The Isles of Collier Preserve in Naples, FL

Pros

• The community features an excellent clubhouse, pool, and pickleball courts.
• It offers beautiful homes, wonderful amenities, and a convenient location near downtown Naples.
• The setting combines water features and nature preserves with resort-style pools and a large fitness center.
• The sales center is described as knowledgeable, helpful, and friendly.
• Residents praise the community for its outstanding amenities, well-planned design, and great location near Old Naples.
• Neighbors are noted as very nice, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere.
• It enables outdoor recreation like kayaking, tennis, and pickleball, with access to a restaurant and marina.

Cons

• Christopher Ligotti was incredibly rude, condescending and ignorant.
• They found the area overpriced, noting Treviso Bay next door is more beautiful and priced lower.
• There was mold behind cabinets and a ongoing leak; Minto was unwilling to review whether it started during construction, which was disappointing.
• The sales group was unwelcoming, cold and dismissive, with questions about bias against a gay couple.
• Prospective buyers were told they must buy a lot first to build, faced long build times (12–16 months, or 3–5 years for lots), and felt baited and switched.
• The HOA’s driveway parking ban was described as absurd and costly, with fines and limited garage space.
• Some villas had noises through the walls and there were community flooding issues, which felt unpleasant given the sales price.

Review

The Isles of Collier Preserve in Naples is best suited for buyers who want a luxury, nature-forward, resort-style lifestyle in a gated setting that is still minutes from downtown. This community leans into water views, expansive preserves, and a clubhouse culture built around social activity and active living. New construction and villas feature contemporary Florida coastal styling, with outdoor living prioritized through screened lanais and extensive landscaping. For families or active adults who prize a turnkey array of amenities, two pools, a fitness center, tennis and pickleball, kayaking and a nearby marina, and who want a location that delivers quiet, walkable access to Fifth Avenue, beaches, and cultural districts, this development makes a compelling case. It is a strong fit for those who value aesthetics, a curated lifestyle calendar, and a setting that feels upscale yet relaxed.

On balance, the strongest positives center on the amenity package and the location. The resort-style clubhouse, multiple pools (including a lap pool), cabanas, and a robust fitness area create a one-stop daily-life experience that reduces the need to travel far for recreation. The on-site restaurant and bar provide convenience for socializing, while the water-centered design, lakes, canals, and a nature preserve, offers enduring curb appeal and a sense of serenity that is hard to match in nearby developments. For those who want a turnkey, social, and visually polished living environment, the Isles delivers, plus a sense that the HOA and staff are attentive, well-intentioned, and supportive. The proximity to downtown Naples and to beaches also means a buyer can enjoy vibrant activities without sacrificing a peaceful residential feel.

Yet several material drawbacks temper the enthusiasm. The sales experience has been uneven enough to spark concerns about fairness and transparency, with reports of dismissive attitudes and experiences that felt more transactional than welcoming. A recurring friction is the build-timing reality: buyers typically face the need to purchase a lot and then endure a lengthy construction window, often 12 to 16 months or more, before a home can be completed. Some were told to explore other markets because no immediate build was available, or to endure a “bait and switch” impression when initial plans did not align with on-the-ground availability. Structural complaints also surface in a troubling minority of homes, mold behind cabinets, leaks, and disputes about whether problems existed at construction, reminding potential buyers that even premium new builds carry latent risk. Couple these with HOA rules that constrain daily life, cars not allowed to park overnight in driveways, small garages, and fines for parking in visible spaces, and the practical cost of ownership grows beyond the sticker price.

Those most likely to want alternatives are buyers who need to move quickly or who operate with tighter budgets. The Isles sits in a premium tier, and price comparisons with nearby communities often reveal meaningful gaps in both cost and timing. For buyers who prize flexibility over polish, or who require larger garages, more forgiving parking policies, or shorter paths to occupancy, the wait-and-watch mentality may not be tenable. The repeated anecdotes about deceptive or opaque timelines create real risk for households coordinating school starts, job moves, or seasonal relocations. In short, the advantages of scenery and lifestyle must be weighed against ongoing uncertainty about when a home will be ready, and whether the price will still align with personal financial plans when the door finally opens.

