Cudahy Commons

Pros

• The complex is well maintained.
• The apartments have decent-sized rooms and in-unit laundry.
• The inspection person was kind and thorough.
• The maintenance team is awesome and provides fast, friendly, professional service.
• Danny and Josh are an amazing maintenance team who respond quickly to work orders and communicate well.
• The grounds are clean and well-maintained.
• The property offers a fitness center and a pool, with parking included.
• The friendly staff gave a tour of the property.
• The office staff respond to questions promptly.
• The maintenance crew is the best the reviewer has experienced.
• The common areas are clean and look nice.

Cons

• The office staff never took action on the noise complaints from neighbors and were rude and unprofessional.
• They issued a 28-day notice of non-renewal despite rent being paid on time.
• The brown stain on the ceiling was never fixed and was ignored.
• The management is incompetent and does not handle complaints.
• Maintenance failed to fix issues like the moldy washer and non-working outlets, with one outlet burning a microwave plug.
• The building has very thin walls, letting neighbors' noises and snoring be heard.
• There are extra fees and rent fluctuations that are not clearly disclosed.
• Maintenance requests were not responded to promptly, and security deposits were delayed or misdirected.

Review

Residents describe a complex with real potential that can feel like a mixed bag, depending on who you talk to and when you talk to them. Taken together, the reviews paint a picture of a property with clean grounds, solid amenities, and friendly maintenance at times, but with management and communication problems that can derail the living experience. Some residents sing the praises of the on-site team, while others recount rudeness, slow responses, and decisions that left them frustrated and dissatisfied. The end result is a property that can feel welcoming on the surface, yet deeply unreliable in important moments.

Noise and neighbor relations stand out as a recurring frustration. Several tenants narrate sleepless nights caused by noise from neighbors in the units below or above, including disturbances at very late hours like 1 a.m. or 2 a.m. In some cases, residents were told by office staff merely to record the times they heard noise or to jot notes, with little follow-through or intervention from management. Other times, the stress is compounded by walls that feel insufficiently soundproof, so even ordinary living - someone snoring or people talking - can become a painful disruption. A few reviews mention cigarette smoke infiltrating units and odors carried through shared walls, further highlighting the challenges of quiet enjoyment in this building.

Management and maintenance emerge as the most divisive elements. A subset of residents describes office staff as rude, unresponsive, and uninterested in addressing complaints about noise or upkeep. One account catalogues repeated failures: a ceiling stain that was never repaired, a roof leak that went unpainted for months, and a continuing sense that "you have to be on top of them" to get anything done. In one particularly sharp note, a resident recalls receiving a "28 Day Notice of Non-Renewal of Lease" despite always paying rent on time, which underscores a perception that administrative decisions and dispute handling can feel punitive or capricious rather than service-oriented. In contrast, other reviews praise individual staff members by name - insisting that certain administrators are responsive, respectful, and helpful - and some tenants remember inspection visits as courteous and thorough. The contrast suggests that experience can vary dramatically from one staff interaction to the next.

Maintenance crews, however, are often singled out as a bright spot in these reviews. Several residents highlight Danny and Josh as exceptionally capable and friendly, noting that they respond quickly to work orders and perform tasks with competence and good communication. The sentiment is echoed in multiple accounts that maintenance visits were punctual, efficient, and effective, with some residents calling the team the best they've encountered. This positive thread helps balance the generally negative mood around management, suggesting that when maintenance staff are on their game, the living experience improves noticeably and preserves credibility even amid broader concerns.

Beyond maintenance and staff demeanor, residents raise concerns about costs, transparency, and policy details. One review points out a clubhouse fee of $20 and limited hours, which some prospective residents might view as inconvenient or excessive. Another common note is the fluctuation in advertised rent versus what people actually pay, due to water, sewer, and trash charges and grounds maintenance costs. For some, these nuggets of cost information would be better communicated up front, as they can affect the perceived value of the unit. Add to that stories about security deposits taking a long time to return and misdirected mailings to the wrong address, and you have a pattern of administrative friction that can undermine otherwise positive impressions.

