Scottish Towers II Apartments in Dunedin, FL

Pros

• The staff at Scottish Towers are incredibly friendly and helpful.
• The maintenance team shows up quickly and fixes issues professionally.
• The grounds are immaculate and well kept.
• The pier and waterfront setting offer beautiful sunsets and scenic views.
• The clubhouse is welcoming and the community feels friendly and engaging.
• The pool area is well maintained and a highlight of the property.
• The office staff consistently provides excellent service and problem solving.
• The property feels safe and has a strong sense of community.
• The amenities, including grills, boating access, and the walking/biking areas, enhance the living experience.

Cons

• They would not return to the property due to filth and rats.
• They describe the property as absolutely disgusting and say it should do better.
• They would never recommend this place to a senior or anyone else.
• They allege a bait-and-switch regarding advertised appliances like dishwashers and microwaves.
• They consider the property overpriced for what it offers, with horrible office staff.
• They warn non-smokers not to rent there because of pervasive cigarette smoke.
• They say maintenance can enter the apartment without notice, making residents feel unsafe.
• They claim tenants can be evicted for complaining about maintenance issues.

Review

Scottish Towers II Apartments in Dunedin is best suited for active, water-loving seniors who want a welcoming, social footprint near the waterfront and who rely on responsive, hands-on on-site staff. The community sits on the Gulf-access side of Dunedin, with a pier, a heated pool, scenic sunsets, and ready access to kayaking, fishing, and a promenade of nearby shops and eateries. Residents repeatedly describe a vibe of belonging and ease: great grounds maintenance, a busy clubhouse, and a calendar of activities that give daily life shape beyond merely renting an apartment. For someone who prizes a scenic, resort-like setting and values dependable maintenance support that keeps everyday living smooth, Scottish Towers II is a strong match. The combination of waterfront views, walkable amenities, and a staff that frequently earns praise makes this property a practical, decision-ready option for long-term residents who want to feel cared for and connected.

Those who should consider alternatives are clear enough in the mix of reviews. Prospective renters who crave absolute quiet, a spotless pest-free environment from day one, or a strictly predictable lease experience may find fault lines here. Multiple reviewers mention a rat sighting near the back of the building, and others flag ongoing concerns about cleanliness and odor from smoking zones, issues that can color daily living if a home must be pristine and smoke-free. A minority of reviews allege managerial rigidity or negative experiences with office staff, including claims of hostile or dismissive interactions, which helps explain why some long-tenured residents still love the place but others strongly caution new arrivals about the management dynamic. Also, a few readers point to discrepancies between marketing promises and actual unit features (appliances, updates), and to occasional pricing shifts that feel heavy for some tenants. Families weighing alternatives will want to verify current policies on appliances, smoking, and lease terms, and to shadow the management culture during a trial stay or initial weeks.

The strongest positives, location, community, and maintenance responsiveness, offset many notable drawbacks, but not all. The staff is repeatedly described as accessible, courteous, and capable: front-office anchors Diane, Linda, and Karly are cited for clarity and helpfulness, while maintenance pros like Terry, Billy, Chad, and the grounds crew, Holly and Rick among them, delivering timely fixes, clean common areas, and proactive maintenance. The grounds themselves are a magnet: a clean, park-like campus with a dock, pool, barbecue nooks, and a habit of thoughtful upgrades, from new grills and the pier area to improved landscaping and club amenities. This operational excellence, the speed of response to work orders, the willingness to walk residents through facilities, and the visible pride in common spaces, creates real value, particularly for those who want to avoid the hassles of apartment life and focus on enjoying the water-facing lifestyle. When issues do arise, the experience of a responsive crew and a proactive management team tends to make life smoother and more predictable than in other settings.

Yet, certain cons do persist with enough frequency to warrant a disciplined decision framework. The most concrete red flags center on cleanliness and pests, with the rat incident and occasional complaints about odor around designated smoking areas. For non-smokers or those sensitive to indoor air, this can be a material drawback, especially if access to a truly smoke-free living environment is a non-negotiable. Maintenance and vendor conduct also surface in a minority of reviews, occasional intrusions into apartments, concerns about inconsistent communication, and stories of friction with some office staff. The most cautionary notes concern the balance between a warm, community-centric operation and a risk of feeling pressured or limited when raising concerns. In other words: the strengths live loudly, the sunsets, the dock, the responsive team, the activities, while the risks live in the gaps between residents’ expectations for a perfect, uniformly problem-free living experience.

