields superior peace of mind compared with facilities that rely on impersonal systems.
Bottom line: Evergreen Manor Residential Community in Safety Harbor is a strong fit for families prioritizing warmth, personalized attention, and a home-like daily rhythm. It serves residents who benefit from close family-style care, clear communication, and reliable day-to-day support from a stable team led by Montice. Those who need robust medical infrastructure, a secular setting, or a broad menu of high-end therapies should evaluate larger or more clinically oriented options. Pros such as empathetic staff, consistent family updates, separate private rooms, delicious meals, and engaging activities are not merely nice extras; they’re rotation-stabilizing advantages that translate into real comfort for residents and relief for caregivers. Prospective families should visit, speak with Montice, review care plans, and confirm alignment with each loved one’s goals.
36 resident community capacity
Assisted Living
Respite Care
Beauty salon
Cable or satellite TV
Dining room
Fully furnished
Garden
Housekeeping services
Kitchenette
Move-in coordination
Outdoor space
Restaurant-style dining
Small library
Telephone
Wi-Fi/high-speed internet available
St. Petersburg-Clearwater International (8 miles away)
24-hour call system
Activities of daily living assistance
Assistance with bathing
Assistance with dressing
Assistance with transfers
Diabetes diet
Medication management
Mental wellness program
Special dietary restrictions
How and When Medicaid May Cover Assisted Living Costs
A Detailed Exploration of Assisted Living Medicaid Waivers Across the United States
Comprehensive Residential Support and Assisted Living Solutions for Individuals with Disabilities