Nevertheless, not all feedback is negative, and many residents speak with warmth about specific experiences that did go well. A few reviews recount positive interactions with staff during tours, noting clean, well-kept grounds, a sense of care in the common areas, and amenities such as a fitness center and a pool with included parking. Others speak of quick and professional responses to questions or concerns, and several long-term residents describe years without major issues, praising the overall livability when the administrative side cooperates and the neighborhood remains clean and well maintained. In short, the property has many features that can make it a comfortable home if the staff are responsive, consistent, and fair.

In the end, the consensus suggests a property with strong starting assets - well-maintained grounds, decent-sized units with in-unit laundry in some cases, reliable maintenance when it happens, and a generally friendly vibe from several team members. But the on-the-ground experience is highly dependent on interactions with the office and the ability of the management to manage complaints, address repairs promptly, and communicate policies clearly. For prospective residents, the takeaway is clear: the complex can be a solid place to live if you encounter supportive staff, a responsive maintenance crew, and a straightforward, transparent management approach. If your experience hinges on thorough follow-through, timely repairs, and predictable communication, you may want to ask pointed questions about how issues are tracked, how fines or fees are explained, and how non-payment or renewal notices are handled before you sign a lease.

Located in Cudahy, Wisconsin, this area offers convenient access to a variety of amenities and services suitable for seniors. With multiple pharmacies nearby such as Walgreens and CVS, residents can easily access their medication needs. There are also several dining options available including The Landing, Papa Luigi's, and Subway. For medical care, hospitals like Aurora St Luke's South Shore and Froedert Drexel Square Clinic are within a short distance. Public transportation is easily accessible with the Milwaukee Mitchell International Airport and the Milwaukee Intermodal Station located nearby. Additionally, there are parks like South Shore Park and cafes like Hawthorne Coffee Roasters in close proximity for leisure activities. Overall, this part of Cudahy provides a well-rounded community with essential amenities for senior living.

Pharmacies

• Walgreens (0.5 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (1.2 miles)
• Walgreens (2.5 miles)
• Walgreens (2.5 miles)
• Target Pharmacy (3.2 miles)
• Walgreens (3.4 miles)
• Walgreens (3.6 miles)

Restaurants

• The Landing (0.6 miles)
• Papa Luigi's (0.8 miles)
• Subway (1.8 miles)
• Culver's (2.3 miles)
• Wendy's (3.1 miles)
• The Vanguard (3.3 miles)
• McDonald's (3.3 miles)

Transportation

• MKE Runway (0.9 miles)
• Concourse D (1.2 miles)
• Concourse C (1.3 miles)
• Security Checkpoint (1.4 miles)
• Milwaukee Mitchell International Airport (MKE) (1.4 miles)
• Delta Ticket Counter (1.4 miles)
• Milwaukee Intermodal Station (6.1 miles)

Hospitals

• Aurora St Luke's South Shore (1.6 miles)
• Froedert Drexel Square Clinic (4.2 miles)
• Aurora St Luke's Medical Center (4.6 miles)
• Aurora Sinai Medical Center (6.8 miles)

Cafes

• Hawthorne Coffee Roasters (2.1 miles)
• Starbucks (3.2 miles)
• Colectivo Coffee (3.8 miles)
• Starbucks (6.8 miles)
• Colectivo Lakefront (7 miles)

Parks

• Runway Dog Exercise Area (2.5 miles)
• South Shore Park (2.9 miles)
• Humboldt Park (3 miles)
• Paliafito Park (5.2 miles)
• Henry Maier Festival Park (5.3 miles)
• Lakeshore State Park (5.9 miles)
• Red Arrow Park (6.5 miles)

Physicians

• Layton Avenue Dermatolgy Clinic (3.9 miles)
• Sports Medicine & Orthopedic Center (4 miles)
• Innovative Pain Care (4.8 miles)
• Aurora Health Care (5.8 miles)
• Greendale Health Center (6.1 miles)

Theaters

• South Shore Cinema Oak Creek, Wi (4 miles)