To decide with confidence, prospective residents should map personal priorities to the realities on the ground. If waterfront living, a robust social calendar, and consistently strong amenity upkeep matter most, Scottish Towers II presents a compelling case. The hallmark is a hands-on staff that makes move-in, daily maintenance, and leisure activities feel seamless, with a sense of “home-life” culture reinforced by visible pride in the grounds and common spaces. If, however, the priority is a pristine, ultra quiet, smoke-free corridor with zero tolerance for any management friction, or if a tight, predictable lease-and-price narrative is essential, it is prudent to compare other Dunedin options where the trade-offs skew toward more formalized policies and fewer reports of occasional vendor-related tension. The review set also suggests verifying the exact appliance package on each unit, confirming current smoking policies, and gauging personal tolerance for occasional after-hours service calls and the frequency of required building improvements.

The practical takeaway is clear: for a senior who wants to live on the water, engage in regular social activities, and rely on a maintenance team that shows up quickly and treats residents like family, Scottish Towers II is a well-grounded, high-value option. The blend of picturesque setting, dockside living, and a reputation for responsive care makes it worthy of strong consideration, especially when tours confirm the degree of resident-to-staff warmth and the tangible quality of the grounds and clubhouse. At the same time, this is not the pick for someone seeking a frictionless, perfect-for-everyone experience with zero caveats. Prospective movers should confront realism head-on: speak with multiple residents about the service culture, inspect recent renovation and pest-control updates, and confirm the precise appliance lineup and rent trajectory before signing. When these checks align with personal expectations, Scottish Towers II becomes a practical, durable home rather than a temporary retreat.

This area of Dunedin, Florida, offers a variety of dining options ranging from casual bar and grill fare at Frenchy�s Outpost Bar & Grill to fast food options like McDonald's. Additionally, there are several pharmacies nearby such as Walgreens and CVS Pharmacy for convenient access to medications and health needs. The neighborhood features several parks including Stirling Park for outdoor recreation and relaxation. Medical care is easily accessible with facilities like North Pinellas Surgery Center and Virginia Street Dermatology in close proximity. For leisure activities, there are cafes like Starbucks for socializing over coffee and the AMC Woodlands Square 20 theater for entertainment. Hospitals in the area include Mease Countryside Hospital for any healthcare needs. Overall, this part of Dunedin provides a well-rounded environment with amenities that cater to the needs of seniors looking to settle in the area.

Restaurants

• Frenchy’s Outpost Bar & Grill (0.1 miles)
• Dunedin Brewery (2.7 miles)
• Our Place (2.7 miles)
• McDonald's (2.7 miles)
• Dunedin House of Beer (2.7 miles)
• McDonald's (2.7 miles)
• Hog Island Fish Camp (2.7 miles)

Pharmacies

• Walgreens (0.2 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (1.4 miles)
• Winn-Dixie (1.6 miles)
• Winn-Dixie (2.4 miles)
• Walgreens (2.6 miles)
• Walgreens (2.6 miles)
• CVS Pharmacy (2.7 miles)

Parks

• Stirling Park (0.7 miles)
• Canal Park (4.7 miles)
• Anclote Key Preserve State Park (6.7 miles)
• Kapok Park (6.8 miles)
• Sand Key Park (7 miles)
• Cooper Bayou Park (7.2 miles)
• McMullen Booth Tennis Center Clearwater FL (7.3 miles)

Physicians

• North Pinellas Surgery Center (2.4 miles)
• Virginia Street Dermatology (2.8 miles)
• Dunedin Pediatrics (3.3 miles)
• Advanced Gastroenterology Associates (3.3 miles)
• The Reproductive Medicine Group (4.6 miles)
• Rose Radiology-Boot Ranch (4.7 miles)
• Florida Department of Health, Pinellas County Health Department, Clearwater Center (5.8 miles)

Cafes

• Starbucks (2.8 miles)
• Starbucks (3.9 miles)
• Starbucks (6.4 miles)
• Starbucks (7 miles)

Hospitals

• Mease Countryside Hospital (4.7 miles)
• Mease Countryside Hospital-Medical Arts Building (4.7 miles)
• AdventHealth North Pinellas (5.8 miles)
• Morgan Heart Hospital (7 miles)
• Morton Plant Hospital (7 miles)

Theaters

• AMC Woodlands Square 20 (5 miles)