Presbyterian Home Quitman Inc in Quitman, GA

Pros

• The staff have been friendly and helpful with every visit.
• Christy on G unit was a savior, going out of her way to get a package to Granny.
• The staff are very nice and friendly, and the environment is pleasant.
• The staff truly care about residents and treat them like family.
• Rehab and tender loving care helped her become encouraged and begin walking with a walker.
• The staff were wonderful - attentive, professional, and caring, with great communication.
• Stephanie Thomas was very helpful and made transitioning home easy.
• The facility is described as having kind, caring staff who make all patients feel welcome.

Cons

• They removed the 96-year-old father from Presbyterian Home for bad behavior, even though it was later found he had dementia.
• They said he didn't have dementia and didn't start treating it until just before he was kicked out.
• They should have suspected something about his bad behavior.
• Families wasted a year waiting on Presbyterian Home and had to start over after trusting what they were told.
• They didn't even take the time to call, and they gave the room to someone else without courtesy.
• One would think Presbyterian Home Quitman would be more sympathetic and understanding given what their customers are going through.

Review

Presbyterian Home Quitman is best suited for seniors who are navigating rehabilitation or short-term medical recovery and who place a premium on genuinely warm, attentive care from staff. Families that value a welcoming, "treat you like family" atmosphere and tangible acts of kindness will find the daily caregiving feel supportive during a stressful recovery period. It's a solid fit for those who want measurable progress in rehab - such as improved mobility and confidence - driven by hands-on, professional staff in a pleasant, three-section setting. However, this community may not be the right match for households demanding immediate private-room availability or robust, highly structured dementia-specific programming from day one.

Alternatives should be considered for families where time, guarantees, or specialized dementia care are non-negotiable. The most pressing red flags here include inconsistent admissions communication and a slow or opaque wait for a private room, which can strand families for months while their planning hinges on assurances that do not materialize. Also, families dealing with advanced dementia or challenging behavioral needs may want options with clearer policies on behavioral management and earlier, more proactive diagnosis and treatment planning. In short, if certainty, rapid room assignment, or dementia-focused care are essential, look beyond this community.

The strongest positives lie in the human side of care. Reviewers repeatedly highlight friendly, attentive staff who go out of their way to help, from locating a misplaced package to coordinating transitions with tenderness and respect. The environment is described as pleasant, and residents report meaningful engagement with meals, activities, and worship services. Rehab success stories - where a resident begins walking again with support after a hospital stay - underscore the practical value of a caring team that treats recovery as a real, supported process rather than a paperwork exercise. These pros materially offset daily frustrations for many families who need reassurance that their loved one is seen and valued.

Yet the main cons do not disappear simply because the staff shines. The most troubling business-side issue is the lag between visits, inquiries, and actual room availability, sometimes stretching nearly a year and eroding trust. When admissions staff fail to follow through or communicate clearly, families are left frustrated and hesitant to commit, which undermines the overall experience. The case of a resident removed for "bad behavior" (with later indications of a dementia diagnosis) also raises questions about how early cognitive issues are identified and managed, and whether behavior triggers are handled consistently. For some families, these patterns will be a deal-breaker, especially if stability and predictability are priorities.

In practice, the staff's warmth and the rehab outcomes can offset a lot for families who are flexible about logistics and who prioritize compassionate care. The ability to move a loved one from hospital rehab toward independent living, with ongoing monitoring and a transition plan, is a meaningful strength. When those outcomes align with a family's values - empathy, daily attentiveness, and a home-like environment - the default choice tilts toward Presbyterian Home Quitman. However, the offset is not universal. For households facing tight timelines, a need for guaranteed private accommodations, or a requirement for robust dementia care from intake, this community may fall short.

To make a well-informed decision, prospective families should probe admissions policies head-on: what is the current average wait time for a private room, what guarantees exist if delays occur, and who manages room assignments to prevent "lost" filings? Demand a clear dementia-care plan, including how behavioral issues are assessed, diagnosed, and treated, and who oversees transition plans for residents moving from rehab to assisted living. Talk to current residents' families about communication quality and follow-through, and request to speak with the rehab team about realistic recovery timelines. With those guardrails in place, Presbyterian Home Quitman can be a compelling option for those who will value daily kindness and proven rehab momentum over perfect administrative precision.

Restaurants

• Burger King (0.5 miles)
• CJ's BBQ (1.1 miles)
• The Sister S Place (1.2 miles)
• Royal Cafe of Quitman (1.3 miles)
• The New Royal Cafe (1.3 miles)
• 3 Nelson's Burgers & Wraps (1.5 miles)
• Coyoacan Mexican Restaurant (2 miles)

Pharmacies

• Harveys Supermarkets (0.6 miles)
• Lee & Pickels Drugs (1.3 miles)
• Lee and Pickels Drugstore (1.3 miles)
• Lee and Pickels Drugs - Troupeville (14 miles)
• Walmart Pharmacy (15.7 miles)
• Walgreens (15.8 miles)
• Octapharma Plasma (15.8 miles)

Places of Worship

• Calvary Christian Center (0.6 miles)
• New Life Assembly of God (0.7 miles)
• Dixie Seventh-Day Adventist Church (0.8 miles)
• House of Deliverance & Restoration (0.8 miles)
• Fodie Church of God In Unity (0.9 miles)
• First Baptist Church (0.9 miles)
• Southern Baptist Convention (1 miles)

Parks

• Quitman Historic District (1.2 miles)
• Baseball Field (2.2 miles)

Physicians

• Archbold-Brooks Specialty Clinic (1.3 miles)
• Express Care Medical Clinic (16 miles)

Hospitals

• Brooks County Hospital (1.3 miles)
• South Georgia Medical Center (16.4 miles)
• Smith Northview Hospital (16.4 miles)

Transportation

• Owens Aircraft (9.9 miles)
• U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer (14.1 miles)
• U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer (15.2 miles)
• Five Star Taxi (15.5 miles)

Cafes

• Starbucks (15.4 miles)
• Panera Bread (15.9 miles)

Theaters

• Valdosta Stadium Cinemas 16 (15.9 miles)