Cudahy Commons in Cudahy, WI

Pros

• The complex is well maintained with decent-sized rooms and in-unit laundry.
• The inspector was kind and thorough, explaining things clearly.
• The staff are very helpful and responsive, making residents feel cared for.
• The apartments are clean, with spacious bedrooms and a nice main living area.
• Maintenance is fast, professional, and friendly; Danny and Josh consistently deliver.
• The maintenance team is among the best, with great communication and reliable service.
• Grounds are clean and well-maintained, and amenities like the fitness center and pool are a plus.
• Penny, the property manager, is efficient, professional, and attentive to residents’ needs.
• All in all, the experience at Cudahy Commons is highly recommended and feels like home.

Cons

• The staff are rude and unprofessional and do nothing to resolve neighbor noise problems.
• Management sends eviction-style notices, like a 28‑Day Non-Renewal of Lease, even though rent was paid on time.
• Maintenance neglects repairs (ceiling stains, roof leaks) and never follows through.
• Walls are extremely thin, making neighbor noises and smells easily audible.
• Maintenance requests are ignored or take too long; electrical/outlet issues are not fixed.
• Extra fees and rent fluctuations make the cost higher than advertised, with misleading pricing.
• Security deposits are mishandled or delayed, sometimes not returned as expected.
• The property has safety/cleanliness issues, such as dogs running loose and not being cleaned up after.

Review

Cudahy Commons is best suited for renters who want a practical, service-forward mid‑size community where maintenance responsiveness and on-site staff can make day-to-day living smoother, and who value convenient access to Milwaukee-area routes, amenities, and a pet-friendly environment. The property often shines for tenants who prioritize a straightforward leasing process, quick maintenance fixes, and friendly, professional staff. It is not the right pick for someone chasing absolute quiet, a guaranteed pool, or a perfectly predictable, low-fee price structure every month. For those demanding an unquestioned calm, or a transparent, no-surprises budget from day one, alternatives deserve serious consideration.

On the plus side, the maintenance team earns the strongest praise across reviews. Residents repeatedly highlight Danny, Josh, and the entire maintenance crew for fast, courteous, and effective service, with many work orders completed the same day or the next. In-unit laundry, decent-sized rooms, and practical layouts, plus on-site amenities like a gym and a pool cited in several comments, contribute to a feeling of home. Groundkeeping and overall property upkeep also come through as solid positives, and several tenants credit Penny or Courtney with responsive, courteous administration that helps transactions feel manageable rather than adversarial.

The flip side is substantial and cannot be ignored. A persistent pattern of management inconsistency, occasional rudeness, and slow or non-responsive handling of complaints shows up in a sizable share of reviews. Specific grievances range from noisy neighbors and frequent repairs left unfixed after months, to high and opaque-feeling charges, miscommunications about rent and deposits, and, in some cases, unresolved water leaks or mold concerns. Several comments describe monthly rent that rises or carries added maintenance fees, and a number of experiences include lease actions like non-renewal notices that feel punitive or misaligned with on-time payments. Wall-thinness and noise from neighboring units also recur as a real, ongoing irritant for many residents.

Those pros can offset the cons only to a degree, and the balance seems highly dependent on the management regime in place at any given time. A thread of improvement runs through several accounts: after ownership changes, some residents report steadier communication, more consistent maintenance response, and even upgrades to common areas or gym facilities. Yet that progress is not universal, and mixed experiences persist, especially for households that depend on a predictable price structure and reliable, proactive issue resolution. Where the maintenance crew genuinely delivers, the relief is substantial; where office staff falters or policies feel unclear, frustration compounds the noise and the cost concerns.

For practical decision-making, prospective residents should verify a few realities before signing. The location is undeniable for those who commute to the southern Milwaukee suburbs or Bay View, with easy access to highways, parks, and shopping, and several reviews praise the convenience and the feel of a community that can feel like home with careful upkeep. Ask current management about the status of promised amenities (is the pool truly active, what are the clubhouse hours), and obtain a clear breakdown of fees beyond base rent. Inspect the unit for appliances, sound insulation, and any signs of past leaks or pests, and confirm who handles after-hours maintenance. In short, confirm the current management trajectory and be prepared for both responsive service and occasional administrative friction.

The bottom-line verdict: Cudahy Commons can be a solid, workable choice for renters who prize responsive maintenance, a friendly on-site team, and convenient access to major Milwaukee-area corridors, provided tolerance for occasional noise and a willingness to navigate a fee-rich environment. It is less suitable for those needing absolute quiet, a guaranteed pool, or rock-solid price transparency every month. Prospective tenants should engage directly with the current management, tour during multiple hours, and read recent resident experiences to confirm that the property’s trajectory aligns with personal expectations. If those conditions hold, Cudahy Commons offers a practical, relatively reassuring living option with strong maintenance support and a community feel; if not, explore alternatives with more predictable budgets and steadier administrative performance.

Located in Cudahy, Wisconsin, this area offers convenient access to a variety of amenities and services suitable for seniors. With multiple pharmacies nearby such as Walgreens and CVS, residents can easily access their medication needs. There are also several dining options available including The Landing, Papa Luigi's, and Subway. For medical care, hospitals like Aurora St Luke's South Shore and Froedert Drexel Square Clinic are within a short distance. Public transportation is easily accessible with the Milwaukee Mitchell International Airport and the Milwaukee Intermodal Station located nearby. Additionally, there are parks like South Shore Park and cafes like Hawthorne Coffee Roasters in close proximity for leisure activities. Overall, this part of Cudahy provides a well-rounded community with essential amenities for senior living.

Pharmacies

• Walgreens (0.5 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (1.2 miles)
• Walgreens (2.5 miles)
• Walgreens (2.5 miles)
• Target Pharmacy (3.2 miles)
• Walgreens (3.4 miles)
• Walgreens (3.6 miles)

Restaurants

• The Landing (0.6 miles)
• Papa Luigi's (0.8 miles)
• Subway (1.8 miles)
• Culver's (2.3 miles)
• Wendy's (3.1 miles)
• The Vanguard (3.3 miles)
• McDonald's (3.3 miles)

Transportation

• MKE Runway (0.9 miles)
• Concourse D (1.2 miles)
• Concourse C (1.3 miles)
• Security Checkpoint (1.4 miles)
• Milwaukee Mitchell International Airport (MKE) (1.4 miles)
• Delta Ticket Counter (1.4 miles)
• Milwaukee Intermodal Station (6.1 miles)

Hospitals

• Aurora St Luke's South Shore (1.6 miles)
• Froedert Drexel Square Clinic (4.2 miles)
• Aurora St Luke's Medical Center (4.6 miles)
• Aurora Sinai Medical Center (6.8 miles)

Cafes

• Hawthorne Coffee Roasters (2.1 miles)
• Starbucks (3.2 miles)
• Colectivo Coffee (3.8 miles)
• Starbucks (6.8 miles)
• Colectivo Lakefront (7 miles)

Parks

• Runway Dog Exercise Area (2.5 miles)
• South Shore Park (2.9 miles)
• Humboldt Park (3 miles)
• Paliafito Park (5.2 miles)
• Henry Maier Festival Park (5.3 miles)
• Lakeshore State Park (5.9 miles)
• Red Arrow Park (6.5 miles)

Physicians

• Layton Avenue Dermatolgy Clinic (3.9 miles)
• Sports Medicine & Orthopedic Center (4 miles)
• Innovative Pain Care (4.8 miles)
• Aurora Health Care (5.8 miles)
• Greendale Health Center (6.1 miles)

Theaters

• South Shore Cinema Oak Creek, Wi (4 miles)