In this Naples market, Treviso Bay and other nearby developments frequently emerge as practical references for value and timeline. Treviso Bay can offer similar resort-style living with potentially lower price points and more predictable procurement, while other neighbors may provide faster move-in or more generous vehicle accommodations. The Isles’ distinctive emphasis on nature preserves and water-centric design remains a differentiator, but it does not automatically translate into a smoother purchase process or lower risk. For buyers who want to compare, the prudent path includes requesting current release schedules, contract milestones, and contingencies in writing, then validating them with independent inspection and a trusted real estate professional.

The practical verdict favors a clear, disciplined approach. For families and individuals who prioritize a turnkey, amenity-rich lifestyle with a refined, resort-grade setting, Isles of Collier Preserve remains compelling. The bottom line hinges on readiness to tolerate premium pricing, potential build delays, and strict HOA controls, while embracing the lifestyle payoff that comes with a water-rich landscape and proximity to Naples’ core attractions. If those conditions align with the timetable and budget, the Isles can deliver a deeply satisfying living experience with strong social fabric and enduring appeal. If not, or if certainty and immediate occupancy are non-negotiable, a well-chosen alternative nearby will likely offer better peace of mind and faster closure.

This part of Naples, Florida offers a convenient and vibrant area for senior living. With a variety of restaurants nearby such as Culver's, Los Molcajetes Del Valle, and Napoli On The Bay III, seniors can enjoy delicious dining options. In terms of healthcare, there are several physician offices and clinics within close proximity, including Physicians Regional Walkin Clinic and Millennium Physician Group. In case of emergencies or more serious medical needs, residents also have easy access to hospitals like Physicians Regional Medical Center and the NCH Healthcare System. Additionally, there are pharmacies like Misir Pharmacy and Walgreens nearby for medication needs. For recreation and relaxation, parks like Sugden Regional Park and Eagle Lakes Community Park provide opportunities for outdoor activities. Overall, this area is well-equipped to cater to the needs of seniors seeking a comfortable and convenient living environment.

Restaurants

• Culver's (0.2 miles)
• Los Molcajetes Del Valle (2 miles)
• Napoli On The Bay III (2.6 miles)
• Midnight Tavern (2.9 miles)
• Joe's Diner (3 miles)
• Country House East (3.1 miles)
• The Dock At Crayton Cove (3.6 miles)

Physicians

• Physicians Regional Walkin Clinic (0.5 miles)
• Millennium Physician Group (0.7 miles)
• Adam Fueredi (1 miles)
• The Mike Davis Medical Center (2.5 miles)
• Healthcare Network of Southwest Florida (2.6 miles)
• East Naples Medical Center (2.6 miles)
• Naples Diagnostic Imaging Center (2.6 miles)

Pharmacies

• Misir Pharmacy (0.6 miles)
• Walgreens (1 miles)
• Walmart Pharmacy (1.9 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (2.4 miles)
• Walgreens (2.8 miles)
• Walgreens (4 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (4 miles)

Places of Worship

• St Peter the Apostle Catholic Church (0.6 miles)
• St Ann Catholic Church (4.1 miles)

Hospitals

• ARA Naples South Dialysis Center (1.1 miles)
• Physicians Regional Medical Center (3.6 miles)
• NCH Healthcare System (4.1 miles)
• Naples Community Hospital (4.6 miles)

Parks

• Sugden Regional Park (1.1 miles)
• Eagle Lakes Community Park (2.6 miles)
• Baker Park (4.1 miles)
• Golden Gate Community Park (4.9 miles)
• Gordon River Greenway (5 miles)

Cafes

• Starbucks (2.1 miles)
• Three60 Market (2.2 miles)
• Panera Bread (3.8 miles)
• EJ's Bayfront Cafe (3.9 miles)
• Bad Ass Coffee (3.9 miles)
• Starbucks (3.9 miles)
• Third Street South (3.9 miles)

Transportation

• Naples Municipal Airport (APF) (3.6 miles)
• Naples Jet Center (4.2 miles)